Ever get that weirdly specific feeling of nostalgia for 2017? It was a strange year for movies. We were right in the middle of the "YA" boom—though maybe toward the tail end of its peak—and Ry Russo-Young’s adaptation of Lauren Oliver’s novel hit theaters with a premise that felt like Groundhog Day meets Mean Girls. Looking back at the before i fall cast today, it’s actually kind of wild to see where everyone landed. Some became indie darlings, others joined the DC Universe, and one or two basically defined the "teen scream" genre for the next five years.
The movie deals with Sam Kingston, a girl who has everything until she dies in a car crash. Then she wakes up. Then she dies again. It’s a loop. But the reason it worked wasn't just the "time loop" gimmick; it was the chemistry of the core four girls. They felt like real high schoolers—meaning they were occasionally terrible people.
Zoey Deutch: The Anchor of the Before I Fall Cast
Zoey Deutch is one of those actors who feels like she’s been around forever because she has a certain "old Hollywood" energy, but she was only in her early twenties when she took on the role of Samantha Kingston. Honestly, without her, this movie might have fallen flat. Sam is a difficult character to like initially. She’s part of the "popular" clique that relentlessly bullies a girl named Juliet Sykes.
Deutch had to play the same day over and over, but with subtle shifts in her emotional state. One day she’s confused, the next she’s reckless, the next she’s grieving. It’s a massive acting challenge. Since 2017, she’s become a powerhouse. You’ve probably seen her in The Politician or the Netflix rom-com Set It Up. She has this knack for playing "sharp-tongued but vulnerable" better than almost anyone in her generation.
Interestingly, her casting was a bit of a legacy move—she’s the daughter of Lea Thompson (from Back to the Future) and director Howard Deutch. But she’s long since moved out of that shadow. In Before I Fall, she managed to make a character who participates in bullying feel like someone worth saving, which is no small feat for a screenplay.
💡 You might also like: The Joy Luck Club 2: Why the Sequel Is Finally Happening and What It Means
The Mean Girls: Halston Sage and the Social Hierarchy
You can't talk about the before i fall cast without mentioning Halston Sage. She played Lindsay Edgecomb, the "queen bee" and Sam’s best friend. In most movies, the mean girl is just a cardboard cutout. Lindsay, however, is a mess. She’s drinking while driving, dealing with her parents' divorce, and masking her insecurity with pure aggression.
Sage was already a bit of a veteran by then, having appeared in Paper Towns and Neighbors. She brought a certain jaggedness to Lindsay. You hated her, but by the third or fourth "loop," you started to realize she was just another scared kid. This wasn't some Disney Channel version of high school. It was darker.
Then you have Cynthy Wu as Ally and Medalion Rahimi as Elody. They filled out the group. Rahimi, in particular, has gone on to have a massive career in television, specifically NCIS: Los Angeles. In the film, their friendship is the catalyst for everything. The "cupid day" roses, the parties, the late-night drives—it captures that suffocating, exhilarating feeling of being seventeen and thinking your friends are the only people who will ever matter.
Logan Miller and the "Nice Guy" Subversion
Kent McFuller, played by Logan Miller, is the guy who has a crush on Sam since they were kids. In any other movie, he’s the "reward" at the end of the story. While Before I Fall keeps some of that trope, Miller plays it with a bit more grit. He’s the host of the party where everything goes wrong.
Miller is one of those "Oh, I know that guy" actors. He was in Love, Simon, The Walking Dead, and those Escape Room movies. He specializes in playing the guy who is slightly overwhelmed by his circumstances. In the context of the before i fall cast, he provides the moral compass. He’s the one who reminds Sam that she wasn't always the person she became in high school.
Elena Kampouris as Juliet Sykes: The Heart of the Tragedy
If Zoey Deutch is the engine of the movie, Elena Kampouris is the soul. She plays Juliet, the girl the popular clique targets. Her performance is haunting. Most of her scenes involve her being pushed to the brink, and she plays it with a raw, uncomfortably realistic intensity.
Kampouris later starred in Jupiter’s Legacy on Netflix. Her role in Before I Fall is actually a masterclass in how to play a character who has mostly given up. The way the movie uses the time loop to let Sam actually see Juliet as a human being instead of a target is where the real emotional weight lies. It’s a stark reminder of how high school hierarchies can literally destroy lives.
📖 Related: Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom Explained (Simply): Why It’s the Weirdest Prequel Ever
Why This Specific Cast Worked
There is a version of this movie that stars four TikTok influencers and feels completely hollow. We see that happen a lot lately. But the before i fall cast was comprised of actual, trained actors who were looking to prove something. They weren't just "playing" teenagers; they were tapping into the specific anxiety of that age.
- Vulnerability: Even the "mean" characters had moments of total breakdown.
- Naturalism: The dialogue felt improvised in spots, especially the banter in the car.
- Chemistry: You believed these four girls had known each other since elementary school.
The film was shot in British Columbia, and the gloomy, rainy atmosphere of the Pacific Northwest acted like a fifth cast member. It mirrored the "stuck" feeling Sam was experiencing. When you pair that atmosphere with the performances of people like Kian Lawley (who played Sam's boyfriend Rob), the whole thing feels incredibly cohesive. Lawley, who started as a YouTuber, actually surprised a lot of critics here. He played the "jerk boyfriend" role without making him a cartoon villain—he was just a typical, self-absorbed teenager.
The Adults in the Room: Jennifer Beals
It’s easy to forget that Jennifer Beals (yes, Flashdance herself) played Sam’s mom. It’s a relatively small role, but it’s pivotal. As Sam relives her final day, her relationship with her mother changes. She goes from being an annoyed teenager who can't wait to leave the house to a daughter who is desperate for one last meaningful conversation. Beals brings a grounded, warm presence that contrasts with the high-octane drama of the high school scenes.
Where Are They Now?
If you look at the before i fall cast today, they’ve largely avoided the "teen star" curse.
- Zoey Deutch is a bonafide lead actress in both indie films and major streaming hits.
- Halston Sage has stayed busy in TV, including a lead role in Prodigal Son.
- Medalion Rahimi became a staple of procedural drama.
- Logan Miller is a consistent face in the horror and thriller genres.
They all used this movie as a springboard. It wasn't just a paycheck; it was a showcase.
Misconceptions About the Film’s Legacy
Some people dismiss Before I Fall as just another "teen girl movie." That’s a mistake. It’s actually a pretty cynical look at social dynamics. The ending—which we won't spoil here for the three people who haven't seen it—is famously divisive. It’s not a "happily ever after" in the traditional sense. It’s a "this is the only way to break the cycle" kind of ending.
The cast had to sell that ending. If the audience didn't believe Sam’s transformation, the finale would feel unearned. Because the before i fall cast committed to the darker elements of the script, the movie has aged much better than other YA adaptations from that same era (looking at you, Divergent sequels).
Actionable Insights for Fans and New Viewers
If you're revisiting the movie or watching it for the first time because you’re a fan of the actors, pay attention to the background details in the early loops. The cast does a lot of non-verbal acting that only makes sense once you know where the story is going.
- Watch for the shift in Lindsay's eyes: Halston Sage plays the "tough girl" early on, but notice how she reacts when Sam starts acting "out of character."
- Look at Juliet's placement: Elena Kampouris is often in the background of scenes before her character "officially" enters the plot for that day.
- Notice the lighting change: As Sam becomes a better person, the way the camera interacts with the cast shifts from cold blues to warmer tones.
Whether you're here for the "Reliving the same day" trope or you're just tracking the career of Zoey Deutch, the before i fall cast delivered a performance that holds up. They took a concept that could have been cheesy and made it feel like a genuine, heartbreaking exploration of what it means to be a "good person" when nobody is looking.
🔗 Read more: Where to Find The Iron Giant Streaming and Why It Keeps Shifting Platforms
If you want to dive deeper into the genre, check out the original novel by Lauren Oliver. It provides a bit more internal monologue that explains why the characters in the movie make the choices they do. Also, keep an eye on Ry Russo-Young’s directing work; she has a specific way of filming young women that avoids the "male gaze" and focuses on the actual friendship—messiness and all.