Honestly, if you ask a casual fan about Jason Todd, they usually point to the 2010 animated movie. It’s great. Don't get me wrong. But if you haven't actually sat down with the Batman Under the Red Hood book—specifically the collected trade paperback written by Judd Winick—you’re basically only getting half the emotional damage.
It’s messy. It’s violent.
Back in 2005, DC Comics did the unthinkable by bringing back the "dead" Robin. At the time, this was heresy. There was a literal rule in comics: nobody stays dead except Bucky Barnes, Uncle Ben, and Jason Todd. Then Winick came along and smashed that rule with a crowbar. See what I did there? Too soon?
What Actually Happens in the Batman Under the Red Hood Book
The plot kicks off with a new player in Gotham. This guy isn't your typical theatrical rogue with a gimmick based on umbrellas or riddles. He’s efficient. He’s wearing the Red Hood—the Joker’s old alias—and he’s systematically taking over the drug trade from Black Mask. He isn't trying to destroy the city; he's trying to control its vices.
Batman is naturally losing his mind trying to figure out who this guy is. The mystery isn't just a "whodunnit" for the reader, because most of us knew it was Jason Todd by issue three. The real tension comes from watching Bruce Wayne slowly realize that his greatest failure didn't stay buried in Ethiopia.
The Infinite Crisis Connection
One thing people often forget about the Batman Under the Red Hood book is how Jason actually came back. In the movie, they hand-wave it with a Ra's al Ghul Lazarus Pit explanation. In the original comics, it’s much weirder and, frankly, more controversial.
✨ Don't miss: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
Superboy-Prime, trapped in a "paradise dimension," got angry and punched the walls of reality. Literally. This "reality punch" rippled through time and changed history. One of those changes was Jason Todd waking up in his own coffin and clawing his way out of the dirt. It sounds ridiculous when you say it out loud, but in the context of mid-2000s DC editorial, it was a massive status-quo shift. Talia al Ghul eventually finds him, realizes he’s a vegetable because of the brain damage, and shoves him into the Lazarus Pit to restore his mind.
The Pit didn't just heal him. It turned his grief into a focused, burning rage.
Why the Comic Version of Jason Todd is Terrifying
In the movie, Jason feels like a hurt younger brother. In the book, he’s a legitimate tactical nightmare. He spent years traveling the globe, training with the same masters Bruce did. But whereas Bruce learned how to disappear, Jason learned how to kill.
He treats Gotham like a chessboard.
His dynamic with Black Mask is peak dark comedy. Roman Sionis (Black Mask) is a lunatic who loses his temper every five minutes. Jason, as Red Hood, plays him like a fiddle. He blows up Sionis's shipments, kills his top lieutenants, and even sends a head in a duffel bag to a board meeting. It’s gritty. It’s mean-spirited. It’s exactly what Gotham looks like when the "no-kill" rule is thrown out the window.
🔗 Read more: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
The Moral Argument That Never Ends
The heart of the Batman Under the Red Hood book isn't the fistfights. It’s the philosophy. Jason poses a question that Batman can never truly answer: Why is the Joker still alive?
Jason doesn't want to be a villain. He doesn't even want to be an anti-hero, really. He wants to be a better Batman. His logic is simple. If you kill the monsters, they can't hurt people anymore. Bruce’s refusal to cross that line is seen by Jason not as a moral victory, but as a Weakness that costs innocent lives.
"I'm not talking about killing the Penguin or Scarecrow or Dent," Jason says in that final, rain-soaked confrontation. "I'm talking about him." He’s pointing a gun at the Joker. And honestly? Half the readers usually agree with the kid.
Key Differences You Need to Know
If you’re coming from the films or the Arkham Knight game, the book might surprise you. For one, Nightwing (Dick Grayson) has a much larger role. His chemistry with Bruce during the investigation provides a necessary light to the darkness. You see the contrast between the "Good Son" and the "Lost Son."
Also, the Joker in this run is genuinely depraved.
💡 You might also like: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
Doug Mahnke’s art makes the Joker look like a gangly, terrifying ghoul. He isn't a funny clown here. He’s a victim of Jason’s revenge as much as he is the villain. The book shows Jason beating the Joker with a crowbar—the ultimate "eye for an eye" moment—and the Joker actually loves it. He’s laughing because he realizes he’s won. He broke Batman’s legacy.
How to Read It Today
If you're looking to pick this up, don't just buy random issues. Look for the trade paperback titled Batman: Under the Red Hood. It collects Batman #635-641 and #645-650.
A lot of people also suggest reading Batman: The Cult or A Death in the Family first to get the full weight of Jason's history. But honestly, Winick does a good job of catching you up. He uses flashbacks effectively—not just as filler, but to show the specific moments where Jason felt Bruce failed him.
The Legacy of the Red Hood
Since this book came out, Jason Todd has become a staple of the DC Universe. He’s led the Outlaws. He’s been a member of the Bat-Family again (mostly). But he’s never been as sharp or as impactful as he was in this specific run.
The Batman Under the Red Hood book didn't just bring a character back to life; it changed the way we look at Batman’s mission. It forced Bruce to admit that his crusade might be a never-ending cycle of failure. That's heavy stuff for a "superhero comic."
Actionable Steps for the True Bat-Fan
If you want to dive deep into this specific era of Gotham history, here is how you should handle it:
- Track down the "Lost Days" Miniseries: After reading the main book, find Red Hood: The Lost Days. It’s also by Judd Winick and explains exactly what Jason was doing during the years he was "missing" before returning to Gotham. It covers his training and his descent into darkness.
- Compare the Ending: Pay close attention to the final standoff in the apartment. The dialogue in the book is more nuanced than the movie. Note the specific way Jason gives Bruce an ultimatum. It’s a masterclass in tension.
- Check the Art Evolution: Watch how the art changes when the story moves from the "hush" style into the grittier Mahnke era. The visual shift mirrors Bruce's deteriorating mental state as he realizes his son is alive and hates him.
- Look for the 2026 Anniversary Editions: Since we're looking at this from a 2026 perspective, many retailers have released "Black Label" or deluxe hardcover versions that include the Annual #25, which is the "missing link" issue explaining the Superboy-Prime punch in more detail.
The Batman Under the Red Hood book isn't just a comic. It’s a tragedy in three acts. It’s the moment the Batman mythos grew up and started asking the hard questions about the cost of justice. If you’ve only seen the movie, you’re missing the gritty, weird, and deeply human heart of the story. Go buy the trade paperback. You won't regret it.