You’re walking down New Dorp Lane. It’s Staten Island—the "forgotten borough"—where food usually means a "regular pie" or a massive hero from a deli that’s been there since 1982. But then there’s this spot. The Basement. It’s tucked away, exactly like the name suggests, and honestly, The Basement Staten Island menu is doing things that most neighborhood joints are too scared to try. It isn't just a place to grab a drink; it's become a weirdly specific cultural touchstone for people who want a city vibe without paying $22 for a cocktail in Manhattan.
It's loud. It's dark. The lighting is low enough that you can barely see your own hands, but the food? That’s what sticks.
Most people come for the atmosphere, but they stay because the kitchen actually knows what it's doing. We aren't talking about Michelin stars here. We're talking about elevated pub grub that hits that sweet spot between "I’m watching the game" and "I’m on a third date and trying to look cool."
What’s Actually on The Basement Staten Island Menu?
If you're looking for a massive, thirty-page cheesecake factory situation, you’re in the wrong place. The menu is tight. It’s focused. They lean heavily into that gastro-pub energy where everything is meant to be shared, or at least defended with a fork if your friends get too close to your plate.
The starters are where the identity of the place really lives. You've got your standard wings, sure, but they usually have a twist—think sauces that aren't just "Buffalo" or "Barbecue." They do these sliders that people obsess over. They’re juicy, seasoned properly, and usually served on buns that actually hold up to the grease.
Then there’s the truffle fries. Look, everyone does truffle fries now. It’s almost a cliché. But at The Basement, they don't skimp on the oil or the parmesan. It’s aggressive. It’s salty. It’s exactly what you want when you’re three drinks deep into a Saturday night.
- The Signature Burger: Usually a blend of short rib or brisket. It’s thick.
- Tacos: They rotate these, but the fish tacos are surprisingly fresh for a basement in the middle of Staten Island.
- Flatbreads: Crispy, thin, and topped with stuff like balsamic glaze or goat cheese.
Honestly, the menu feels like it was designed by someone who loves bar food but got tired of eating frozen mozzarella sticks. There is a clear effort to use better ingredients. You can taste it in the beef. You can see it in the way the garnishes aren't just an afterthought.
The Drink Situation: More Than Just Domestic Pints
You can't talk about The Basement Staten Island menu without talking about the liquid portion of the program. This is where they really lean into the "speakeasy" aesthetic.
The cocktail list is where the real creativity happens. They do the classics—Old Fashioneds, Moscow Mules, the usual suspects—but they usually have a seasonal rotation. One month it’s something with elderflower and gin; the next, it’s a spicy tequila concoction that’ll clear your sinuses.
They also have a solid craft beer selection. It’s a mix of local New York brews and some heavy hitters from out of state. If you’re a Guinness person, they’ve got you, but if you want an IPA that tastes like a pine tree, they’ve got that too.
The price point is interesting. It’s more expensive than your average dive bar on Hylan Blvd, but cheaper than anything you'd find in the Meatpacking District. It’s that "Staten Island premium"—you pay for the environment, the music, and the fact that you don't have to take the ferry to feel like you're out on the town.
Why the Atmosphere Changes How the Food Tastes
Environment matters. If you ate this burger in a brightly lit cafeteria, it would be a 7/10. Inside The Basement, with the brick walls and the leather booths, it’s a 9/10.
There is a specific kind of energy in a subterranean bar. It feels exclusive. It feels like a secret, even though everyone on the island knows about it. The menu caters to this by being "handheld friendly." Most of the food doesn't require a steak knife and a formal education to eat. It’s social food.
The "Late Night" Factor
Staten Island isn't exactly known for having a ton of options after 11 PM that aren't diners or fast food. The Basement fills that gap. Their kitchen often stays open later than the surrounding spots, making it the de facto destination for the post-concert or post-movie crowd.
When you're there at midnight, the menu feels different. The heavy, savory items like the loaded nachos or the steak bites become the absolute stars of the show. It’s comfort food for people who aren't ready to go home yet.
Breaking Down the Favorites
People have opinions. If you ask ten locals what to get, you’ll get ten different answers, but a few things keep coming up.
- The Mac and Cheese: It’s usually baked. It’s usually crusty on top. It’s definitely not from a box.
- Giant Pretzels: These things are the size of a hubcap. They come with mustard or cheese sauce. They’re basically mandatory for any group larger than two people.
- Specialty Wings: They often play with flavors like honey garlic or dry rubs that actually have some kick.
Is it healthy? Absolutely not. Is it supposed to be? No. It’s soulful, heavy, "I'll go to the gym on Monday" kind of food.
The Reality of Dining Subterranean
There are downsides. It can get loud. Like, "I have to scream my order at the server" loud. If you’re looking for a quiet place to discuss your 401k, this isn't it. But if you want a place where the bass is thumping and the food is consistent, it works.
🔗 Read more: How Make the Paper Actually Works: From Pulsing Wood to Finished Sheet
The service is usually "Staten Island friendly"—meaning it’s direct, efficient, and they don't have time for nonsense. They know the menu inside and out, so if you ask what’s good, they won't give you a corporate script. They’ll tell you to get the burger because the kitchen just prepped a fresh batch of patties.
Navigating the Menu Transitions
One thing most people miss is that the menu can shift. They do events. They do brunch occasionally. The Basement Staten Island menu you see on a Tuesday afternoon might have a different "vibe" than what you see on a Friday night during a DJ set.
For brunch, they flip the script. You might see chicken and waffles or some variation of an avocado toast, but it always maintains that "Basement" edge. It’s never too precious. It’s always substantial.
What Most People Get Wrong About The Basement
Some folks think it’s just a club. They think they can’t get a decent meal there. That’s a mistake. While the music and the drinks are a huge draw, the kitchen is the backbone.
They actually care about presentation. You’ll see plates coming out that look like they belong in a high-end bistro. The contrast between the grit of a basement bar and the polish of the plating is part of the charm.
Also, don't sleep on the salads. I know, who goes to a bar for a salad? But they usually have one or two options with grilled protein that are actually legitimate meals, not just some wilted iceberg lettuce.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
If you're planning on heading down, keep a few things in mind to get the best experience:
- Check the Specials: They often have off-menu items or seasonal cocktails that aren't on the main printed sheet. Ask the bartender.
- Timing is Everything: If you want to actually eat and talk, go early (around 6 or 7 PM). If you want the party, show up after 10 PM.
- Park Smart: New Dorp Lane is a nightmare for parking. Use the side streets or a ride-share if you plan on diving into that cocktail menu.
- Order for the Table: Most of the "small bites" are better shared. Get three or four things for the group rather than everyone getting their own heavy entree.
The Basement represents a shift in Staten Island's dining scene. It’s moving away from the "red sauce joint" monopoly and toward something more modern, more urban, and frankly, more interesting. It’s a place that knows its identity and doesn't apologize for it. You go down the stairs, the world gets a little darker, the music gets a little louder, and the food hits exactly the way it’s supposed to.
Whether you’re there for a quick bite before a night out or you’re making the bar your home base for the evening, the menu has enough variety to keep you from getting bored but enough focus to ensure they do the basics right. Stick to the burgers, try the wings, and definitely don't skip the fries. It’s straightforward, it’s effective, and it’s one of the best ways to spend an evening on the island.