Why the Azerbaijan Armenia Peace Deal Is Still Stuck in Limbo

Why the Azerbaijan Armenia Peace Deal Is Still Stuck in Limbo

Wait. People have been talking about a "final" peace agreement in the South Caucasus for years. You've probably seen the headlines. Diplomats in Brussels, Washington, and Moscow all smiling for the cameras. But if you actually look at the border right now, it’s anything but settled. The Azerbaijan Armenia peace deal isn't just some legal document waiting for a signature; it is a massive, shifting puzzle of land, identity, and raw power that could reshape Eurasia.

It's complicated. Honestly, it's messy.

Since the 2020 Nagorno-Karabakh war, the momentum has swung wildly toward Baku. Then came 2023. In a lightning-fast 24-hour operation, Azerbaijan took full control of the Karabakh region. That changed everything. It effectively ended the thirty-year-long ethnic conflict over that specific patch of land, but it didn't end the tension. Now, the two nations are staring at each other across a border that hasn't even been fully drawn yet. They are closer to peace than they’ve been in three decades, yet the "final mile" feels like a marathon.

The Zangezur Corridor and the Sovereignty Roadblock

You can't talk about a peace deal without talking about maps. Specifically, the Zangezur Corridor. This is the big one. Azerbaijan wants a land link to its Nakhchivan exclave through Armenian territory. Baku argues this was part of the 2020 ceasefire agreement overseen by Russia. Armenia, understandably, is terrified of losing sovereignty over its southern border with Iran.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has proposed the "Crossroads of Peace" project. It’s his way of saying, "Sure, let's trade, but we control the roads." Azerbaijan's President Ilham Aliyev has been much more blunt. He wants a path that doesn't involve Armenian checkpoints. This isn't just a minor disagreement over a highway. It’s about who controls the flow of goods between Turkey, Central Asia, and Europe. If they can’t agree on who holds the keys to those gates, the Azerbaijan Armenia peace deal stays on the shelf.

Constitutionally Speaking, We Have a Problem

Here is something most casual observers miss. Azerbaijan is demanding that Armenia change its constitution. Baku points to the Armenian Declaration of Independence, which mentions a 1989 joint decision to unify Nagorno-Karabakh with Armenia. Aliyev says he won't sign anything while that text exists. He views it as a ticking time bomb—a legal loophole that a future Armenian government could use to claim land again.

✨ Don't miss: Trump Declared War on Chicago: What Really Happened and Why It Matters

Pashinyan is in a tough spot. You can't just rewrite a constitution on a whim. It requires a referendum. It requires the people to say "okay" to removing a core part of their national identity. Many Armenians feel like they’ve already given up too much. For them, changing the constitution feels like a final surrender. This legal hurdle is currently one of the biggest "gotchas" in the entire negotiation process.

Who Is Actually Pulling the Strings?

The mediators are a revolving door of global powers. You have the European Union, led by Charles Michel, trying to play the neutral arbiter. Then you have the United States, with Secretary of State Antony Blinken frequently hosting the foreign ministers in Arlington. And then, there’s Russia.

Russia used to be the only player in the room. Now? Not so much. Because of the war in Ukraine, Moscow’s influence has slipped. Armenia feels betrayed because Russian peacekeepers didn't stop the 2023 takeover of Karabakh. As a result, Yerevan is freezing its participation in the CSTO (Russia’s version of NATO) and looking toward the West. This pivot makes the Kremlin very nervous. If the Azerbaijan Armenia peace deal is signed under Western mediation, Russia loses its primary lever of control in the region.

Iran is also watching. Tehran is obsessed with its border with Armenia. They’ve stated clearly that any "geopolitical changes" (meaning Azerbaijan taking a slice of southern Armenia) is a red line. So, while the two leaders talk, they have five different world powers whispering—or shouting—in their ears.

The Human Cost of "Delimitation"

Let's get real for a second. This isn't just about lines on a computer screen. It’s about villages like Kirants. Recently, the two sides started "delimiting" the border—basically deciding exactly where the fence goes. In some cases, this meant moving the border right through people's backyards or past their schools.

🔗 Read more: The Whip Inflation Now Button: Why This Odd 1974 Campaign Still Matters Today

The protests in Armenia, led by Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan, show how fragile the domestic situation is. Thousands of people marched on Yerevan because they feel the government is giving away pieces of the motherland without getting anything in return. Peace is expensive. Not just in money, but in political capital. Pashinyan is betting his entire career—and maybe his safety—on the idea that a signed Azerbaijan Armenia peace deal will bring enough prosperity to make the territorial losses worth it.

Why Is This Taking So Long?

  • The Enclaves: There are tiny pockets of land—islands of territory—belonging to one country but surrounded by the other. Deciding whether to swap these or keep them as "exclaves" is a logistical nightmare.
  • The Prisoners: Armenia wants its detainees back. Azerbaijan uses them as a bargaining chip.
  • The Language: Every word in the treaty is being fought over. Does it say "corridor" or "route"? Does it say "guarantees" or "observations"?
  • The Minefields: Nagorno-Karabakh is one of the most mined places on earth. Armenia has handed over maps, but Azerbaijan says they are inaccurate. Trust is at absolute zero.

Economic Windfall or Just a Pipe Dream?

If they actually sign the thing, the upside is massive. Armenia is currently blockaded by Turkey and Azerbaijan. Opening those borders would be like hitting an economic "on" switch. Trade would flow from Istanbul to Baku through Yerevan. Central Asian gas could move more easily to Europe. It would turn a "landlocked" region into a global transit hub.

But wait. There’s a catch. Azerbaijan has already started building an alternative route through Iran (the Aras Corridor) to bypass Armenia if they have to. This takes away some of Armenia's leverage. It’s a game of chicken played with billion-dollar infrastructure projects.

What Needs to Happen Next

Forget the grand speeches. For an Azerbaijan Armenia peace deal to actually stick, three things have to happen. First, the two countries need to finalize the border coordinates without a riot breaking out in the streets of Yerevan. Second, they need a third-party guarantee that actually means something—something both Baku and Yerevan trust, which is a tall order. Third, the rhetoric has to cool down. You can't sign a "friendship" treaty while your state media is still calling the other side the enemy.

It’s easy to be cynical. People have been dying over these mountains since the 1980s. But for the first time, the "status quo" is gone. The old frozen conflict has thawed, and while that’s dangerous, it also means things can finally move.

💡 You might also like: The Station Nightclub Fire and Great White: Why It’s Still the Hardest Lesson in Rock History

Actionable Steps for Staying Informed

To truly understand where this is headed, don't just follow the official press releases. Keep an eye on the following:

  1. Monitor the border commissions: When you see reports of "border pillars" being installed, that is actual progress, regardless of the political noise.
  2. Watch the Iranian-Azeri relationship: If Baku and Tehran get too cozy, Armenia’s "Crossroads of Peace" loses its value.
  3. Check the "Return" rhetoric: Watch if Azerbaijan starts talking about a "Western Azerbaijan" (referring to modern-day Armenia). If that language increases, a peace deal is moving further away.
  4. Follow local journalists: Sources like CivilNet in Armenia or independent bloggers in Baku often capture the reality that state-run media ignores.

The path to a final agreement is basically a minefield, both literally and figuratively. But the alternative is another thirty years of isolation and the constant threat of a new war. Everyone involved knows that. They just have to decide if they can live with the compromise.


Practical Next Steps

To get the most accurate picture of the current situation, cross-reference reports from the International Crisis Group (ICG) with local updates. Pay close attention to the specific wording used by the Armenian Foreign Ministry regarding constitutional changes, as this remains the primary legal hurdle. Additionally, tracking the construction progress of the Horadiz-Aghband railway will tell you more about the future of regional transport than any diplomatic summit ever will. Don't look for a single "signing ceremony" to fix everything; look for the small, incremental steps of border demarcation as the true indicator of lasting peace.