It was a mess. Honestly, looking back at the Argentina football squad for World Cup 2018, there is no other way to describe the chaos that unfolded in Russia. You had the greatest player to ever lace up boots, Lionel Messi, trapped in a tactical whirlwind that felt more like a fever dream than a professional football tournament. One minute they were barely qualifying thanks to a hat-trick in the thin air of Quito; the next, they were getting thrashed by Croatia while the manager, Jorge Sampaoli, looked like he wanted to vanish into his own tight-fitting t-shirt.
People remember the goals, sure. They remember Kylian Mbappé tearing through the defense in the Round of 16. But the real story of that squad is about the friction between a golden generation that was aging out and a coaching staff that couldn't decide on a philosophy.
The Names You Know and the Roles They Struggled With
The roster was top-heavy. It’s a classic Argentina problem, isn't it? You look at the attacking options and your jaw drops, but then you look at the defense and realize things are a bit... shaky.
Jorge Sampaoli brought a 23-man squad that was, on average, the oldest in the tournament. He leaned heavily on the "Old Guard." We’re talking about Javier Mascherano, who was playing his final World Cup and frankly looked a step slow against elite pace. Then you had Gonzalo Higuaín and Sergio Agüero. Two of the best strikers in Premier League and Serie A history, yet they spent half the time rotating or looking lost as Messi dropped deeper and deeper into midfield just to touch the ball.
In goal, things got weird before the plane even left. Sergio Romero, the long-time undisputed number one, got injured. Sampaoli tapped Willy Caballero to start. It didn't go well. That misplaced chip against Croatia? It basically broke the team's spirit. By the time Franco Armani was subbed in for the final group game against Nigeria, the fans were basically picking the lineup themselves.
The Argentina Football Squad for World Cup 2018: Tactics or Chaos?
If you try to find a consistent tactical blueprint for that month in Russia, you’ll give yourself a headache. Sampaoli is a disciple of Marcelo Bielsa. He likes high pressing. He likes frantic energy. But he had a squad that wanted to play a different way.
💡 You might also like: El Salvador partido de hoy: Why La Selecta is at a Critical Turning Point
In the opening 1-1 draw against Iceland, they looked static. 27 shots and nothing to show for it but a missed Messi penalty and a lot of frustrated gesturing. Then came the Croatia game. A 3-0 loss that felt like an execution. Sampaoli switched to a back three, which felt suicidal against players like Ivan Perišić and Ante Rebić. It was.
Rumors swirled that the players had a "meeting" with the coaching staff after that loss. Basically, the veterans took over. You could see it on the sidelines. During the Nigeria game, cameras caught Sampaoli seemingly asking Messi if he should bring on Kun Agüero. It wasn't a manager leading a team; it was a group of desperate legends trying to save their own legacy.
The Midfield Vacuum
Midfield was the "black hole" of the Argentina football squad for World Cup 2018. Ever Banega was the only one who seemed capable of passing the ball forward. Without him on the pitch, the connection between the defense and Messi was non-existent.
Javier Mascherano gave everything. He literally finished the Nigeria game with blood smeared across his face. But heart doesn't stop a 19-year-old Mbappé running at 38 kilometers per hour. Biglia looked out of sorts. Enzo Pérez was literally on vacation when he got the call to replace the injured Manuel Lanzini. Think about that. A key midfielder for a World Cup run was called up from a beach in Rio because the squad lacked depth in creative transitions.
That Crazy Night in Kazan
The 4-3 loss to France was the perfect microcosm of this team. They actually led! For a brief moment after Gabriel Mercado’s deflected goal, it looked like Argentina might fluke their way into the quarter-finals.
📖 Related: Meaning of Grand Slam: Why We Use It for Tennis, Baseball, and Breakfast
But the cracks were too wide.
Benjamin Pavard hit a strike that defies physics, and then Mbappé just... happened. The Argentine defense, led by Nicolás Otamendi and Marcos Rojo, had no answer for raw, vertical speed. It was the end of an era. You could see it in Messi's eyes at the final whistle. He had provided two assists, played as a "false nine" because Sampaoli benched both Higuaín and Agüero, and it still wasn't enough.
The squad was:
- Goalkeepers: Caballero, Armani, Guzmán.
- Defenders: Mercado, Tagliafico, Ansaldi, Fazio, Acuña, Otamendi, Rojo.
- Midfielders: Biglia, Banega, Di María, Meza, Mascherano, Lanzini (replaced by Pérez), Lo Celso, Salvio.
- Forwards: Messi, Higuaín, Agüero, Dybala, Pavón.
It looks great on a FIFA video game. On a pitch in Kazan? It was disjointed.
Why 2018 Matters for the 2022 Triumph
You can't understand Argentina’s 2022 World Cup win without looking at the wreckage of 2018. The 2018 squad was the "last dance" for a group that had lost three consecutive finals (2014, 2015, 2016). They were carrying too much emotional baggage.
👉 See also: NFL Week 5 2025 Point Spreads: What Most People Get Wrong
Lionel Scaloni, who was actually part of Sampaoli’s coaching staff in 2018, saw the dysfunction firsthand. He saw that you can't just throw eleven talented names on a pitch and hope Messi does a miracle. When he took over, he gutted the philosophy. He built a midfield—De Paul, Paredes, Lo Celso—specifically designed to run for Messi, not just watch him.
What We Can Learn From the 2018 Roster
Names don't win trophies. Logic does. The Argentina football squad for World Cup 2018 was a warning about what happens when a federation is in turmoil and a manager is disconnected from his players' strengths.
If you're analyzing this period of football, look at the minutes played. Paulo Dybala, one of the most exciting talents in the world at the time, barely saw the pitch. Why? Because the system couldn't figure out how to play him alongside Messi. It was a failure of imagination.
Take Action: How to Analyze This Era
If you want to truly understand how this squad fell apart, do these three things:
- Watch the Croatia 3-0 highlights but ignore the goals. Watch the spacing between the Argentine midfielders and defenders. It’s massive.
- Compare the heat maps of Lionel Messi in 2014 versus 2018. In 2018, he is frequently forced into his own half just to receive a pass from the center-backs.
- Check the age profile. Realize that nearly 60% of the starting XI was over 30. In a tournament defined by transition speed, they were sitting ducks.
The 2018 squad wasn't a lack of talent. It was a lack of cohesion. It serves as the ultimate proof that in international football, a functional "team" will beat a collection of "stars" every single time.