Honestly, walking into a beauty store these days feels like a fever dream of beige and taupe. Everything is "clean girl" this and "quiet luxury" that. But then you remember the Appley in Love eye shadow palette. It’s a bit of a throwback, sure. It doesn't have the clinical, minimalist packaging that’s everywhere on TikTok right now. Instead, it leans into that juicy, vibrant, slightly whimsical aesthetic that actually made makeup fun in the first place. This palette, released by the brand I Heart Revolution (part of the Revolution Beauty London umbrella), is basically a love letter to autumnal tones and crisp, orchard-inspired colors.
It's not just another red palette. Red is hard. If a brand messes up a red or pink pigment, you end up looking like you’ve got a nasty case of pink eye or a light allergy. Nobody wants that. But this specific collection of eighteen shades manages to walk the line between "daring editorial" and "I can actually wear this to the office." It’s weirdly versatile.
What the Appley in Love Eye Shadow Palette Actually Gets Right
Most people look at a palette themed after apples and expect eighteen variations of fire-engine red. That would be a nightmare to blend. Instead, the designers went for a more sophisticated color story. You’ve got the deep, bruised purples of a Red Delicious skin. There are those shimmering, golden-greens that look like a Granny Smith catching the light. Then, you have the neutrals. Oh, the neutrals. They are the unsung heroes here. They provide the structural integrity for the crazier shimmers.
The texture isn't that dry, chalky mess you sometimes find in budget palettes. Revolution Beauty has a bit of a reputation for being hit-or-miss, but their "Tasty" range—which this belongs to—is generally considered one of their high points. The pans are raised in a 3D apple shape. Is it a bit gimmicky? Yeah. Is it cute? Absolutely.
The Pigment Reality Check
Let’s be real for a second. We’ve all bought a palette because the swatches on Instagram looked like literal paint. Then you get it home, and it’s sheer. It’s a heartbreak. The Appley in Love eye shadow palette performs surprisingly well for its price point, but you have to know how to work it.
The mattes are the stars. They have a soft, almost buttery feel. However, because they are pressed quite firmly to maintain that apple shape, you can't just jab your brush in there. You need a light hand. The shimmers, on the other hand, are best applied with a finger. It's just the truth of modern cosmetic chemistry. The heat from your skin breaks down the binders in the shimmer, making it melt into your eyelid rather than sitting on top of it like glittery dust.
💡 You might also like: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
- Start with the shade "Sweet," a soft matte cream, to set your primer.
- Use "Tart" or "Crisp" in the crease—these are those perfect transition shades.
- If you're feeling bold, "Juicy" is that deep red that makes green or blue eyes pop like crazy.
Why Green Eye Shadows Are the Secret Weapon
People are terrified of green. I get it. It feels very 1980s or very "wicked witch." But the greens in this palette are muted. They have an earthy undertone. When you mix a mossy green with a warm brown, you get a depth that a standard smoky eye just can’t touch. It’s sophisticated.
Expert makeup artists often suggest using these olive and apple-green tones as a liner. Take a small, angled brush, wet it slightly with some setting spray, and dip into the dark green shade. It’s softer than black but more interesting than brown. It frames the eye without the harshness that can sometimes make us look tired.
Dealing with the "Fallout" Factor
No palette is perfect. If an "expert" tells you a palette has zero fallout, they’re probably lying or they aren't using enough pigment. Because the Appley in Love eye shadow palette uses some heavier mineral pigments to get those deep reds, you will get a little bit of dusting under your eyes.
The fix is simple. Do your eyes first. It’s a pro tip that feels wrong until you do it. Apply your shadows, wipe away the stray glitter with a makeup wipe, and then do your foundation. Your skin will look flawless, and you won't be fighting red streaks on your cheekbones all day.
Does it actually last?
Longevity is where budget palettes usually fail. They look great at 8:00 AM and vanish by lunchtime. With this palette, a primer is non-negotiable. Because the formula is quite emollient, it can crease on oily lids. A thin layer of a dedicated eye primer (or even just a bit of concealer set with powder) gives the pigment something to grip onto. If you do that, you’re looking at a solid 8 to 10 hours of wear.
📖 Related: The Gospel of Matthew: What Most People Get Wrong About the First Book of the New Testament
The Cultural Context of "Fruity" Makeup
We’ve seen a massive shift in how brands market to us. We went from the high-glam era of the 2010s to the minimalist era, and now we’re circling back to "Kitsch." This palette sits right in the middle of that. It’s nostalgic. It reminds people of the early days of YouTube tutorials when makeup was about transformation and play, not just looking like you have a great skincare routine.
The "Tasty" collection, including the Peach, Avocado, and Appley in Love palettes, carved out a niche for Revolution. They proved that you could have high-performing, vegan, and cruelty-free products without a triple-digit price tag. According to market data from 2023 and 2024, "food-themed" cosmetics saw a 15% uptick in Gen Z interest because they are inherently "postable." They look good on a vanity.
Addressing the Quality Concerns
Look, we have to be honest about the brand's history. Revolution Beauty has faced some scrutiny over the years regarding their business practices and financial reporting. However, from a consumer product standpoint, their manufacturing consistency has improved significantly since 2022. The Appley in Love palette remains one of their most stable formulations.
Some critics argue that the sheer number of palettes the brand releases dilutes the quality. There's some truth to that. But the "Tasty" line is often cited by influencers like SophDoesLife and others as being superior to their standard "Reloaded" palettes. The plastic casing is sturdier. The mirror is actually usable. It doesn't feel like it's going to snap in half if you drop it in your gym bag.
Comparison: Appley in Love vs. High-End Reds
If you compare this to something like the Huda Beauty Empowered palette or an Anastasia Beverly Hills vault, you’ll notice the difference in "blendability." The high-end shadows basically blend themselves. With the Appley in Love palette, you have to work for it a little more. You need to buff. You need to build.
👉 See also: God Willing and the Creek Don't Rise: The True Story Behind the Phrase Most People Get Wrong
But for the price of a fancy latte, you’re getting eighteen shades. If you only use five of them, you’ve still gotten your money’s worth. It’s an entry-point palette. It’s for the person who wants to experiment with red and green without committing fifty dollars to a color story they might hate in a week.
Actionable Steps for the Best Application
To get the most out of these shades, you need the right tools. Don't use those tiny sponge applicators that come in some drug store kits. Throw those away.
- Invest in a fluffy blending brush. This is the only way to handle the matte reds without looking like you have a bruise.
- Use a flat, synthetic brush for the shimmers. If you don't want to use your fingers, a synthetic brush "grabs" the shimmer particles better than natural hair.
- Try a "Halo Eye" with the greens. Put the dark green on the inner and outer corners, and pop the bright gold-green shimmer right in the center of the lid. It creates an incredible 3D effect.
- Layering is key. Start with a tiny amount of pigment. It is much easier to add more than it is to take it away once you’ve gone too far.
The Appley in Love palette isn't just a gimmick. It’s a functional, warm-toned workhorse that offers a lot of creative freedom for anyone willing to spend an extra five minutes on their blending technique. It’s a reminder that makeup is allowed to be fun, themed, and colorful.
To keep your palette in top shape, make sure to store it in a cool, dry place. Because of the "Tasty" line's specific pressed-powder formulation, humidity can sometimes make the shimmers "hard pan" (that annoying crusty layer on top). If that happens, just gently scrape the top layer with a clean spoolie, and it’ll be as good as new. Focus on using the deep "Core" shades for definition and the lighter "Seed" tones for highlighting the brow bone. You'll find that this palette covers almost every base for a complete eye look.