L.M. Montgomery was kind of a genius at capturing that specific, localized ache of being an outsider. When she sat down in Cavendish, Prince Edward Island, to write the Anne of Green Gables novel, she wasn't actually trying to create a global franchise. She was a woman dealing with her own loneliness, writing about a "mistake" that changed two lives. The premise is simple: an elderly brother and sister, Matthew and Marilla Cuthbert, want a boy to help on their farm. They get Anne Shirley instead. A skinny, red-headed girl with a temper and a vocabulary that probably would’ve been annoying if she weren't so desperately sincere.
It’s easy to write it off as "twee." You’ve seen the straw hats and the puffed sleeves. But if you actually read the text—really read it—there’s a weirdly modern edge to it. Anne is a survivor of systemic neglect. Before arriving at Bright River station, she was basically used as unpaid childcare for families with too many babies. She survived by dissociating into a world of "imagination." Montgomery wasn't just writing a kids' book; she was documenting a trauma response, even if she didn't have the clinical words for it in 1908.
The Reality Behind the Anne of Green Gables Novel
Most people think of the book as a sunny, pastoral dream. It isn't. Not entirely. The Anne of Green Gables novel is deeply rooted in the rigid social structures of rural Canada at the turn of the century. If you weren't useful, you were a burden. Marilla Cuthbert is a fascinating character because she represents the "sensible" side of that society—the side that initially views a child as a commodity rather than a person.
The book's success wasn't instant in the way we think of viral hits today, but it was massive for its time. Within five years, it had been translated into multiple languages. Even Mark Twain was a fan. He famously called Anne "the dearest and most moving and delightful child since the immortal Alice." High praise from a guy who usually hated everything.
What’s wild is how the book almost didn't happen. Montgomery received five rejections from publishers. She literally put the manuscript in a hatbox and forgot about it for a couple of years. It was only when she pulled it out again and decided to try one more time—with L.C. Page & Co. in Boston—that the world finally got to meet Anne.
Why Prince Edward Island is Basically a Character
You can't talk about this book without talking about the red soil of PEI. It’s not just a setting. It’s the catalyst for Anne’s internal growth.
- The White Way of Delight: Actually a real row of apple trees.
- The Lake of Shining Waters: Based on a pond in Cavendish.
- Green Gables itself: A home owned by Montgomery's cousins, the Macneills.
The geography is tactile. You can smell the balsam fir. Montgomery’s descriptions of nature are so lush they borderline on the psychedelic. She spends pages talking about the way the light hits a birch tree. Some modern readers find it slow. Honestly? It’s a vibe. It’s slow-living before that was a trendy hashtag on TikTok.
✨ Don't miss: Temuera Morrison as Boba Fett: Why Fans Are Still Divided Over the Daimyo of Tatooine
Gilbert Blythe and the Anti-Toxic Romance
Let’s be real. The "enemies-to-friends-to-lovers" trope basically peaked with Gilbert Blythe. When he calls Anne "Carrots" in the schoolhouse, he isn't being a villain; he’s a kid who doesn't know how to get her attention. But Anne’s reaction—smashing a slate over his head—sets the tone for their entire dynamic.
She doesn't forgive him for years.
That’s the nuance. The Anne of Green Gables novel refuses to let Anne be a doormat. She holds a grudge. She’s competitive. She wants to beat Gilbert in every single subject at Queen’s Academy, and she often does. It’s a relationship built on intellectual parity, which was pretty radical for 1908. Gilbert doesn't want to "tame" her; he wants to be her equal.
The Controversy of the Later Years
Montgomery had a complicated relationship with her creation. As the years went by and the sequels piled up—Anne of Avonlea, Anne of the Island, and so on—the author felt increasingly trapped by the "sweet" persona the public demanded. If you read her private journals (which were edited and published years later by Mary Rubio and Elizabeth Waterston), you see a much darker side of the creator.
She struggled with depression. Her marriage to Ewan Macdonald, a Presbyterian minister, was often incredibly lonely.
This darkness leaks into the later books. By the time you get to Rilla of Ingleside, which focuses on Anne's daughter during World War I, the whimsical tone of the first Anne of Green Gables novel is long gone. It’s replaced by a stark, heartbreaking look at how war destroys small communities. It’s arguably the best WWI novel written from a Canadian home-front perspective, yet people still think of Anne as just a girl in a pinafore.
🔗 Read more: Why Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy Actors Still Define the Modern Spy Thriller
Misconceptions About "The Red Hair"
Everyone talks about the red hair. Anne hates it. She tries to dye it black and it turns green. Classic bit. But the red hair is symbolic of her "otherness." In the early 20th century, there was a weird cultural stigma against red hair, often associated with a "fiery" or "unstable" temperament. By having Anne eventually grow to accept herself (and having her hair turn to a "handsome auburn"), Montgomery is charting a path of self-actualization.
It’s not about beauty. It’s about belonging.
The "Kindred Spirits" Philosophy
The term "Kindred Spirit" has been overused to the point of being a Hallmark card, but in the context of the novel, it’s a survival strategy. Anne is looking for people who see the world with the same intensity she does. Matthew Cuthbert is the first. He’s a man of few words—barely any, really—but he recognizes Anne’s soul immediately.
Their bond is the emotional anchor of the book. Marilla provides the discipline, but Matthew provides the unconditional love that allows Anne to thrive. When he dies at the end of the first book, it’s a visceral shock to the system. It forces Anne to grow up instantly, trading her dreams of a full scholarship to stay home and save Green Gables with Marilla.
It’s a bittersweet ending. Most people forget that. She doesn't go off to conquer the world in the first book; she chooses her family.
Modern Adaptations vs. The Source Text
We have to address the "Anne with an E" shaped elephant in the room. The Netflix/CBC adaptation took a lot of heat for being "too dark." But here’s the thing: it actually pulled from the subtext that was already in the Anne of Green Gables novel. The trauma was always there. The 1985 Megan Follows version is the "comfort watch" version, but it skips over some of the sharper edges of Montgomery’s prose.
💡 You might also like: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
The book is funnier than the movies. It’s snarkier. Anne is a chatterbox, sure, but she’s also incredibly observant about the hypocrisies of the adult world. She calls out the "Mrs. Lyndes" of the world with a surgical precision that’s honestly impressive for a thirteen-year-old.
How to Read Anne of Green Gables Today
If you’re coming to the book for the first time, or rereading it as an adult, look for the following things:
- The Shift in Marilla: Watch how Marilla’s internal monologue changes. She goes from seeing Anne as a "duty" to admitting she loves her "better than anything on earth," though she’d never say it to her face.
- The Humor: Don't miss the dry, biting wit. Montgomery loved poking fun at the "Avenlea" gossip mill.
- The Sensory Language: Pay attention to how Anne describes smells and colors. It’s a masterclass in descriptive writing.
The Anne of Green Gables novel isn't just a relic of the past. It's a study in resilience. It's about a girl who had every reason to be bitter and cynical but chose to be "the mistress of her own imagination" instead.
To get the most out of the experience, don't stop at the first book. Read Anne of the Island. That's where she goes to university in the big city (Kingsport), deals with actual grief, and finally realizes that the "glamour" of life isn't nearly as important as the people you share it with.
Next Steps for Readers
Check out the The Selected Journals of L.M. Montgomery if you want to see the "real" woman behind the story. It provides a staggering contrast to the bright world of Avonlea. Also, look into the L.M. Montgomery Institute at the University of Prince Edward Island; they do incredible work preserving the actual historical context of the 1890s-1900s Atlantic Canada. If you can, find a 1908 facsimile edition of the Anne of Green Gables novel to see the original cover art—it’s a fascinating glimpse into how the book was first marketed to the public.