It was June 2017. Fans had been waiting over two decades for a definitive big-screen treatment of the most charismatic, contradictory, and influential figure in hip-hop history. When the All Eyez on Me movie finally hit theaters, the atmosphere was electric, but the reaction? Man, it was messy. People really wanted a masterpiece on par with Straight Outta Compton, but what they got was a film that sparked a massive debate about how we should handle the legacies of our icons.
Tupac Shakur wasn't just a rapper. He was a poet, an actor, a revolutionary, and a lightning rod for controversy. Capturing that in a two-hour runtime is basically an impossible task. If you've seen the film, you know Demetrius Shipp Jr. looked so much like Pac it was actually eerie. He had the mannerisms down—the way he tilted his head, the hand gestures, the smile. But looking the part and capturing the "soul" of a legend are two different things, and that’s where the friction started.
The struggle for authenticity in the All Eyez on Me movie
The production of this film was a literal rollercoaster. It went through multiple directors like Antoine Fuqua and John Singleton before Benny Boom finally took the helm. When a project stays in "development hell" that long, you can usually smell the creative tension on the final product. Singleton, who actually worked with Tupac on Poetic Justice, famously walked away from the biopic, saying the people involved weren't being respectful of Pac's legacy. That’s a heavy accusation. It hung over the All Eyez on Me movie like a dark cloud before the first trailer even dropped.
Biopics always walk a tightrope. On one side, you have the facts. On the other, you have the "vibe" or the emotional truth.
Jada Pinkett Smith, a lifelong friend of Tupac, was notably upset about how her relationship with him was portrayed. She took to social media to clarify that certain scenes—like Pac reading her a poem or saying goodbye before he left for LA—never actually happened. For a movie marketed as the true story, having one of the key living witnesses call out inaccuracies was a huge blow to its credibility. It makes you wonder: if they changed the small, intimate stuff, what else did they smooth over to fit a Hollywood narrative?
Why the casting worked (and why it didn't)
Demetrius Shipp Jr. deserves a lot of credit. Honestly. Imagine the pressure of playing a guy whose face is tattooed on thousands of people’s bodies. He wasn’t even a professional actor when he got the role; his father had actually worked with Tupac at Death Row Records. Talk about a full-circle moment.
💡 You might also like: Kiss My Eyes and Lay Me to Sleep: The Dark Folklore of a Viral Lullaby
Shipp’s performance is the strongest part of the All Eyez on Me movie. He nails the frantic energy of the post-prison 1995 era. You see the transition from the thoughtful son of a Black Panther to the "Makaveli" persona that eventually consumed him. But the script often felt like a "greatest hits" compilation rather than a deep character study. It hits the marks—the Digital Underground days, the shooting at Quad Studios, the courtroom dramas, the signing to Suge Knight—but it sometimes moves so fast that you don't get to feel the weight of those moments.
Then you have Danai Gurira as Afeni Shakur. She was incredible. She brought a gravitas to the role that grounded the film. The scenes between Pac and his mother are arguably the most honest parts of the movie. They show the roots of his trauma and his brilliance. Without her performance, the movie might have felt like a high-budget reenactment rather than a film with a pulse.
The Death Row era and the shadows of the 90s
The second half of the film leans heavily into the glitz and paranoia of Death Row Records. This is the part everyone remembers. Dominic L. Santana plays Suge Knight, and he brings that looming, quiet menace that defined the label's reputation.
The All Eyez on Me movie does a decent job of showing how suffocating that environment was. You see Pac working at a manic pace, recording hundreds of songs because he felt like his time was running out. It was a pressure cooker. But the film shies away from some of the darker, more complex nuances of the East Coast-West Coast feud. It portrays Pac as a man caught in a whirlwind, which is true, but it doesn't always reckon with his own agency in escalating those tensions.
Technical hiccups and the "TV Movie" feel
One of the biggest criticisms from film nerds and casual fans alike was the production value. For a movie about a man who sold 75 million records, some scenes felt strangely low-budget. The lighting in the house parties and some of the studio scenes felt a bit flat. Compared to the cinematic sweep of Straight Outta Compton, which had a gritty, expensive look, this felt more like a made-for-TV special at times.
📖 Related: Kate Moss Family Guy: What Most People Get Wrong About That Cutaway
There's also the issue of the ADR (automated dialogue replacement). There are moments where the lip-syncing of the songs or even the dialogue feels just a tiny bit off. It’s a small detail, but in a biopic about a world-class performer, it pulls you out of the experience. You want to lose yourself in the 90s, not be reminded you're watching a set.
What the All Eyez on Me movie missed
Tupac was a walking contradiction. He was the man who wrote "Keep Ya Head Up" and "Dear Mama," but also the man who spit at cameras and embraced the "Thug Life" mantra. The film tries to show both, but it feels like it’s checking boxes.
What we missed was the "why."
- Why did he feel the need to pivot so hard into the gangsta persona after leaving Clinton Correctional?
- What was his actual political philosophy toward the end?
- How did his acting career—which was legit, by the way—influence his public persona?
The movie touches on his time at the Baltimore School for the Arts, but it’s a brief pitstop. We don't get enough of the theater kid who loved Shakespeare, which is essential to understanding why he was so dramatic and performative later in life.
The legacy of the film in 2026
Looking back now, the All Eyez on Me movie serves as a fascinating time capsule of how we struggle to tell the stories of our Black revolutionaries. Since its release, the conversation around Tupac has only grown. We’ve seen the arrest of Duane "Keffe D" Davis in connection with his murder, which has reopened old wounds and renewed interest in the 1996 Las Vegas shooting.
👉 See also: Blink-182 Mark Hoppus: What Most People Get Wrong About His 2026 Comeback
When you re-watch the film today, the ending hits different. Knowing more about the behind-the-scenes mechanics of that night in Vegas makes the final scenes of the movie feel even more tragic. It wasn't just the loss of a rapper; it was the loss of a man who was clearly in the middle of a massive personal evolution.
Actionable ways to engage with Tupac’s real history
If you’ve watched the movie and felt like you only got half the story, you’re right. To get the full picture, you have to look beyond the Hollywood dramatization.
Read "The Rose That Grew from Concrete"
This is a collection of Pac's poetry from his teenage years. It reveals the vulnerability that the movie often skips over. It’s the best way to understand the "soul" that Demetrius Shipp Jr. was trying to capture.
Watch the "Dear Mama" Docuseries
Directed by Allen Hughes (who, ironically, had a famous physical altercation with Pac in the 90s), this FX docuseries is arguably the "true" version of the story. It weaves together the life of Afeni Shakur and Tupac in a way the biopic couldn't. It uses real footage and deep-dive interviews that provide the context the All Eyez on Me movie lacked.
Listen to the Unreleased Catalog
The film focuses on the hits, but the deep cuts and the posthumous releases like The Don Killuminati: The 7 Day Theory show a man who knew he was living on borrowed time. Pay attention to the lyrics—they're more prophetic than any script could write.
Visit the Tupac Shakur: Wake Me When I'm Free Exhibit
If it’s still touring or has a permanent home when you're reading this, go. It features his notebooks, outfits, and personal artifacts. Seeing his actual handwriting on a yellow legal pad does more to humanize him than a two-hour film ever could.
Ultimately, the All Eyez on Me movie is a flawed tribute to a flawed hero. It’s worth a watch for Shipp’s performance and the nostalgia trip, but it shouldn't be your only source of information. Tupac was too big for one movie. He was a movement, a problem, and a genius all rolled into one. No single film was ever going to be enough to hold all of that. Regardless of the critics, the movie kept his name in the conversation, and in the world of legends, being talked about is the only thing that matters.