Honestly, walking into a theater in 2016 to watch The 5th Wave, you probably thought you were seeing the start of the next Hunger Games. It had everything. A massive YA book pedigree by Rick Yancey, Chloë Grace Moretz at the height of her stardom, and a premise that was genuinely terrifying—an alien invasion that isn't just about big ships in the sky, but the systematic dismantling of human civilization.
But then, nothing.
The movie ended on a massive cliffhanger, the kind that practically screams "see you in two years for the sequel," yet the screen stayed dark. Fans of the book series, which includes The Infinite Sea and The Last Star, were left hanging. If you’ve spent any time on Reddit or old movie forums lately, the question is always the same: where is the rest of the story? It’s not just about a "failed" movie; it’s about a specific moment in Hollywood history where the "Young Adult" bubble finally burst, leaving Cassie Sullivan's journey stranded in the woods of Ohio.
What Actually Happens in The 5th Wave?
Let's talk about those waves. Most alien movies give you a big laser beam or a virus. The 5th Wave was different because it felt cruel and methodical. The first wave is an EMP—everything electronic dies. No phones, no planes, no lights. The second? Massive tsunamis triggered by the "Others" dropping huge rods onto fault lines. Then comes the Red Death—a bird-borne plague that wipes out the survivors.
By the time the fourth wave hits, the aliens are living inside humans. This is where it gets psychological. You can't trust your neighbor. You can't even trust your own family.
The movie focuses on Cassie Sullivan, a high schooler played by Moretz. She’s trying to find her younger brother, Sam, who has been taken to a military base called Camp Haven. Along the way, she meets Evan Walker, a guy who is—spoiler alert for a ten-year-old movie—half-alien. They fall in love, because of course they do, and she realizes the military isn't actually the human resistance. They are the Others. They’re training kids to kill the "infested" adults, effectively making humanity finish itself off. It's a dark, twisted concept that the movie tries to balance with a teen romance, and that's where things started to get a bit messy.
💡 You might also like: Why Love Island Season 7 Episode 23 Still Feels Like a Fever Dream
The Problem With the Adaptation
Adapting Rick Yancey's prose is a nightmare. His writing is internal, gritty, and deeply cynical. In the book, the perspective shifts constantly. One minute you're with Cassie, the next you're inside the head of Zombie (Ben Parish, played by Nick Robinson), and then you're seeing the cold, calculated thoughts of an alien.
The movie flattened this. It turned a complex psychological thriller into a somewhat standard action flick. While the first thirty minutes—the depiction of the world falling apart—are actually quite haunting and well-paced, the second half feels rushed. J Blakeson, the director, had a tough job. He had to squeeze a dense novel into 112 minutes while maintaining a PG-13 rating. This meant the visceral horror of the Red Death and the sheer hopelessness of the situation were toned down. For many fans, the "Others" felt less like an existential threat and more like generic movie villains by the time the credits rolled.
Why We Never Got The Infinite Sea
Numbers don't lie. But they can be misleading.
On paper, The 5th Wave wasn't a total disaster. It cost about $38 million to make and brought in $109 million worldwide. Usually, a movie that triples its budget gets a sequel. So, why did Sony/Columbia Pictures pull the plug?
- The Domestic Slump: It only made $34 million in the United States. In Hollywood math, domestic earnings are king because the studio keeps a higher percentage of the ticket sales compared to international markets like China.
- Critical Reception: A 15% on Rotten Tomatoes is hard to ignore. Critics called it derivative. They weren't entirely wrong—by 2016, audiences were suffering from "Chosen One" fatigue. We’d already had Twilight, The Hunger Games, Divergent, and The Maze Runner. People were tired of teenagers in cargo pants fighting the government.
- The Divergent Warning: Right around the same time, the Divergent series hit a wall. Allegiant bombed so hard they considered finishing the story as a TV movie (which never happened). This spooked every studio executive in town. They realized the YA gold rush was over.
It's a shame, honestly. The second book, The Infinite Sea, is a much tighter, more claustrophobic story. It focuses on the characters hiding out in a hotel during a brutal winter while being hunted by "Silencers." It’s less about world-ending spectacles and more about the psychological toll of the invasion. It would have made for a much better, lower-budget thriller, but the momentum was gone.
📖 Related: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
The Cast: Where Are They Now?
One reason people still talk about The 5th Wave is because the cast actually went on to do great things. They weren't the problem.
- Chloë Grace Moretz: She’s continued to pick interesting, often darker roles like Suspiria and the sci-fi series The Peripheral. She’s voiced her frustrations with how the industry treated her during her teen years, and she’s moved far beyond the YA heroine trope.
- Nick Robinson: He became a massive star in his own right with Love, Simon and Maid. Looking back at his performance as Ben Parish, you can see the talent, even if the script didn't give him much to do besides look tired and hold a rifle.
- Maika Monroe: She played Ringer, the tough-as-nails sharpshooter. Since then, she’s become a "Scream Queen" icon with It Follows and the recent 2024 hit Longlegs.
- Alex Roe: The mysterious Evan Walker. He went on to star in the TV show Siren.
If you tried to assemble this cast today, the budget would triple just from their salaries. They were a "dream team" of up-and-coming talent that simply got caught in a project that didn't know what it wanted to be.
Was it a "Bad" Movie?
Not really. It’s "fine." That’s the most frustrating thing about it. It’s a perfectly watchable Saturday afternoon movie. The visual effects for the tsunami are genuinely impressive, and the "Others" reveal—using children as weapons because they are the only ones who can't be "infested" yet—is a chilling concept.
The real issue is that the book series is so much better. Rick Yancey’s writing is almost poetic in its nihilism. The movie tried to make it "fun," and you can't really make a story about 7 billion people dying "fun." It felt sanitized. When you take the teeth out of a story about the end of the world, you’re left with a gumless gums-fest that doesn't leave a mark.
How to Experience the Rest of the Story
Since we aren't getting a sequel—and let’s be real, at this point, it would have to be a full reboot—the only way to find out what happens to Cassie and the gang is to read. Or listen to the audiobooks, which are actually fantastic.
👉 See also: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
If you’re a fan of the first movie and want to know what you missed, here is the breakdown of the remaining story beats.
The Infinite Sea (The Second Act)
This book is much bleaker. It introduces a character named Grace, a Silencer who is basically a super-soldier for the Others. We learn more about how the aliens think. They aren't just "monsters"; they are a collective consciousness that views humanity as a virus. The book ends with a massive betrayal and the realization that the "waves" were never about killing humans, but about stripping away what makes them human.
The Last Star (The Finale)
The final book wraps everything up in a way that most fans found polarizing. Without spoiling too much, it deals with the concept of the "5th Wave" being the moment humans become the aliens themselves. It’s a heavy, philosophical ending that involves a lot of sacrifice. It’s definitely not the happy, triumphant ending you usually get in Hollywood blockbusters, which might be another reason why a movie sequel would have struggled.
The Legacy of the 5th Wave
It’s easy to dismiss The 5th Wave as just another failed franchise. But it serves as a fascinating case study in the "Peak YA" era. It represents the exact moment when the industry realized that a popular book doesn't automatically equal a billion-dollar film series.
It also highlights a shift in how we consume sci-fi. Today, a story like this would likely be a 10-episode prestige series on HBO or Apple TV+. You need that time. You need the space to let the world breathe and to let the characters feel the weight of their losses. Trying to cram the collapse of humanity into two hours while also trying to sell popcorn and lunchboxes was a doomed mission from the start.
Actionable Steps for Fans
If you're still thinking about this movie and want more, here is what you should do:
- Read the Books: Start with The 5th Wave even if you've seen the movie. The internal monologues change everything. Then move to The Infinite Sea and The Last Star.
- Check out the Audiobooks: Brendan King and Phoebe Strole do an incredible job with the narration, capturing the different "voices" of the narrators perfectly.
- Watch 'The Peripheral' on Amazon: If you liked Chloë Grace Moretz in a sci-fi setting, this series is much closer to the "gritty" tone that The 5th Wave should have had.
- Explore Maika Monroe’s Filmography: If you liked her as Ringer, watch It Follows or Watcher. She’s one of the best actors working in the genre today.
The story of Cassie Sullivan might be dead on the big screen, but the themes of trust, survival, and what it means to be human in the face of extinction are more relevant now than they were in 2016. Sometimes, the best way to enjoy a story is to let the version in your head be the one that finishes the trilogy.