Look, everyone loves Billy Bob Thornton’s Malvo from the first year. I get it. He was a force of nature. But if you really sit down and watch the 1979-set prequel, you start to realize that the 2nd season Fargo cast didn't just play characters; they built a fragile, violent, midwestern ecosystem that felt dangerously alive. It’s rare. Usually, a show has one or two standouts and a lot of "moving parts" in the background. Not here. From the butcher shop in Luverne to the Gerhardt syndicate in Fargo, every single person on screen felt like they had a mortgage, a secret, and a very specific way of making hotdish.
Noah Hawley took a massive gamble. He moved the timeline back to the tail end of the seventies, right when the oil crisis was hitting and Jimmy Carter was giving his "malaise" speech. To make that work, you need actors who can handle that specific brand of Minnesota Nice—which is basically just aggression wrapped in a thick wool sweater.
The Gerhardts and the death of the family business
Most crime shows give you a boss. Fargo gave us a dynasty in collapse. Jean Smart, playing Floyd Gerhardt, is the absolute anchor of this season. It’s a masterclass. She’s this grandmotherly figure who can order a hit while sipping tea, and you believe every second of it. She isn’t playing a "girl boss" or some trope; she’s a woman who has survived a hard life in a hard place and now has to manage three sons who are, frankly, a total disaster.
Then there’s Dodd. Jeffrey Donovan is terrifying here. He plays Dodd Gerhardt with this twitchy, misogynistic energy that makes your skin crawl. He’s the eldest son who thinks he’s the king, but he’s really just a bully who doesn't understand that the world is changing. Compare him to Bear (played by Angus Sampson). Bear is quiet. He’s the heavy. But Sampson gives him this soulful, tragic quality—especially in his scenes with his son, Charlie. You actually feel bad for the guy, even when he’s doing terrible things. It’s that nuance that makes the 2nd season Fargo cast so special.
And we can't forget Rye. Kieran Culkin isn't in the season for long—spoiler, I guess, though the show is years old now—but he sets the entire plot in motion. He’s got that frantic, "small man complex" energy he later perfected in Succession, but here it’s deadlier because he’s desperate. One bad decision at a Waffle Hut, and the whole world burns.
Why Kirsten Dunst and Jesse Plemons are the MVPs
If the Gerhardts are the "old world" of crime, Peggy and Ed Blumquist are the "new world" of total accidental chaos. Honestly, Kirsten Dunst should have won every award on the planet for this. Peggy is... well, she’s "actualizing." She’s obsessed with self-improvement seminars and celebrity magazines while literally cleaning blood off her windshield.
📖 Related: Chris Robinson and The Bold and the Beautiful: What Really Happened to Jack Hamilton
Dunst plays her with this manic optimism that is both hilarious and deeply unsettling. She isn't a villain, exactly. She just has a very loose relationship with reality. Then you have Jesse Plemons as Ed. "The Butcher of Luverne." He’s just a guy who wants to own his shop and have some kids. He loves Peggy so much he’s willing to put a corpse in a meat grinder for her. Plemons put on weight for the role and slowed his speech down, creating this image of a "big, dumb ox" who is actually the moral (or amoral) heart of the suburban tragedy. Their chemistry is legendary, likely because they actually fell in love on set and are married now. You can't fake that kind of domestic tension.
The Law: Lou Solverson and the burden of being good
Patrick Wilson had the hardest job. He had to play a younger version of Keith Carradine’s Lou Solverson from Season 1. How do you play "young and stoic" without being boring? You do it with your eyes. Wilson plays Lou as a man who just got back from Vietnam and realized the war followed him home. He’s the only sane person in a room full of lunatics.
His scenes with Ted Danson—who plays his father-in-law, Sheriff Hank Larsson—are some of the quietest and best in the series. Danson is a revelation here. He’s far away from Cheers. He’s playing a man trying to understand why people have become so cruel to one another. He’s literally trying to invent a universal language of symbols to stop wars. It’s weird, it’s quirky, and it’s perfectly Fargo.
The Bokeem Woodbine Factor
We have to talk about Mike Milligan. If you haven't seen Bokeem Woodbine in this role, you haven't lived. He plays a hitman for the Kansas City Mafia, but he talks like a philosophy professor. He’s got these two silent "Kitchen Brothers" flanking him, and he just delivers these incredible monologues about progress and corporate takeovers.
"It’s not a revolution if nobody loses their head."
👉 See also: Chase From Paw Patrol: Why This German Shepherd Is Actually a Big Deal
That line sums up the whole vibe. Woodbine brought a coolness to the 2nd season Fargo cast that balanced out the snowy, Midwestern drabness. He represented the "future"—corporate, cold, and efficient. The way he interacts with the Gerhardts is basically a metaphor for a big-box store moving into a small town and killing the local mom-and-pop shop. Only with more tommy guns.
The supporting players you probably forgot
Even the smaller roles are stacked.
- Nick Offerman plays Karl Weathers, the town's only lawyer/conspiracy theorist. Watching him drunkenly stare down a lynch mob is pure gold.
- Cristin Milioti as Betsy Solverson. She’s the heart of the season. She’s dying of cancer, and her quiet dignity provides the stakes. If Lou doesn't make it home, she’s alone.
- Zahn McClarnon as Hanzee Dent. Hanzee is the most dangerous person in the show. He starts as the Gerhardts' tracker and ends as... well, something much more significant. McClarnon’s performance is so internal. He says maybe fifty words the whole season, but you can feel his rage simmering in every frame.
The brilliance of this ensemble is that nobody is just "the help." Every character feels like they are the protagonist of their own, much sadder movie that we just happen to be glimpsing.
Complexity, Aliens, and the "True Story" Trope
A lot of people got hung up on the UFO stuff. Yeah, there’s a flying saucer. It’s weird. But when you look at the 2nd season Fargo cast reacting to it, it makes sense within the logic of the show. It’s 1979. People were seeing things. The world felt like it was ending. For a character like Hanzee or Lou, a spaceship isn't even the craziest thing they've seen that week.
The Coen Brothers' original 1996 film started with the "This is a true story" disclaimer, even though it wasn't. Season 2 leans into that by framing the whole thing as a history book titled The History of True Crime in the Mid-West. This allows the actors to play things a bit more "legendary." They aren't just people; they are folk figures.
✨ Don't miss: Charlize Theron Sweet November: Why This Panned Rom-Com Became a Cult Favorite
How to actually appreciate this cast today
If you’re going back for a rewatch, don't just focus on the plot. The plot is a mess of coincidences—that’s the point. Focus on the pauses.
- Watch the dinner scenes. The Gerhardt dinners are tense because of what isn't said.
- Listen to the accents. They aren't caricatures. They are specific. There’s a difference between "North Dakota" and "Minnesota" in this world.
- Look at the costuming. Note how Mike Milligan’s purple suit stands out against the browns and greys of the winter landscape. It tells you he doesn't belong.
The 2nd season Fargo cast succeeded because they understood the tone. It’s a tragedy that thinks it’s a comedy, or maybe a comedy that’s accidentally a bloodbath. When you have actors like Jean Smart and Jesse Plemons operating at the top of their game, you don't need a lot of flashy effects. You just need a camera and a lot of fake snow.
To get the most out of your next binge-watch, pay attention to Hanzee Dent’s evolution from a loyal soldier to a man seeking total autonomy. It’s arguably the most important character arc in the entire franchise, and Zahn McClarnon plays it with a terrifying, silent precision. Compare his stoicism to the frantic energy of the Blumquists, and you'll see exactly how this season balances its disparate tones. If you really want to dive deep, track how many times "progress" is mentioned by different characters; it's the secret theme that ties the Kansas City Mafia, the Gerhardts, and even Peggy's "actualization" together. Once you see the corporate-versus-family subtext, the performances gain a whole new layer of meaning.
---