Walking past 21 West 52nd Street today feels weird. The row of colorful cast-iron jockeys—those iconic lawn ornaments that stood like tiny, silent sentries over the entrance—aren't greeting a line of celebrities or power brokers anymore. It’s quiet. For nearly a century, the 21 Club New York wasn't just a restaurant; it was the unofficial mess hall for the American elite. If you were someone, or even if you were just trying to look like someone, you ended up at "21." Then the pandemic hit, and the gates stayed shut.
Most people think it was just another casualty of 2020. That's part of it, sure. But the story of this place is way messier and more interesting than a simple business closure. It’s a tale of Prohibition-era secret chutes, a cellar that supposedly "didn't exist," and a ceiling covered in toy trucks and airplanes donated by the world's most powerful CEOs. It’s about a specific kind of old-school New York prestige that's basically gone now.
The Prohibition Secret No One Could Bust
You have to understand that the 21 Club started as a speakeasy. Jack Kriendler and Charlie Berns weren't trying to build a landmark; they were trying to sell booze without getting arrested. They moved around a bit before settling at the 52nd Street spot in 1929, right as the Great Depression was about to kick everyone in the teeth.
The engineering of the place was honestly genius. While other speakeasies were getting raided and boarded up, 21 was thriving because of a sophisticated alarm system. When the lookout spotted a fed, they’d flip a switch. This triggered a mechanism that tipped the shelves in the bar, sending every single bottle of illegal gin and whiskey sliding down a chute into the city sewers. By the time the police walked in, the patrons were just sipping water and looking bored.
Then there’s the wine cellar.
📖 Related: Bates Nut Farm Woods Valley Road Valley Center CA: Why Everyone Still Goes After 100 Years
It wasn't actually in the building's basement. It was hidden behind a two-ton brick door in the basement of the house next door (number 19). You needed a long meat skewer to poke through a tiny, invisible hole in the mortar to release the latch. It worked. During the entire era of Prohibition, the feds never found the stash. Even today, if you look at the archives or talk to the historians who toured it before the 2020 shuttering, that door is a marvel of 1920s trickery.
That Ceiling and the "Power Table"
If you ever stepped into the Bar Room, you probably looked up and wondered why it looked like a messy toy store. Those weren't just random decorations.
The tradition started when British Airways (then BOAC) gave the owners a model plane. Suddenly, every regular wanted their company represented. Howard Hughes dropped off a model. So did the CEOs of major shipping lines and trucking firms. It became a high-stakes game of "who’s who." If your model was hanging from the ceiling at the 21 Club New York, you’d made it.
The seating chart was even more cutthroat.
👉 See also: Why T. Pepin’s Hospitality Centre Still Dominates the Tampa Event Scene
- Table 1: This was the legendary spot by the door.
- The "A-List" Row: The first row of tables in the Bar Room was where you’d see Frank Sinatra, Dorothy Parker, or Ernest Hemingway.
- The Upper Floors: If you were sent upstairs to the dining rooms, it was basically a polite way of saying you weren't important enough for the main action.
Basically, the staff were masters of the "polite snub." They knew exactly who mattered and who was just a tourist with a fat wallet. It was an ecosystem of ego.
The Mystery of the Closure
When the announcement came in late 2020 that the 21 Club wouldn't reopen, people lost their minds. It wasn't just about the burgers (which were famously expensive and, honestly, kinda basic for the price). It was about the loss of a sanctuary.
There have been endless rumors about what’s happening behind those closed doors now. The building is owned by Belmond, which is part of the LVMH luxury empire. You’d think they’d have the cash to keep it going, right? But the union issues were massive. The staff had been there for decades. We’re talking about captains and waiters who knew exactly how every regular liked their martini and which mistress shouldn't be seated near which wife.
The official line is that they are "reimagining" the space. Rumors have swirled about it becoming a private members' club or a different kind of hospitality venture. But as of now, the jockeys are gone (they were reportedly sent off for restoration and safekeeping), and the building sits as a 19th-century brownstone shell of its former self.
✨ Don't miss: Human DNA Found in Hot Dogs: What Really Happened and Why You Shouldn’t Panic
Why We Still Talk About It
Is it elitist? Yeah, totally. The dress code was notoriously strict—men had to wear jackets, and if you didn't have one, they’d hand you a loaner that probably didn't fit right. But the 21 Club New York represented a bridge to a version of Manhattan that doesn't exist anymore. It was a place where JFK had a private locker for his cigars and where every sitting President since FDR (except for George W. Bush) had dined.
It was a museum you could eat in.
The tragedy of its current state isn't just about a business closing; it’s about the fact that you can’t replicate that kind of history. You can’t build a "new" 21 Club. You can’t fake 90 years of grease, cigar smoke, and secret deals etched into the wood paneling.
Actionable Takeaways for the Modern New York Explorer
Since you can't currently grab a table at 21, you have to look elsewhere to find that specific "Old New York" DNA. If you’re trying to capture the vibe that the 21 Club once held, here is how you should navigate the city now:
- Seek out the survivors. Places like P.J. Clarke’s on 3rd Avenue or Keens Steakhouse offer that same sense of historical weight. Keens, specifically, has the largest collection of churchwarden pipes in the world, which rivals the 21 Club’s toy collection for sheer eccentric history.
- Look for the "Secret" Infrastructure. If you’re fascinated by the 21 Club’s hidden cellar, visit the New York Transit Museum or take a tour of the Old City Hall Subway Station. The city is full of hidden chambers that prove the 21 Club wasn't an anomaly—it was just the most famous example of New York’s "underground" life.
- Monitor the 52nd Street Developments. Keep an eye on the LVMH/Belmond press releases. The 21 Club site is too valuable to stay dark forever. When it does "reimagine" itself, expect a heavy emphasis on the private-club model, which is currently exploding in New York (think Casa Cipriani or Zero Bond).
- Visit the Jockeys. While they aren't on the steps right now, many of the original jockeys were donated or moved. Keep an eye on local auctions and museum exhibits; they remain the most recognizable symbols of New York's vanished café society.
The 21 Club might be dormant, but the spirit of the place—that mix of secrecy, power, and slightly overpriced gin—is still the heartbeat of Manhattan’s social ladder. You just have to know where to look for the next secret door.