It was weird. Honestly, there is no other way to describe it. The 2018 Green Bay Packers weren't just bad; they were confusing. You had Aaron Rodgers, fresh off a massive contract extension, playing on a fractured knee and a tibial plateau fracture suffered in Week 1. You had Mike McCarthy, a coach who had brought a Lombardi Trophy to Title Town, visibly losing his grip on the locker room.
They finished 6-9-1. That tie against the Vikings in Week 2? It felt like a loss. That loss to the Cardinals at home in December? That was the final nail.
People remember the 2018 Green Bay Packers as the end of an era. It was the year the "Mike McCarthy way" finally ran out of gas. It was the year we all realized that even a generational talent like Rodgers couldn't paper over every single crack in a roster that was aging in the wrong places and young in the most chaotic ones. If you followed the team that year, you remember the feeling of waiting for a spark that never actually stayed lit.
The Knee, the Comeback, and the False Hope
It all started with the Bears. Week 1. Sunday Night Football.
Khalil Mack, who the Packers reportedly tried to trade for before he went to Chicago, was destroying Green Bay’s offensive line. Then, it happened. Rodgers went down. He got carted off. Most of us at Lambeau or watching at home figured the season was over in about thirty minutes. DeShone Kizer came in, and it was a disaster.
Then Rodgers came back out. On one leg.
The comeback he staged in that second half was legendary stuff. It’s the kind of game that wins MVPs. The 75-yard touchdown pass to Geronimo Allison? The game-winner to Randall Cobb? It was magic. But looking back, that win was the worst thing that could have happened for the 2018 Green Bay Packers. It created a mask. It made everyone think that as long as Number 12 was under center, the dysfunction didn't matter.
But the injury was real. Rodgers wasn't mobile for the rest of the year. He threw for 4,442 yards and 25 touchdowns with only two interceptions, which sounds elite on paper. In reality? He was "throw-away" happy. He was avoiding hits because his leg was a mess, leading to a league-leading number of intentional throwaways. The rhythm was gone. The offense felt clunky, predictable, and—dare I say—boring.
The Mike McCarthy Friction
By mid-season, the tension between McCarthy and Rodgers was the worst kept secret in the NFL. You could see it on the sidelines. The play-calling felt like it was stuck in 2011. While the rest of the league, led by guys like Sean McVay and Kyle Shanahan, was embracing pre-snap motion and creative spacing, the Packers were still running "ISO" routes and hoping their receivers could just beat their man.
They couldn't.
💡 You might also like: CIF Central Section Baseball Playoffs 2025: Why Division 1 Was Pure Chaos
Davante Adams was incredible, obviously. He had 111 catches for nearly 1,400 yards. But behind him? It was a rotating door of rookies and guys who weren't ready. Marquez Valdes-Scantling and Equanimeous Strown showed flashes, but they were rookies. They made rookie mistakes. In a McCarthy system that demanded perfect timing and "mind-meld" chemistry with the QB, that was a recipe for 3rd-and-longs.
The Defense Under Mike Pettine
This was the first year of the Mike Pettine era. Dom Capers was finally out. There was hope that the "Palace Guard" defense would finally stop giving up 400 yards a game.
And for a while, it was actually better.
The Packers spent big—well, big for them at the time—on Jimmy Graham (who was a disappointment) and brought in Tramon Williams for a second stint. But the real story was the young guys. Jaire Alexander was a fireball. You could tell immediately that he was a foundational piece. Kenny Clark was blossoming into a premier nose tackle.
Still, the stats were middling. They finished 22nd in points allowed. They couldn't get off the field in crunch time. Think back to the Seattle game on Thursday Night Football. Or the Rams game where Ty Montgomery took the ball out of the end zone when he was told not to, fumbled, and effectively ended the comeback attempt.
That Montgomery fumble in Los Angeles was a microcosm of the 2018 Green Bay Packers. It was a lack of discipline. It was a "me-first" mistake in a "we-first" organization. He was traded to the Ravens two days later.
🔗 Read more: NFL Live Updates and Scores: What Really Happened This Wild Card Weekend
Why the Cardinals Game Changed Everything
December 2, 2018. A dreary, snowy day at Lambeau Field. The Arizona Cardinals were a bad football team. They came into Green Bay with two wins. Two!
The Packers lost 20-17.
Mason Crosby, usually the most reliable guy in the building, missed a 49-yard field goal as time expired. But the loss wasn't on him. The offense was stagnant. The energy was dead. It was the first time in the Rodgers era that Lambeau felt like a place where opponents weren't afraid to play.
Mark Murphy didn't even wait for the season to end. McCarthy was fired that evening. It was jarring. The Packers don't fire coaches mid-season. They just don't. But the 2018 Green Bay Packers had become so unwatchable, so disconnected, that the front office felt they had no choice. Joe Philbin took over as the interim, and while they beat the Falcons the next week, the soul of the season was already gone.
The Stat That Tells the Story
If you want to know why this team failed, look at their road record.
Zero wins.
Well, technically they beat the Jets in Week 16 in a meaningless overtime thriller where Rodgers went supernova, but for the vast majority of the season, they were 0-7 on the road. You cannot be a playoff team if you can't win in someone else's stadium. They were fragile. When things went wrong away from home, they folded.
The Unsung Narrative: The Roster Transition
Brian Gutekunst was in his first year as General Manager. He was trying to pivot away from the "Draft and Develop" purism of Ted Thompson. He traded back in the first round, snagged Jaire Alexander, and picked up an extra 2019 first-rounder in the process (which became Darnell Savage).
In hindsight, the 2018 Green Bay Packers were a "bridge" team.
- Aaron Jones was held back. For some reason, McCarthy refused to give Jones the bulk of the carries, splitting time with Jamaal Williams. Jones averaged 5.5 yards per carry that year. Every time he touched the ball, something good happened. Yet, he only had 133 carries the whole season.
- The Tight End vacuum. Paying Jimmy Graham $30 million over three years was a swing and a miss. He had two touchdowns. He wasn't the red-zone threat he was in New Orleans or Seattle.
- The Bashaud Breeland saga. Remember him? A mid-season pickup who actually played well. It showed that the Packers were finally willing to look outside the building for help, even if it was too late.
Lessons from the 2018 Green Bay Packers
So, why does this specific, mediocre season matter now? It matters because it forced the organization to modernize. Without the failure of 2018, you don't get the hiring of Matt LaFleur. You don't get the "Smith Bros" free agency splurge in 2019. You don't get the offensive shift that led to Rodgers winning two more MVPs.
The 2018 Green Bay Packers were a necessary disaster. They proved that talent alone isn't a strategy.
If you're looking back at this season for research or just to settle a bar bet, remember these three things:
- Don't ignore the road splits. If a team can't win on the road by October, they're cooked. The 2018 Packers proved that chemistry issues travel poorly.
- Health isn't just "active" or "inactive." Rodgers played 16 games, but he wasn't "Rodgers" for 14 of them. A hobbled superstar often changes a scheme for the worse because the coach tries to protect them rather than attack the opponent.
- The "Lame Duck" coach effect is real. Once the locker room sensed McCarthy was on the hot seat, the urgency vanished.
If you're analyzing a current team that looks like the 2018 Packers—high-end QB, stale coaching, and a struggle to beat bad teams—prepare for a coaching change. History doesn't repeat, but it definitely rhymes. The best way to move forward is to audit the current "scheme-to-talent" fit. If your best playmaker (like 2018 Aaron Jones) isn't getting the ball 15-20 times a game, something is fundamentally broken in the coaching room.
Check the 2018 injury reports compared to the 2019 jump in performance. It shows that a "lost" season is often just a transition period in disguise.