If you look back at the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket, it honestly feels like a fever dream. Seriously. Think about it. We had the "best team in the league" getting swept in the first round by a wild card. We had a guy named Jake Guentzel—who most casual fans couldn't pick out of a lineup in October—scoring goals like he was prime Mike Bossy. Then there was the whole "Nashville catfish" thing. It was a weird time for hockey, but man, was it ever entertaining. The bracket itself started as a structured grid of potential outcomes and ended up looking like a Jackson Pollock painting by the time Sidney Crosby hoisted his third Stanley Cup.
Most people remember the Pittsburgh Penguins winning back-to-back titles, which was a massive historical feat. But that’s the bird’s-eye view. When you zoom in on the actual 2017 playoffs nhl bracket, the granular details are what actually make it special. It was the year the "Era of Parity" finally felt real. It wasn't just about the heavyweights anymore. It was about surviving.
The First Round Chaos That Broke Every Bracket
Let's talk about the Chicago Blackhawks. They were the top seed in the West. People expected them to sleepwalk through the Nashville Predators. Instead, Pekka Rinne turned into a literal brick wall. Nashville didn't just win; they humiliated Chicago. A sweep. Four games and done. That single result basically set fire to 90% of the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket entries across the globe. If you had Nashville winning that series in your office pool, you were either a genius or a liar. Probably a liar.
Meanwhile, in the East, the Washington Capitals were doing their usual "dominant regular season followed by playoff anxiety" routine. They eventually got past Toronto, but it took six games and a lot of sweat. The Toronto Maple Leafs were just babies then—Auston Matthews and Mitch Marner were rookies. Nobody expected them to push the Presidents' Trophy winners that hard. It showed a shift in power. The young guns were coming for the throne, even if they weren't quite ready to take it yet.
Then you had the Columbus Blue Jackets against the Penguins. Columbus had a historic regular season, but they ran into the buzzsaw. It was a reminder that the regular season and the postseason are two different sports. The Blue Jackets played hard, but the Penguins had that "we've been here before" aura. It’s hard to beat a team that doesn't panic when they go down a goal.
🔗 Read more: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
Re-evaluating the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket mid-way through
By the time the second round hit, the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket was wide open. The Rangers and Senators were battling it out in a series that felt like it lasted three years. Jean-Gabriel Pageau scored four goals in a single game. Four! That’s the kind of random heroics that define this specific year. Erik Karlsson was playing on one leg—literally, he had hairline fractures in his foot—and he was still the best player on the ice. It was gutsy. It was gross. It was playoff hockey.
The Anaheim Ducks and Edmonton Oilers gave us a series for the ages in the West. This was Connor McDavid’s true introduction to the playoff stage. But the Ducks were veterans. They knew how to manipulate the refs, how to grind down a young superstar, and how to come back from the dead. Game 5 of that series? The "Comeback on Katella"? Anaheim scored three goals in the final three minutes to tie it and then won in OT. If you turned that game off early, you missed one of the most statistically improbable events in NHL history.
Why the Penguins actually won (It wasn't just Crosby)
Look, Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin are legends. We know this. But look at the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket through the lens of depth. The Penguins lost their #1 defenseman, Kris Letang, before the playoffs even started. Most teams would fold. Instead, Justin Schultz stepped up. Ron Hainsey—a guy who had played over 900 NHL games without ever sniffing the playoffs—suddenly became a top-pair shutdown guy.
The goaltending situation was even more insane. Matt Murray got hurt in warmups for Game 1 of the first round. Marc-Andre Fleury, who had basically been demoted to the backup role, stepped in and played like a Vezina winner for two rounds. Then, when Fleury faltered against Ottawa in the Conference Finals, Murray came back and finished the job. It was a masterclass in roster management by Mike Sullivan.
💡 You might also like: Heisman Trophy Nominees 2024: The Year the System Almost Broke
The Ottawa Senators were the ultimate "trap" team that year. Guy Boucher had them playing a 1-3-1 neutral zone trap that was boring as hell to watch but incredibly effective. They dragged the Penguins to double overtime in Game 7 of the Eastern Conference Finals. One bounce of the puck and the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket ends with Ottawa in the Finals. Chris Kunitz, who hadn't scored a goal in months, fluttering a knuckleball past Craig Anderson is the reason the Penguins dynasty stayed alive. Hockey is a game of inches, but that night it was a game of millimeters.
The Nashville Factor and the Final Stand
The Finals were Nashville vs. Pittsburgh. A #16 seed vs. a defending champ. On paper, it looked lopsided. In reality, it was a war. Nashville was missing their top center, Ryan Johansen. They were starting Frederick Gaudreau, who didn't even have a locker in the home dressing room at the start of the series. And yet, the "Smashville" atmosphere was so intense that it almost tilted the ice.
The Penguins eventually won in six games, but the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket will always be remembered for the controversial "no-goal" in Game 6. Kevin享有 Early whistle? Referee blew the play dead before the puck was poked in. It’s one of those "what if" moments that Nashville fans will talk about in bars for the next fifty years.
Lessons from a chaotic postseason
What can we actually learn from digging back into this specific year? First off, momentum is a myth until it isn't. Nashville had it, then they lost it, then they found it again. Second, goaltending is the ultimate equalizer. Pekka Rinne and Craig Anderson almost fundamentally changed the history of the league just by getting hot for six weeks.
📖 Related: When Was the MLS Founded? The Chaotic Truth About American Soccer's Rebirth
If you’re looking at your own hockey analysis or just trying to understand how to predict future brackets, remember that the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket proved that "heavy" teams—those built on grit and defensive structure—can still stifle high-flying offenses. Until they run into a team with two of the greatest centers to ever play the game, of course.
- Check the injury reports: Depth wins. The Penguins survived without Letang because they had a system that supported replacement-level players.
- Respect the Wild Card: Since 2017, we've seen more and more lower seeds make deep runs. Nashville was the blueprint.
- Watch the shot blocks: The Senators blocked an absurd amount of shots to compensate for a lack of elite talent. It works, but it’s physically unsustainable for more than three rounds.
The best way to appreciate the 2017 playoffs nhl bracket is to realize that it was the end of an era. It was the last time we saw that specific iteration of the Penguins at the peak of their powers, and the beginning of a new age where speed and youth started to overwhelm old-school grit. If you want to dive deeper into the stats, go look at the puck possession numbers for the Predators during that run. They outplayed almost everyone; they just couldn't beat the bounces in the end.
The next time you're filling out a bracket, don't just pick the favorites. Pick the team with the backup goalie who has a chip on his shoulder and the third-line winger who is due for a hot streak. That's the 2017 way.