You ever look at a box score and just assume there's a typo? Like, surely the intern at ESPN accidentally hit the "7" key too many times? That’s basically the reaction everyone had on October 22, 2016, when the final whistle blew in Lubbock.
The score was 66-59. Oklahoma won. But honestly, "winning" feels like a weird word for a game where your defense gave up 859 yards. Yes, you read that right.
Eight. Hundred. Fifty. Nine.
The 2016 Oklahoma Texas Tech matchup wasn't just a football game; it was a glitch in the Matrix. It was two of the greatest quarterbacks to ever pick up a pigskin—Baker Mayfield and Patrick Mahomes—deciding that punting was a moral failure. They played a four-hour track meet with a ball involved. If you like defense, this game was a horror movie. If you like chaos, it was the Mona Lisa.
The Night the Record Books Caught Fire
Let’s talk about Patrick Mahomes for a second. Before he was the guy on every third commercial and a three-time Super Bowl champ, he was just a skinny kid in Lubbock with a bionic arm and a death wish for his own personal safety. That night against the Sooners, Mahomes put up numbers that don't even look real in Madden.
He threw for 734 yards.
That tied the NCAA record. He also ran for another 85 yards, bringing his total offense to 819 yards. One guy. One game. 819 yards. To put that in perspective, there are entire NFL teams that don't get 819 yards of offense in three weeks combined. He threw the ball 88 times. By the fourth quarter, you could see him shaking out his arm like he’d just spent ten hours at a typing competition.
But here’s the kicker: he lost.
📖 Related: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
He lost because Baker Mayfield, returning to the school where he originally walked on before a messy transfer, was surgical. Baker didn't need 88 throws. He only needed 36. He completed 27 of them for 545 yards and seven touchdowns. Seven! He was playing "point guard" on grass. It was personal for Baker, and you could see it in every flex and every scream toward the Red Raider faithful.
Why Nobody Could Stop a Beach Ball
It’s easy to say "the defenses were terrible." And yeah, they kinda were. Oklahoma’s secondary was getting scorched on every play, and Texas Tech’s defensive line was basically a group of polite young men letting Joe Mixon run past them. Mixon had 263 yards rushing and 114 yards receiving. He scored five touchdowns.
But it wasn't just bad tackling. The pace was frantic.
Lincoln Riley was the offensive coordinator for OU back then. Kliff Kingsbury was running the show for Tech. These are two of the most aggressive play-callers in the history of the sport. They weren't looking for three yards and a cloud of dust. They were hunting for explosive plays on every single snap. The 2016 Oklahoma Texas Tech game featured 1,708 combined yards of offense. That is an all-time FBS record. It’s a mile of football.
The Baker vs. Mahomes Narrative
What makes this game so legendary a decade later isn't just the stats. It’s the "where are they now" factor.
- Baker Mayfield: Went on to win the Heisman, went number one overall in the NFL draft, and has had a rollercoaster career that currently has him as a legit starter in Tampa.
- Patrick Mahomes: Well, we know what happened there. He became the face of the NFL.
- Joe Mixon: Became a Pro Bowl running back.
- Dede Westbrook: Was a Heisman finalist that year and shredded Tech for 202 yards.
Seeing these guys on the same field in 2016 was like watching a Marvel movie before the CGI is added. You knew they were special, but you didn't realize they were "rewrite the history of the sport" special.
People forget that Texas Tech was actually leading or tied for a good chunk of the early going. It felt like whichever team had the ball last would win, or maybe whichever team's quarterback didn't literally collapse from exhaustion first. Mahomes was playing through a bungled shoulder and a fractured wrist. Think about that. He threw for 734 yards while physically falling apart.
👉 See also: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
The Misconception of "Bad Football"
Critics of the Big 12 used to point to this game as proof that the conference didn't play "real" football. "It’s just basketball on grass," they’d say. "No physicality."
That’s a total misunderstanding of what happened.
The 2016 Oklahoma Texas Tech game was the peak of the "Air Raid" era. It was a masterclass in spacing, timing, and exploiting leverage. If you watch the tape, it’s not always receivers running wide open because of blown assignments. A lot of it is Mahomes making throws that shouldn't be humanly possible—drifting left, throwing back across his body 50 yards downfield into a bucket. It was high-level execution that just happened to move faster than the defenders could think.
The Sooners eventually pulled away because they had a slightly more balanced attack. While Mahomes was doing everything himself, OU had Joe Mixon to take the pressure off Baker. That balance is what allowed Oklahoma to sustain drives without Baker having to throw 90 times.
A Box Score That Defies Logic
To really wrap your head around this, you have to look at the drive charts. Texas Tech had 10 possessions in the second half. They scored on almost all of them, yet they couldn't close the gap. Oklahoma scored touchdowns on five straight possessions in the second half.
It was a nightmare for the punters. Austin Seibert (OU) and Dominic Panazzolo (Tech) might as well have bought tickets and sat in the stands. They were the most irrelevant people in Lubbock that night.
The Legacy of 1,708 Yards
This game changed how we evaluate college stats. It forced people to realize that yardage alone doesn't tell the whole story, but it also cemented the Big 12 as the most entertaining circus in sports.
✨ Don't miss: OU Football Depth Chart 2025: Why Most Fans Are Getting the Roster Wrong
If you're looking for a game to show someone why college football is better than the NFL sometimes, this is the one. The NFL is polished and corporate. The 2016 Oklahoma Texas Tech game was raw, chaotic, and slightly insane. It was a game where 59 points wasn't enough to even get a "good job" in the locker room.
How to Appreciate This Game Today
If you want to go back and watch the highlights, don't just look for the touchdowns. Look at the pocket movement.
- Watch Mahomes’ footwork when the pocket collapses. He was already doing the "no-look" stuff back then.
- Look at Baker’s accuracy on deep posts. He was hitting Dede Westbrook in stride while taking hits to the chin.
- Notice the exhaustion. By the middle of the fourth quarter, the defensive linemen are basically leaning on each other just to stay upright.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Fan
Don't let people tell you this was a "bad" game because of the lack of defense. To get more out of your football viewing, try these steps:
Study the Air Raid Evolution
Check out how the concepts from this game—specifically the "mesh" and "Y-cross" concepts—are now standard in every NFL playbook. What Kingsbury and Riley were doing in 2016 is now what the Chiefs and 49ers do on Sundays.
Evaluate QB Grit
When you’re watching new prospects, look for the "Mahomes Factor" from this game. It's not just the arm talent; it's the willingness to keep firing when you're down two scores in a hostile environment. Mahomes never looked like he thought he would lose, even when his defense was a sieve.
Respect the Conditioning
Next time you’re at the gym, try to imagine sprinting or throwing a heavy object 88 times in three hours under intense pressure. The sheer physical output of the 2016 Oklahoma Texas Tech game is an athletic marvel that gets overshadowed by the scoreboard.
Check the Context
Remember that Oklahoma went on to win the Big 12 and the Sugar Bowl that year. This game was a turning point. It proved they could survive a shootout, which they eventually had to do against teams like West Virginia later that season. For Tech, it was the "what if" game—what if they had just three or four more stops? Patrick Mahomes might have a Heisman on his mantle right now.
This wasn't just a game. It was a fever dream in West Texas that we're all still trying to wake up from.