The 2009 St. Louis Cardinals roster is a weird time capsule. Honestly, if you look at the stats now, it feels like a fever dream where one guy was playing a completely different sport than everyone else on the planet. That guy was Albert Pujols. He didn’t just win the MVP; he basically owned the National League. But when you dig into the actual bones of that 91-win squad, you realize it was a masterclass in "Tony La Russa baseball"—a mix of aging legends, reclamation projects, and a pitching staff that somehow defied the laws of physics under Dave Duncan.
They won the NL Central by 7.5 games. It wasn’t even close by September.
But there’s a catch. Most people remember the 2009 season as a success because they returned to the playoffs after a two-year drought. Others remember it as a massive "what if" because they got absolutely steamrolled by the Dodgers in the NLDS. It was a team built for the regular season grind, specifically designed to beat up on the Cubs and Brewers, but it lacked that late-inning explosive power outside of the top three spots in the order.
The Year of the Machine: Albert Pujols at His Peak
Let's talk about 2009 Albert. It’s arguably the greatest individual offensive season in Cardinals history, and yeah, I'm counting Hornsby and Musial in that conversation. He hit .327. He led the league with 47 home runs. He had a 1.101 OPS.
Think about that.
The league average OPS that year was around .750. Pujols was essentially two players in one body.
Teams stopped pitching to him. He walked 115 times, 44 of those were intentional. It became a joke. You’d see runners on second and third with two outs, and managers would just point to first base before the pitcher even touched the rubber. He was the sun that the entire St. Louis solar system orbited around.
Ryan Ludwick and Ludwick’s 22 homers helped, but the real protection came from a mid-season trade that changed the franchise's trajectory for the next half-decade. John Mozeliak, the GM, pulled the trigger on a deal for Matt Holliday in July. Before Holliday arrived, the offense was anemic whenever Pujols wasn't at the plate. After the trade? Holliday hit .353 in 63 games for the Birds on the Bat. It was the perfect pairing, even if Holliday’s 2009 is forever marred by that infamous dropped fly ball in the playoffs.
📖 Related: New Jersey Giants Football Explained: Why Most People Still Get the "Home Team" Wrong
A Rotation Held Together by Dave Duncan’s Magic
If Pujols was the heart, the starting rotation was the spine. And it was a rigid one.
Adam Wainwright and Chris Carpenter were the best 1-2 punch in baseball that year. Period.
Wainwright won 19 games and finished third in the Cy Young voting. Carpenter, coming back from years of injury hell, actually finished second in the Cy Young voting with a 2.24 ERA. It’s rare to see two teammates dominate like that. They were competitive about it, too. They pushed each other. If Carp threw eight scoreless on Tuesday, Waino felt like he had to go nine on Wednesday.
Behind them? It got a bit more "creative."
Joel Pineiro was a sinkerball machine that year, tossing 214 innings. He didn't strike anyone out—seriously, his K/9 was a measly 4.4—but he induced ground balls like he was paid by the out. Dave Duncan, the legendary pitching coach, had this uncanny ability to take guys like Pineiro or Kyle Lohse and turn them into reliable workhorses by simply telling them to throw the ball down in the zone and let the defense work.
The Weird Parts of the 2009 St. Louis Cardinals Roster
People forget how many "random" players got significant playing time on this team.
Remember Brendan Ryan? He was the starting shortstop. He hit .292 and played defense like a wizard, but he had zero power. Then there was the catching situation. Yadier Molina was already the best defensive catcher in the game, but he hadn't quite found his offensive stroke yet. He hit .293, which was great, but with only 6 homers.
👉 See also: Nebraska Cornhuskers Women's Basketball: What Really Happened This Season
The bench was a revolving door of "wait, he played for them?" names:
- Khalil Greene (who struggled mightily with anxiety and injuries)
- Julio Lugo
- Mark DeRosa (a huge trade acquisition who was unfortunately playing with a shredded wrist)
- Rick Ankiel (in his final full season as a primary outfielder for STL)
Ankiel’s story is always incredible, but by 2009, the magic was fading. He hit 11 homers but struck out a ton. You could feel the transition happening. The "Old Guard" of the 2004-2006 era was mostly gone, replaced by a bridge crew that was trying to keep the window open.
Why the Postseason Was Such a Disaster
On paper, the 2009 Cardinals should have made a deep run. They had the MVP. They had the two best pitchers in the league. They had Matt Holliday.
Then the NLDS happened.
The Dodgers swept them. 3-0. It was brutal to watch.
The defining moment—the one Cardinals fans still see when they close their eyes—is Matt Holliday losing a line drive in the towels at Dodger Stadium. It was the second game. The Cardinals were up 2-1 in the 9th inning. Two outs. Bases empty. James Loney hits a liner. Holliday, wearing sunglasses at night for some reason, loses it. The ball hits his stomach.
The Dodgers rallied. They won. The Cardinals' spirit seemed to break right then and there.
✨ Don't miss: Nebraska Basketball Women's Schedule: What Actually Matters This Season
That series exposed the roster's one true weakness: the bullpen. Ryan Franklin had been an All-Star closer that year (38 saves), but he wasn't a "strikeout guy." In the postseason, when you need to miss bats, the Cardinals' strategy of "pitch to contact" backfired.
The Legacy of the 2009 Squad
We shouldn't look at 2009 as a failure.
It was the year the Cardinals re-established themselves as the kings of the Central. It was the year we realized Adam Wainwright was a true ace. Most importantly, it was the year that convinced the front office that Matt Holliday was a franchise cornerstone, leading to his massive seven-year contract that winter.
Without the 2009 foundation, the 2011 World Series run doesn't happen.
The 2009 stl cardinals roster was a bridge. It bridged the gap between the Jim Edmonds/Scott Rolen era and the era of the "Gritty Birds" of the 2010s. It was a team of extremes—the extreme greatness of Pujols and Carpenter, mixed with a bunch of guys just trying to hold their spots in the Bigs.
What You Can Learn From This Roster Today
If you’re a student of the game or just a fan looking back, there are some pretty clear takeaways from how this team was built:
- Stars matter, but depth wins titles. The 2009 team had the best stars in the world but a thin bench and a shaky bullpen. In a short series, that gets exposed.
- The "Duncan Effect" is real. Pitching to contact works in the regular season (162 games) because of the law of averages. In the playoffs, you need "stuff."
- Capitalize on peaks. 2009 was the absolute peak of Albert Pujols. The fact that they didn't get him a ring that year is one of the biggest missed opportunities in St. Louis sports history.
If you're looking for more info on this era, check out the Baseball-Reference page for the 2009 Cardinals to see just how insane the gap was between Pujols' WAR and everyone else's. Also, look up Dave Duncan’s coaching philosophy—it explains why guys like Joel Pineiro suddenly looked like Greg Maddux for exactly twelve months.
For your next step, go back and watch the highlights of the July 2009 series against the Cubs. It was the peak of the rivalry that decade, and it perfectly encapsulates why that specific roster was so beloved in the Midwest, despite the ugly October exit.