Why the 1997 Green Bay Packers Are Still the Biggest What-If in Wisconsin Sports History

Why the 1997 Green Bay Packers Are Still the Biggest What-If in Wisconsin Sports History

You know the feeling. It’s that nagging, low-level itch at the back of your brain that tells you something wasn't quite right. For anyone who bled green and gold in the late nineties, the 1997 Green Bay Packers are basically the personification of that itch.

They were supposed to be a dynasty. Honestly, they were a dynasty in every sense except for the hardware.

Coming off a Super Bowl XXXI win where Desmond Howard basically teleported across the Superdome turf, the 1997 squad looked even better on paper. Brett Favre was at the absolute peak of his "gunslinger" powers, slinging balls into windows the size of a microwave. Mike Holmgren was the undisputed professor of the West Coast Offense. The defense was a brick wall painted in forest green.

But then, San Diego happened. Super Bowl XXXII happened. John Elway’s "helicopter" happened.

The Absolute Dominance of the 1997 Green Bay Packers Regular Season

If you look at the stats, the '97 Packers didn't just win; they bullied people. They finished 13-3. They went 8-0 at Lambeau Field, a place that felt more like a gladiator pit than a football stadium back then.

Favre threw for 3,867 yards and 35 touchdowns. That earned him his third consecutive MVP award, a feat that still feels a bit surreal when you think about the level of competition in the league at the time. He wasn't just playing; he was improvising a masterpiece every Sunday. You’ve got to remember that this was the era before the league-wide passing explosion. 35 touchdowns in 1997 was a massive number.

The supporting cast was ridiculous. Dorsey Levens stepped out of Edgar Bennett’s shadow and put up over 1,400 rushing yards. Robert Brooks was back from injury, and Antonio Freeman was transforming into a genuine superstar.

💡 You might also like: What Channel is Champions League on: Where to Watch Every Game in 2026

Defensively? Fritz Shurmur was a wizard.

They had the #5 ranked defense in the league. Reggie White, the Minister of Defense, was 36 years old but still playing like he was 24, racking up 11 sacks. Alongside him, Santana Dotson and Gilbert Brown—the "Grave Digger"—made running the ball against Green Bay a miserable experience.

Why the Postseason Felt Like a Coronation

The playoffs started, and it honestly felt like a formality.

The Packers dismantled the Tampa Bay Buccaneers 21-7 in the Divisional Round. Then came the NFC Championship game against the San Francisco 49ers. At 3Com Park, in the mud and the rain, Green Bay just choked the life out of Steve Young and Jerry Rice.

Winning 23-10 in San Francisco was the statement. It was the "we are the kings of the NFC" moment.

Heading into the Super Bowl against the Denver Broncos, the 1997 Green Bay Packers were 11.5-point favorites. Eleven and a half! In a Super Bowl! People weren't asking if the Packers would win; they were asking by how many points. The AFC had lost 13 straight Super Bowls. They were considered the "junior varsity" conference.

📖 Related: Eastern Conference Finals 2024: What Most People Get Wrong

The Night Everything Went Sideways in San Diego

January 25, 1998. Qualcomm Stadium.

Most people remember the helicopter run by Elway. It’s the iconic image. But if you really watch the tape of that game, that wasn't why the Packers lost.

They lost because they couldn't stop Terrell Davis.

Davis ran for 157 yards and three touchdowns, and he did a huge chunk of that while suffering from a migraine so bad he could barely see. The Packers' defense, so stout all year, couldn't find an answer for Mike Shanahan’s zone-blocking scheme. It was a schematic nightmare.

The game was tied 24-24 in the fourth quarter. The Packers had the momentum. But then, a series of small disasters. Favre threw an interception. The defense couldn't get off the field.

Then came the final drive. Favre had the ball with 1:45 left, trailing 31-24. He moved the ball to the Denver 31. This was the moment. This was where the legend of the 1997 Green Bay Packers was supposed to be cemented with a back-to-back title.

👉 See also: Texas vs Oklahoma Football Game: Why the Red River Rivalry is Getting Even Weirder

Instead, three straight incompletions. On 4th and 6, Favre tried to force a pass to Mark Chmura. It fell incomplete.

Game over. Dynasty dead.

The Fallout Nobody Saw Coming

Looking back, that loss was a butterfly effect moment for the entire franchise.

If they win that game, do they win a third? Probably. They had the talent. But instead, the "aura" broke. Mike Holmgren left for Seattle a year later. Fritz Shurmur tragically passed away in 1999. The coaching staff dispersed, and while Favre stayed elite, the team around him started to fluctuate.

The 1997 season remains a masterclass in "on any given Sunday." It’s a reminder that even the most talented, MVP-led rosters are vulnerable to a hot running back and a well-timed migraine.

Actionable Takeaways for History Buffs and Fans

To truly understand the weight of the 1997 season, you should look beyond the Super Bowl box score.

  • Study the West Coast Offense: Watch film of the 1997 NFC Championship game. It is perhaps the best example of Mike Holmgren’s offensive philosophy at its peak—surgical, rhythmic, and unstoppable.
  • Analyze the Zone Block: If you’re a football nerd, look at how the Broncos' offensive line moved the Packers' defensive front. It changed how NFL teams drafted defensive tackles for the next decade.
  • Contextualize the MVP: Research the 1997 MVP voting. Favre shared the award with Barry Sanders. Seeing those two names together gives you a real sense of the "Goliaths" that ruled the league that year.
  • Visit the Hall of Fame: If you're ever in Green Bay, the Packers Hall of Fame has specific exhibits on this era. Seeing the jerseys and the "ice bowl" mentality of that 13-3 run puts the heartbreak of the Super Bowl into perspective.

The 1997 Green Bay Packers might not have the second ring, but they remain one of the most statistically dominant and entertaining teams to ever step onto a football field. They taught a generation of fans that in sports, nothing is guaranteed—not even when you have the best player in the world under center.