It was cold. That’s the first thing anyone who was at Three Rivers Stadium on January 11, 1998, will tell you. But it wasn’t just the Pittsburgh winter biting through the starter jackets; it was the realization that the Steelers were letting a Super Bowl slip right through their fingers. The 1997 AFC Championship Game is one of those moments in NFL history that feels like a glitch in the matrix for anyone who followed the 90s era of the AFC. You had Bill Cowher’s smash-mouth Steelers, the heavy favorites, hosting a Denver Broncos team led by John Elway, a guy who—at that point—everyone thought was destined to be the legendary quarterback who just couldn't win the big one.
People forget how much was on the line here. This wasn't just a game; it was a collision of legacies. If Pittsburgh wins, Cowher gets his second Super Bowl trip in three years and Kordell Stewart, the man they called "Slash," becomes the undisputed future of the league. If Denver wins, Elway finally gets back to the dance for the first time since the 80s.
Honestly, the Steelers should have won. On paper, they were built for this. But football isn't played on paper, and the 24-21 final score remains a scar on the psyche of Western Pennsylvania.
The Day Kordell Stewart Learned a Hard Lesson
Kordell Stewart was a phenomenon. In 1997, he was doing things that modern fans see in Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen, but back then, it was alien. He’d thrown for over 3,000 yards and rushed for nearly 600. He was the dual-threat prototype. But in the 1997 AFC Championship Game, the lights might have been just a bit too bright for a first-year starter.
The interceptions were killers. Three of them.
The first one was a dagger. Pittsburgh was down 7-0 but moving the ball. Stewart drops back and looks for Yancey Thigpen in the end zone. Instead of a touchdown, he finds Denver's Ray Crockett. It wasn't just a turnover; it was a momentum evaporator. You could feel the air leave the stadium. Later, in the second quarter, another pick led to a Denver touchdown. Stewart was talented, maybe the most talented guy on the field that day, but he was playing against a Denver defense that smelled blood.
He finished the day with those three interceptions and a lost fumble. You can’t do that against a Mike Shanahan-led offense. You just can't. Despite the mistakes, the Steelers were still in it late. That’s how good the rest of that roster was. Jerome Bettis was hammering away, the "Steel Curtain" (the 90s version, anyway) was hitting hard, but every time Pittsburgh built a bridge, a turnover burned it down.
John Elway and the "Road Warrior" Broncos
Denver wasn't supposed to be there. Not really. They were a Wild Card team. They had to go through Kansas City just to get to Pittsburgh. The narrative around Elway was exhausting by 1997. "He can't win the big one." "He's too old."
🔗 Read more: 2024 dynasty rookie mock draft: Why the Consensus is Often Wrong
Elway wasn't actually spectacular in this game, stats-wise. He went 18-of-31 for 210 yards, two touchdowns, and a pick. But he was efficient. When it mattered, he found Ed McCaffrey or Shannon Sharpe. Shannon Sharpe was a nightmare for the Steelers' secondary all afternoon. He had this way of finding the soft spot in the zone and then chirping loud enough for the fans in the nosebleeds to hear him.
The real hero for Denver, though, was Terrell Davis.
Davis was a workhorse. He finished with 139 yards and a score. In the cold, on the turf of Three Rivers, he just kept churning. He didn't care about the Steelers' reputation. The Broncos’ zone-blocking scheme was a masterpiece of lateral movement that left Pittsburgh’s linebackers guessing. It was a tactical clinic by Shanahan. Denver didn't beat the Steelers with brute force; they beat them with angles and timing.
The Coaching Chess Match: Cowher vs. Shanahan
Bill Cowher is a legend, but he got outcoached in the 1997 AFC Championship Game. It’s hard for Steelers fans to admit, but it’s true.
Pittsburgh’s defensive strategy was aggressive—too aggressive. They kept trying to blitz Elway, but the Broncos were prepared. They used screen passes and quick slants to neutralize the pressure. On the other side, the Steelers' offense felt frantic. They had the Bus—Jerome Bettis—who was having a decent day, but they kept putting the game on Kordell’s arm.
There was a moment in the second quarter where it felt like Pittsburgh was regaining control. They had a 14-10 lead. But then, the wheels fell off. Denver scored two touchdowns in the final minutes of the half. That’s a 14-point swing that basically decided the game. A late touchdown catch by Charles Johnson gave the Steelers hope in the fourth quarter, but the comeback fell short when Stewart’s final heave was intercepted.
Why This Game Changed the NFL
We look back at the 1997 AFC Championship Game as the turning point for the AFC. For years, the NFC had dominated the Super Bowl. It was a joke. The NFC had won 13 straight Super Bowls heading into that season. The AFC was the "junior" conference.
✨ Don't miss: Haley Van Lith: Why the Basketball World is Obsessed With Her Training
When Denver won this game and moved on to face the Packers in Super Bowl XXXII, nobody gave them a chance. But this win in Pittsburgh gave the Broncos the confidence they needed. They realized they could go into a hostile environment, against a physical team, and dictate the tempo. If Denver loses this game in Pittsburgh, John Elway probably retires without a ring. He never gets that "This one's for John" moment.
For Pittsburgh, it was the end of an era. It was the last time that specific core really had a wide-open shot at a title before the roster started to shift in the early 2000s. It also sparked a long-standing debate in Pittsburgh about whether Stewart was the right guy to lead the franchise, a debate that didn't truly end until Ben Roethlisberger arrived years later.
Surprising Details You Probably Forgot
- The Turf: Three Rivers Stadium was notorious for its "AstroTurf" which was basically green carpet over concrete. Players from both sides complained about how hard the surface was in the freezing cold.
- The Third Down Struggles: Pittsburgh went 2-for-12 on third downs. You aren't winning a championship with a 16% conversion rate.
- The Yancey Thigpen Factor: Thigpen was one of the best receivers in the league that year, but Denver’s secondary held him to just 46 yards.
- The Scoring Spurt: Denver scored 17 points in the second quarter alone. That’s the most points the Steelers defense had given up in a single quarter all season.
Actionable Takeaways for Football Historians and Fans
If you want to truly understand the impact of the 1997 AFC Championship Game, don't just look at the box score. Do this:
- Watch the "NFL Throwback" highlights on YouTube. Specifically, look at the body language of the Steelers after Kordell's end-zone interception. It’s a masterclass in how a single play can deflate a stadium.
- Analyze the Denver Zone-Blocking Scheme. This game is the blueprint for how Mike Shanahan revolutionized NFL rushing attacks. Notice how the offensive linemen move in unison.
- Compare Stewart to Modern QBs. Watch how Kordell played in '97 and compare it to the "positionless" football of today. He was 20 years ahead of his time, even if his decision-making that day was flawed.
- Visit the Heinz History Center in Pittsburgh. They have a massive Western Pennsylvania Sports Museum section that puts the Cowher era into perspective, including the heartbreak of the late 90s.
The game wasn't just a loss; it was a transition. It ended the NFC's stranglehold on the Lombardi Trophy and proved that a Wild Card team could go the distance. For Pittsburgh, it remains the great "What If?" of the Bill Cowher years.