It was weird. Honestly, there is no other way to put it. When you sit down to watch That '70s Show season 8, you aren't just watching the final lap of a legendary sitcom; you're watching a show try to breathe while its heart has been ripped out.
Topher Grace was gone. Ashton Kutcher was basically gone.
If you grew up with the Formans, the absence of Eric and Kelso felt like coming home for Thanksgiving and finding out your parents replaced your childhood bed with a treadmill. It just didn't sit right. Yet, millions of us watched anyway. We watched because we loved Red's grumpiness and Kitty’s nervous laugh, but mostly, we watched to see how they’d wrap up a decade of "hanging out."
The Randy Pearson Experiment and the Void Left by Eric
The biggest sticking point for anyone discussing That '70s Show season 8 is undoubtedly Randy. Josh Meyers is a talented guy, but the writers put him in an impossible position. He wasn't just a new character; he was a human patch kit. They tried to give him Eric’s wit and Kelso’s leading-man looks, but the chemistry was off.
It felt forced.
When Eric Forman left for Africa at the end of Season 7, the show lost its "straight man." Every great ensemble needs a center, a person whose basement everyone else is occupying. Without Eric, the basement felt like a set, not a hangout. Randy walked in with this 1970s feathered hair and a suave attitude that didn't mesh with the established loser-energy of Hyde and Fez.
Fans hated it. They still do.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
The shift changed the group dynamic from "lifelong friends" to "people who are paid to be in the same room." It's a classic TV mistake. When a lead leaves, you shouldn't try to replace the archetype; you should pivot the story. Instead, the showrunners tried to pretend the vibe hadn't shifted, which only made the change more glaringly obvious to everyone watching at home.
Why the Character Arcs Went Off the Rails
Let's talk about Jackie and Fez. This is the hill many fans are willing to die on. For seven years, the show carefully built Jackie Burkhart from a vapid cheerleader into a nuanced, albeit still shallow, woman with real feelings. Her relationship with Hyde was genuinely compelling. It was the classic "opposites attract" trope done right.
Then That '70s Show season 8 happened.
Suddenly, Hyde is married to a stripper named Samantha in a plotline that went nowhere and felt wildly out of character for a guy who was finally starting to grow up. Meanwhile, Jackie ends up with Fez.
Fez!
The creepy, candy-obsessed foreign exchange student was a great comic relief character for 150 episodes, but making him the romantic endgame for Jackie felt like a slap in the face to years of character development. It felt like the writers were just pairing off the remaining cast members because the clock was ticking. It lacked the emotional earn that the Hyde/Jackie or Eric/Donna pairings had.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
Speaking of Donna, her story in the final season is just depressing. She’s dating a guy she doesn't seem to like (Randy) while waiting for a guy who left her to go find himself in another continent. Laura Prepon did her best with the material, but Donna Pinciotti deserved a better send-off than being a side character in her own life.
The Red and Kitty Saving Grace
If there is one reason to actually rewatch That '70s Show season 8, it is Kurtwood Smith and Debra Jo Rupp. They carried the show on their backs. Red Forman's transition from a hard-nosed veteran to a man contemplating retirement—and his genuine, if grumpy, love for Kitty—remained the most consistent part of the series.
- Red’s "foot in bucket" moments remained gold.
- Kitty’s increasing reliance on "badgering" and cocktails provided the only laughs that didn't feel scripted by a machine.
- The realization that they were actually going to move to Florida (before the finale changed things) gave the season a much-needed sense of stakes.
Without them, the season would have been unwatchable. They provided the tether to the show's original DNA. When Red finally softens up just a tiny bit, it feels earned because we’ve spent eight years watching him call people "dumbasses."
The Finale: A Rare Moment of Perfection
Despite the mess that led up to it, the final episode, "That '70s Finale," is actually one of the better sitcom finales out there. It understood the assignment. It brought Topher Grace and Ashton Kutcher back for a few precious minutes, and suddenly, the magic was back.
Seeing the core group back in the Circle one last time reminded us why we liked the show in the first place.
The countdown to January 1, 1980, served as a perfect metaphor. The '70s were over, and so was the childhood of these characters. When they walk up those basement stairs for the last time and the camera lingers on the empty room, it hits hard. It doesn't matter that the previous twenty episodes were a bit of a train wreck. That final scene captures the universal feeling of leaving your youth behind.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
It’s poignant. It’s quiet. It’s real.
Lessons Learned from a Sinking Ship
Television historians and sitcom writers often look at That '70s Show season 8 as a cautionary tale. It’s the "jump the shark" moment for an entire generation of viewers. What can we actually learn from it?
First, never underestimate the power of an ensemble's chemistry. You can't just swap out parts like a Chevy engine. Second, character growth shouldn't be sacrificed for a "shocking" plot twist or an easy romantic resolution.
If you're a fan of the series and you've been avoiding the final season, my advice is to watch the first episode, skip the middle entirely, and then watch the finale. You’ll save yourself a lot of frustration while still getting the closure you need.
Next Steps for the Ultimate Fan:
If you want to dive deeper into the behind-the-scenes drama, look up the interviews with the cast regarding the transition to the final season. There's a lot of nuance regarding the contracts and the decision to keep the show going for one more year. You might also want to check out That '90s Show on Netflix to see how they handled the legacy of these characters decades later—it offers a much-needed "correction" for some of the mistakes made during the 1979-1980 timeline.