Video games love to tell you that "your choices matter." Usually, that’s a lie. You might pick between a red ending or a blue ending, but the journey stays the same. Telltale Batman The Enemy Within is the rare exception that actually followed through on the promise. It didn't just give us a different ending; it gave us two entirely different versions of the Joker based on how we treated a lonely, mentally ill man named John Doe.
It’s been years since the final episode dropped, and honestly, the industry hasn't really caught up to what Telltale pulled off here.
Most Batman stories are about the mask. This one is about the man behind it. Specifically, it’s about how Bruce Wayne’s influence can either save a soul or create a monster. In the first season, Telltale played it relatively safe. They flipped the script on Thomas Wayne—making him a criminal—but the core mechanics were familiar. By the time we got to Telltale Batman The Enemy Within, the developers at the now-reborn Telltale Games (then under its original leadership) decided to take a massive swing. They bet everything on the relationship between Bruce and John Doe.
The John Doe Problem: Why This Version of Joker Works
Usually, the Joker is a force of nature. He arrives fully formed, a chaotic clown ready to burn Gotham. But in this game, he starts as a blank slate. He’s a patient at Arkham who looks up to Bruce. He’s desperate for a friend.
If you play Bruce as a cold, manipulative strategist, you're basically teaching John that people are tools. If you try to be a genuine friend, you're teaching him that he can be a hero. It’s stressful. You’re constantly walking a tightrope between your duty to the Pact (the group of villains John hangs out with) and your personal connection to this guy who is clearly one step away from a total breakdown.
Most games use "affinity meters" that feel mechanical. Here, it feels visceral. You see it in John's eyes. You hear it in Anthony Ingruber’s incredible voice performance, which transitions from high-pitched insecurity to gravelly menace with terrifying ease. When you lie to him, and he catches you, it isn't just a "John will remember that" notification. It feels like a betrayal of a real person.
🔗 Read more: Gothic Romance Outfit Dress to Impress: Why Everyone is Obsessed With This Vibe Right Now
The Divergent Finale
The fifth episode, "Same Stitch," is arguably the most ambitious piece of content Telltale ever produced. Most episodic games have a "bottleneck" where all your choices lead to the same basic climax. Not this one. Depending on how you’ve shaped John, you get one of two completely different episodes.
In the Vigilante Path, John actually tries to be a hero. He dresses like a bizarre, proto-Joker version of Batman. He tries to help you. But because he's fundamentally broken, his brand of justice is violent and terrifying. It’s a tragic deconstruction of the Batman mythos. You realize that even if he wants to be "good," his brain isn't wired for it.
In the Villain Path, he becomes the Joker we know, but with a personal grudge. He feels used. He feels like Bruce was just another bully. This version is scary because it’s Bruce’s fault. You didn't just fail to stop the Joker; you built him in a lab of your own bad decisions.
Reimagining the Rogues Gallery
It wasn't just about John Doe. Telltale Batman The Enemy Within took some huge liberties with other characters, and for the most part, they landed.
- Bane: Instead of just being a "venom-junkie," he’s a tactical powerhouse who actually feels like a physical threat to Bruce’s home life.
- Harley Quinn: This was the biggest shock. Usually, Harley is the Joker’s sidekick/victim. Here, she’s the boss. She’s the one calling the shots in the Pact, and John is the one obsessed with her. It flips the dynamic on its head and gives Harley a sense of agency we rarely see in other media.
- Amanda Waller: She is the "heroic" antagonist. She wants to save Gotham, but she’s willing to dismantle Bruce’s life to do it. Her inclusion adds a political layer that makes the stakes feel larger than just a "supervillain of the week" plot.
Working undercover with these villains as "Brucie Wayne" creates some of the best tension in the series. You’re sitting at a table with Freeze, Bane, and Harley, trying to figure out how to sabotage their plans without getting your head caved in. It’s a social stealth game as much as it is a narrative adventure.
💡 You might also like: The Problem With Roblox Bypassed Audios 2025: Why They Still Won't Go Away
The Technical Reality
Let's be real for a second. The game isn't perfect. Even in the remastered versions, the Telltale Tool engine shows its age. You’ll see the occasional stutter. Some of the animations are stiff. But the art direction—that "living comic book" aesthetic—masks a lot of the flaws.
The combat also improved significantly from the first season. The "finisher" moves where you select how to take down an enemy feel more impactful. It’s still just QTEs (Quick Time Events), but they’re choreographed with a sense of weight that makes you feel like the world's greatest combatant.
Why We Still Talk About It
The reason Telltale Batman The Enemy Within resonates in 2026 is that it treats the player like an adult. It doesn't give you easy outs. Sometimes, the "moral" choice leads to a disastrous outcome. Sometimes, being a bit of a jerk is the only way to keep your cover and save lives.
It asks a fundamental question: Is Bruce Wayne the mask, or is Batman?
By the end of the game, you're forced to make a choice about your future that feels genuinely earned. It’s not about winning or losing. It’s about what kind of legacy you want to leave in Gotham. Do you stay the Dark Knight at the cost of your sanity and your family? Or do you walk away?
📖 Related: All Might Crystals Echoes of Wisdom: Why This Quest Item Is Driving Zelda Fans Wild
Actionable Insights for Players
If you're jumping into the game for the first time or looking to revisit it, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience:
Don't try to "win" the Joker.
A lot of players try to play "perfectly" to keep John Doe from turning. Don't do that. Play as your version of Bruce Wayne. If you think Bruce would be suspicious, be suspicious. The story is much more impactful when the outcome is a natural reflection of your personality rather than a guide-following exercise.
Pay attention to Alfred.
Alfred’s arc in this season is heartbreaking. He’s suffering from PTSD after the events of the first game. If you ignore his well-being in favor of your crusade, the ending will hit you like a freight train. Check in on him. Listen to what he isn't saying.
Save your "Vigilante" run for second.
The Villain Path is the classic Batman experience, but the Vigilante Path is where the writing truly shines. It’s the more "unique" story. Seeing John Doe try to throw a Batarang while giggling like a madman is something every DC fan needs to experience at least once.
Explore the optional dialogue.
Telltale hidden some of the best character beats in the optional "examine" prompts. Specifically, the items in the Batcave and Bruce’s office change based on your choices in the first season. It’s a nice bit of continuity that rewards long-term fans.
Telltale Batman The Enemy Within stands as a high-water mark for narrative gaming. It proved that you can take a character as established as Batman and still find something new to say. By focusing on the fragility of the human mind—both Bruce’s and John’s—it created a tragedy that feels more personal than any "world-ending" threat ever could. If you haven't played it, or if you've only seen the "canon" endings in movies, you're missing out on one of the best Joker stories ever told.