Walk up Amsterdam Avenue past 100th Street and the air changes. It’s not just the standard Manhattan exhaust and roasted coffee smell anymore. Instead, you get hit with this heavy, savory cloud of searing pork and warm corn tortillas. That’s Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana. It isn’t flashy. Honestly, if you aren't looking for it, you might just walk right past the narrow storefront with its bright signage and cramped interior. But for anyone who has lived uptown for more than a week, this place is basically a landmark.
It’s tiny. I mean, really tight. You’re rubbing elbows with Columbia students, construction crews, and families who have been coming here since the 90s. There’s something deeply reassuring about a place that refuses to change its soul while the rest of the Upper West Side turns into a sterile stretch of bank branches and luxury condos. Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana stays loud, cramped, and smells like heaven.
People always ask if it’s the best Mexican food in New York. That’s a loaded question. NYC’s taco scene has exploded lately with high-end spots in Bushwick and Queens, but "best" is relative. If you want a place that feels like a neighborhood heartbeat and serves portions that could feed a small horse, this is it.
The Burrito That Actually Broke The Mold
Most people come here for the tacos, sure, but we need to talk about the burritos. They are massive. I'm talking about a two-pound situation that requires a serious strategy to finish. Unlike those chain spots where everything tastes like salt and lime juice, the burritos at Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana have a weirdly perfect structural integrity.
They don't fall apart. You’d think a tortilla stretched that thin would give up under the weight of the carnitas, beans, and rice, but it holds. The carnitas are the real MVP here. They aren’t dried out husks of pork; they’re juicy, fatty in the right ways, and have those crispy little edges that only come from a long, slow simmer in their own rendered fat.
Usually, when you go to a "fonda" (which basically means a small neighborhood eatery), you expect home-style cooking. This place delivers that. It doesn't taste like a "concept." It tastes like someone’s grandmother is in the back making sure the salsa verde has enough kick to make your eyes water but not enough to ruin your afternoon.
💡 You might also like: Virgo Love Horoscope for Today and Tomorrow: Why You Need to Stop Fixing People
What Most People Get Wrong About The Menu
Don’t just stick to the tacos al pastor. I know, they’re tempting. The pineapple is fresh and the pork is spiced right, but the menu goes deeper. A lot of folks overlook the enchiladas or the chilaquiles because they’re in a rush. Big mistake.
If you sit down—if you can actually snag one of those few coveted stools—order the mole. It’s dark, complex, and has that subtle chocolatey bitterness that balances out the heat. It’s a labor-intensive sauce that most cheap taquerias cheat on. Here? It tastes authentic.
- The Salsa Situation: They don't play around. The red sauce is smoky and deceptive. It starts slow then hits you.
- The Portions: One taco is a snack. Two is a meal. Three is a commitment you might regret if you have to walk back down to 72nd Street.
- The Vibe: It’s cash-heavy (though they’ve adapted a bit) and fast-paced. Don't stand in the doorway looking confused.
The seating is the only real "downside" if you’re looking for a romantic date spot. It’s not that. It’s a "let’s eat incredible food and get out of the way" spot. You’ll be sitting on a stool, probably bumped by someone waiting for their pickup order, and you won’t care because the food is that distracting.
Why This Place Survived The Pandemic And The Gentrification
The Upper West Side is expensive. Rent is astronomical. We’ve seen legendary diners and bakeries fold because they couldn't keep up with the overhead. Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana survived because it has a cult following that isn't built on Instagram aesthetics.
It’s built on consistency.
📖 Related: Lo que nadie te dice sobre la moda verano 2025 mujer y por qué tu armario va a cambiar por completo
You can go there today, and the Al Pastor will taste exactly like it did in 2015. In a city that’s constantly reinventing itself to be more "curated," there’s a massive amount of respect for a business that just does one thing—Mexican soul food—and does it without an ounce of pretension.
They also understand the neighborhood. They’ve kept prices relatively accessible even as ingredient costs have spiraled. It’s one of the few places left where you can get a truly filling, high-quality meal for a price that doesn't feel like a heist. That loyalty goes both ways. When the city shut down, the locals kept this place alive with delivery orders because nobody wanted to live in a world where Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana didn't exist.
The Secret Order: Getting The Most Out Of Your Visit
If you want to eat like a regular, you have to deviate from the standard order. Most people panic at the counter and just say "steak tacos." Don't be that person.
Try the Cecina. It’s salted, thinly sliced beef that has this incredible chew and deep savory flavor. Or the Lengua (tongue). I know it scares some people off, but at La Mexicana, it’s braised until it’s basically butter. It’s probably the most tender protein on the entire line.
Also, get the horchata. It’s creamy, not too sweet, and acts as a fire extinguisher for the spicy salsa.
👉 See also: Free Women Looking for Older Men: What Most People Get Wrong About Age-Gap Dating
A Quick Note On Timing
- Avoid the 12:30 PM rush: The nearby hospital staff and students descend like a swarm.
- Late night is prime: It’s a different energy. Quieter, but the kitchen is still humming.
- Takeout vs. Dine-in: If you live within 5 blocks, take it to go. The steam in the bag actually softens the tortillas just a tiny bit more, which some people (me included) actually prefer.
Acknowledging The Competition
New York is a different city than it was twenty years ago regarding Mexican cuisine. You have Michelin-starred spots downtown and the absolute taco mecca of Roosevelt Avenue in Queens. Does Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana beat a street cart in Corona? Maybe not on a "pure" taco-for-taco basis if you're a purist.
But for Manhattan? It’s in the top tier.
It fills a specific gap between "expensive sit-down restaurant" and "dubious deli taco." It’s a Fonda in the truest sense—a kitchen away from home. The spices aren't toned down for a "Manhattan palate." They don't skimp on the cilantro. They don't charge you extra for every little tiny thing. It’s honest food.
How To Master Your Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana Experience
If you're planning a trip up to 106th and Amsterdam, keep a few things in mind to make it worth the trek. This isn't a place where you'll be pampered, but it is a place where you'll be fed well.
- Check the specials board. Sometimes they have soups or seasonal tamales that aren't on the main printed menu. The Pozole, if they have it, is a cure for whatever ails you.
- Bring cash. Even if they take cards now, the small business struggle is real. Using cash helps them out and often speeds up the line.
- The "Three Salsa" Rule. Ask for all of them. Even if you think you can't handle the heat, the flavor profiles are distinct enough that you should at least dip a corner of a chip in each.
- Walk it off. After a meal here, you're going to feel heavy. Walk two blocks east to Central Park. It’s the perfect way to digest a burrito the size of a newborn baby.
Taqueria y Fonda La Mexicana represents a version of New York that is slowly being polished away. It’s gritty, it’s authentic, and it’s delicious. Whether you’re a local or just passing through the Upper West Side, it’s a mandatory stop for anyone who actually cares about the culinary fabric of this city.
Go for the food. Stay for the fact that places like this are what make New York feel like a neighborhood instead of just a collection of buildings. Don't overthink your order; just make sure whatever you get has plenty of salsa and a side of their incredibly seasoned beans. You really can't go wrong.