Let's be real. Task Force X is a mess. It’s a beautiful, chaotic, frequently tragic mess that has redefined how we look at villains in comic book movies. When people talk about Suicide Squad characters, they usually gravitate toward the neon-soaked Harley Quinn or maybe Will Smith’s Deadshot. But there is a much deeper, weirder well of lore here that both David Ayer and James Gunn tried to tap into with varying levels of success. Honestly, the evolution of these characters tells us more about the state of the DCEU (and now the DCU) than almost any other franchise under the Warner Bros. umbrella. It’s about expendability. It’s about the fact that if you’re a C-list villain like Slipknot, you’re basically a walking red shirt.
The Harley Quinn Effect and the Problem of Star Power
Margot Robbie’s Harley Quinn is the sun that the entire Suicide Squad universe revolves around. She’s the only character who feels truly "safe," which ironically goes against the entire premise of the team. In the 2016 film, Harley was framed through a very specific, stylized lens that focused heavily on her relationship with Jared Leto's Joker. It was polarizing. Fans hated the "damaged" tattoo, but they loved Robbie’s energy. By the time we got to The Suicide Squad in 2021, the character had shifted. She wasn't just a sidekick or a love interest; she was a chaotic neutral force of nature.
This presents a weird creative hurdle. When you have a character as big as Harley, the stakes for the other Suicide Squad characters start to feel lopsided. You know Rick Flag is in danger. You know Bloodsport might actually bite it. But Harley? She has plot armor thicker than the walls of Belle Reve. This tension between "anyone can die" and "we need to sell lunchboxes" is where the movies often struggle.
Deadshot vs. Bloodsport: A Tale of Two Marksmen
It's funny how history repeats itself. In 2016, we had Will Smith playing Floyd Lawton, aka Deadshot. He was the moral center—a hitman with a heart of gold who just wanted to see his daughter. Fast forward to 2021, and because of scheduling conflicts, James Gunn brought in Idris Elba to play Robert DuBois, aka Bloodsport.
They are fundamentally the same archetype.
Dad issues? Check.
Never misses? Check.
Reluctant leader? Absolutely.
👉 See also: Finding the Best One Piece Characters Photos Without Getting Scammed by AI Art
However, the nuance in their portrayals matters. Deadshot felt like a "Will Smith Character" first and a DC villain second. Bloodsport felt like a man genuinely broken by his upbringing, specifically the trauma inflicted by his father who used rats to punish him. That specific character beat—the phobia of rats—wasn't just a quirk. It was the emotional bridge to Ratcatcher 2, arguably the heart of the second film. It's those weird, specific details that make a character stick in your brain long after the credits roll.
Why the D-List Villains Actually Matter
Most people hadn't heard of Polka-Dot Man before 2021. He was a joke. A literal punchline from the Silver Age of comics. But David Dastmalchian turned Abner Krill into a tragic figure. This is the secret sauce of the Suicide Squad. You take a character with a ridiculous power—throwing glowing dots—and you ground it in body horror and maternal trauma.
When we look at the roster of Suicide Squad characters, the most successful ones are usually the ones with nothing to lose.
- King Shark (Nanaue): He’s a god. He’s a shark. He’s a "nom nom" machine. Voiced by Sylvester Stallone, he provided the levity needed to balance out the gore.
- Ratcatcher 2: Daniela Melchior’s portrayal of Cleo Cazo changed the game. She wasn't a "villain" in the traditional sense. she was just a kid trying to survive.
- Rick Flag: Joel Kinnaman’s transformation from the stiff military man in the first movie to the weary, rebellious hero in the second is one of the best character arcs in the entire DC filmography. His death at the hands of Peacemaker actually meant something because we had grown to respect his misplaced sense of duty.
The Peacemaker Pivot
We have to talk about Christopher Smith. John Cena’s Peacemaker is the ultimate "love to hate" character. He’s a walking contradiction: a man who loves peace so much he’s willing to kill men, women, and children to get it. He represents the dark side of American exceptionalism, wrapped in a shiny chrome helmet.
The brilliance of his character isn't just in the movie, but in the subsequent HBO series. It proved that these characters have legs outside of the ensemble format. By stripping away the "Squad" and focusing on the man behind the mask, DC found its most human story yet. It dealt with racism, toxic masculinity, and the desire for redemption in a way that felt earned, not forced.
The Logistics of Belle Reve and Amanda Waller
None of these characters work without Amanda Waller. Viola Davis is terrifying. She doesn't have super strength or heat vision, but she is the most dangerous person in the room. Waller is the personification of "the ends justify the means."
✨ Don't miss: Why The X-Files The Post-Modern Prometheus Is Still the Show's Weirdest Masterpiece
In the comics, created by John Ostrander, Waller was a response to the Cold War era of politics. She was the gray area. In the films, she is the constant. Whether the team is fighting an ancient witch or a giant alien starfish, Waller is in the ear of every Suicide Squad character, ready to blow their head off if they step out of line. Her lack of empathy is the engine that drives the plot. If Waller were "nice," the stakes would vanish. You need that threat of the nanite explosive to keep the audience on edge.
Common Misconceptions About the Squad
People often think the Suicide Squad is just "DC's version of the Guardians of the Galaxy." That's a mistake. The Guardians are a family. They love each other. The Squad is a work release program from hell. Most of them hate each other. They are only working together because they have a literal bomb in their neck.
Another misconception? That they have to be "evil."
Most members aren't megalomaniacs trying to take over the world. They’re bank robbers. They’re assassins. They’re people who made bad choices or were born into bad circumstances. El Diablo in the 2016 film is a prime example. He was a man consumed by guilt over his own power, seeking a redemption he didn't think he deserved. When you treat them like human beings instead of caricatures, the story becomes a lot more interesting.
The Role of Humor vs. Horror
James Gunn's take leaned heavily into the "Troma" style of filmmaking—lots of gore, lots of irreverent jokes. David Ayer's take was more "urban crime thriller." Both styles have their place, but the characters seem to thrive better when there's a bit of absurdity involved. You can't have a guy who talks to boomerangs (Captain Boomerang, played brilliantly by Jai Courtney) and take it 100% seriously. You have to lean into the weirdness.
Jai Courtney’s Boomerang is actually a great case study. He was one of the few highlights of the first film, and his sudden, unceremonious death in the opening minutes of the second film was a shock. It served a purpose: it told the audience that no one is safe. It established the rules of the world.
📖 Related: Why Based on True Story Movies Netflix Keeps Adding Are Actually Ruining Our Memories
How to Navigate the Suicide Squad Lore
If you're trying to understand these characters, don't just stick to the movies. The source material is where the real depth lies.
- Read the 1980s Ostrander Run: This is the gold standard. It’s where the modern iteration of the team was born. It deals with political intrigue and characters who are genuinely disposable.
- Watch the Animated Movies: Suicide Squad: Hell to Pay is arguably better than the 2016 live-action film. It understands the "grindhouse" nature of the concept.
- The New 52 Era: This is where the modern aesthetic of Harley Quinn and Deadshot really took shape. It’s flashier and more action-oriented.
Actionable Steps for the DC Fan
If you want to dive deeper into the world of Suicide Squad characters, start by looking at the upcoming projects. With James Gunn now heading DC Studios, the "Squad" DNA is going to be everywhere.
- Watch Peacemaker Season 1: If you haven't seen it, you're missing the best character development in the DCU.
- Track the Waller Spin-off: There is a series in development focused entirely on Amanda Waller. This will likely bridge the gap between the old DCEU and the new DCU.
- Look for Creature Commandos: This is an animated series that serves as a spiritual successor to the Squad. It features even weirder characters like Weasel and G.I. Robot. It’s the next logical step in the evolution of "monsters as heroes."
The beauty of the Suicide Squad is that the roster is infinite. Anyone can be a member. Anyone can die. In a genre that is often criticized for having no stakes, the Squad is the exception. They are the losers, the outcasts, and the villains who occasionally do something good—usually by accident. That unpredictability is why we keep coming back, even when the movies themselves are hit or miss. It's the characters that keep the lights on in Belle Reve.
Keep an eye on the casting announcements for the new DCU projects. The "next" Suicide Squad might not even be called the Suicide Squad, but the spirit of the expendable anti-hero is now a permanent fixture of superhero cinema. Focus on the character-driven stories like Peacemaker to see where the franchise is actually heading.