It starts the same way every time. You’re driving down a backroad, maybe a bit too fast because the silence of the woods is starting to feel heavy. The high beams cut through the dark, reflecting off the eyes of a deer or a raccoon. Usually, those eyes blink and vanish. But then there are the stories that don't end with a rustle in the brush. People describe a man with glowing eyes chasing car at speeds that should be physically impossible for a human being.
It sounds like a bad horror movie plot. Honestly, it’s one of those things you laugh at until you’re the one behind the wheel at 2:00 AM in rural West Virginia or the outskirts of the Pine Barrens. These accounts aren't just internet creepypasta fluff. They've been part of regional folklore for decades, often blurring the line between mass hysteria, misidentified wildlife, and genuine, unexplained encounters.
The phenomenon is weirdly specific. It’s rarely just a man standing there. He’s moving. He’s keeping pace with a vehicle doing forty, fifty, sometimes sixty miles per hour. And those eyes—usually described as a piercing, bioluminescent red or a sickly yellow—don't reflect light like a cat's eyes. They seem to generate it.
The psychology behind the man with glowing eyes chasing car
Why do we see this? Psychologists often point to something called pareidolia. That’s basically our brain’s obsession with finding patterns—specifically faces—in random data. When you’re driving at night, your peripheral vision is trash. The rods in your eyes are working overtime, but the lack of light means your brain has to fill in the gaps.
A reflection of your own dashboard lights on the side window can look like a pair of eyes following you. A tall stump with two knots in the wood? That’s a person. But pareidolia doesn't quite explain the "chasing" aspect.
There’s also the Troxler Effect. If you stare at a steady point for too long—like a dark road—surrounding images can disappear or morph. It’s a literal optical illusion. But when multiple people in a car see the same man with glowing eyes chasing car, the "it's just your brain playing tricks" argument starts to feel a little thin.
Real-world sightings: From Mothman to the Loveland Frog
We can’t talk about glowing eyes and cars without mentioning Point Pleasant, West Virginia. In 1966, two couples reported being chased by a "large flying man" with glowing red eyes. They were in a Chevy, doing over 100 mph, and the thing stayed right with them. This became the legend of the Mothman.
📖 Related: Is there actually a legal age to stay home alone? What parents need to know
It’s the gold standard for these types of encounters. The witnesses weren't just looking for clout; they were genuinely terrified. Since then, similar reports have popped up in Chicago near O'Hare Airport and throughout the Ohio River Valley.
Then you have the Loveland Frogman sightings in Ohio. In 1972, a police officer claimed to see a creature with leathery skin and glowing eyes by the side of the road. While that's more "monster" than "man," the core experience remains: a driver, a lonely road, and eyes that shouldn't be there.
What science says about "Glowing Eyes"
Biologically, humans don't have a tapetum lucidum. That’s the reflective layer behind the retina that makes dog or cat eyes shine in the dark. If you see a human-shaped figure and its eyes are glowing, science says it’s either:
- Reflective gear: Someone jogging or biking with high-visibility patches.
- Flashlights or LEDs: A person holding equipment.
- Drugs or Psychosis: Stimulants like PCP can cause extreme pupillary dilation, which might catch light in a weird way, though it wouldn't create a "glow."
- Misidentified Animals: An owl or a large bird taking flight can look like a tall man in the split second of a car's passing.
But let’s be real. None of those explanations cover a man keeping pace with a car at highway speeds. That’s where the "explanation" ends and the "mystery" begins.
Why the "Man with Glowing Eyes" trope persists
We’re obsessed with this because it taps into a primal fear of the "uncanny." It's something that looks human but acts in a way that violates the laws of physics.
Modern folklore experts, like the late Linda S. Godfrey, spent years documenting "upright canines" and "man-wolves" that people often mistake for humans with glowing eyes. Her research into the Beast of Bray Road in Wisconsin highlighted numerous accounts of people being pursued by something that looked like a man but moved like an Olympic sprinter.
👉 See also: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
There’s also a cultural element. Many Indigenous cultures have stories of "Skinwalkers" or "flesh-gaits"—beings that can mimic human form but are betrayed by their eyes or their gait. In the Southwest United States, these stories are taken incredibly seriously. If you’re driving through the Navajo Nation at night, you’ll find plenty of locals who won’t even talk about the man with glowing eyes chasing car for fear of "calling" it to them.
Practical ways to handle night-driving "encounters"
If you find yourself in a situation where you think you're being followed by something unexplained, your brain is going to go into a "fight or flight" loop. Here is what you actually need to do to stay safe, regardless of whether it's a ghost or a guy in a reflective vest.
Don't swerve. The biggest danger in these sightings isn't the entity; it's the ditch. People see something weird, jerk the wheel, and end up in a rollover. Keep your eyes on the road ahead of you.
Check your mirrors, but don't obsess. Glancing back is natural. Fixating on the rearview mirror takes your attention away from where the car is actually going. If something is "chasing" you, looking at it won't make it stop, but looking away might keep you on the pavement.
Use your technology. If you have a dashcam, great. Don't try to grab your phone to film while driving 60 mph. Most "paranormal" videos are blurry precisely because the driver was panicking. If the footage captures it, it captures it.
Verify the "Glow." If the eyes are steady and rhythmic, it might be a bicycle reflector. If they bob up and down, it’s a gait. If they disappear and reappear, it’s likely an animal blinking or moving through brush.
✨ Don't miss: Why Every Mom and Daughter Photo You Take Actually Matters
The role of Dashcams and "Citizen Science"
In the last ten years, the number of reports has actually gone up, but the "evidence" remains shaky. You'd think with everyone having a 4K camera in their pocket, we'd have a clear shot of the man with glowing eyes chasing car by now.
Instead, we get "blobsquatch" videos—grainy, shaky footage that could be anything from a bear to a prankster in a suit. This suggests one of two things: either the phenomenon is rare enough to dodge cameras, or our eyes are much better at being tricked than lenses are.
Experts in digital forensics often point out that "eye glow" in videos is frequently just lens flare or "backscatter"—dust or insects catching the infrared light from a camera's night-vision mode. This is a huge factor in why so many "paranormal" YouTube channels are filled with what look like glowing orbs or eyes.
Actionable steps for your next night drive
If you're fascinated by these stories and want to explore the "haunted" roads where these sightings occur—like Clinton Road in New Jersey or Kelly Road in Pennsylvania—do it smartly.
- Install a high-quality 4K dashcam. Look for one with a high dynamic range (HDR) to handle the contrast between dark woods and bright headlights. This is the only way to objectively review what you saw later.
- Carry a high-lumen spotlight. Most car headlights only reach about 160 to 250 feet. A handheld LED searchlight can cut through the dark much further to identify if that "man" is actually just a reflective road sign or a neighbor out for a late walk.
- Study local wildlife. Know what a deer's eyes look like versus an owl's or a coyote's. Understanding "eye shine" colors can debunk 90% of "glowing eye" sightings instantly. Red is usually birds or some rodents; green/yellow is typically deer or hounds.
- Verify the speed. If you think you're being "chased," look at your speedometer. If you're doing 15 mph, a person can keep up. If you're doing 45 mph and they're still there, that’s when you have a story worth telling.
Fear is a powerful filter. It turns a stray dog into a monster and a hitchhiker into a ghost. Whether the man with glowing eyes chasing car is a literal entity or a product of our ancient, survival-focused brains, the experience is real to the person behind the wheel. Drive safe, keep your high beams on, and maybe don't look too long into the trees when you're alone on the road.
Final Insight: Most sightings of "glowing eyes" are debunked by checking the height of the light source. If the "eyes" are four feet off the ground, it's an animal. If they are six feet or higher and moving at vehicle speeds, you are either looking at a very rare optical illusion or a legend in the making. Your best defense is a calm head and a clear path forward.