You’re driving up Highway 61, the North Shore of Minnesota stretching out to your right, and you finally hit Grand Marais. It’s cold. Even in July, that Lake Superior wind has a bite that makes you question your wardrobe choices. But there’s a line forming outside a small, unassuming building with a giant bear on the roof. People aren’t waiting for hot coffee; they’re waiting for custard. Specifically, they’re waiting to see what the Spelunkers flavor of the day is before they even look at the menu.
Spelunkers—officially known as Spokengear and its sibling shop, World’s Best Donuts, though locals just point toward the custard—isn’t your typical ice cream stand. It’s an institution. If you’ve never been, the "flavor of the day" system is the heartbeat of the place. It dictates the mood of the town.
The Cult of Frozen Custard in a Sub-Arctic Climate
Grand Marais is a quirky place. It’s an arts colony, a fishing village, and a gateway to the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW). It feels rugged. So, why is everyone obsessed with a refined, velvety frozen custard? Because it’s high-quality fat. Honestly, when the temperature drops, your body craves the density that only real custard provides.
Standard ice cream is pumped with air. Custard? It’s made with egg yolks and has a much lower "overrun" (the technical term for air bubbles). This results in a heavy, silky texture that doesn't melt the instant it hits your tongue. At Spelunkers, they take this seriously. They don't just throw some syrup in a machine. They rotate a calendar of flavors that keeps people refreshing their social media feeds like they’re waiting for concert tickets.
Tracking Down the Spelunkers Flavor of the Day
If you’re looking for the flavor right now, you usually have to do a bit of digital sleuthing or just show up. They aren't always great at updating a static website because, frankly, they’re too busy serving crowds. The most reliable way is checking their Instagram or Facebook stories.
📖 Related: London to Canterbury Train: What Most People Get Wrong About the Trip
Local tip: if you’re staying at one of the lodges nearby like Bearskin or Gunflint, the staff usually knows the schedule for the week. They have their favorites. Some days it’s a classic Vanilla or Chocolate, but the real magic happens when they get weird with it.
The Heavy Hitters
One day it might be Salted Caramel, which hits that perfect balance of savory and sweet. Another day, you might walk into a Marionberry whirlwind. For the uninitiated, Marionberries are like a cross between a blackberry and a raspberry but with a deeper, more complex tartness. When that’s the Spelunkers flavor of the day, the line usually wraps around the block.
Then there’s the Espresso flavor. It’s a favorite for the hikers who just crawled out of the woods after five days in a canoe. It’s punchy. It’s rich. It’s basically a caffeine-infused hug.
Why the "Spelunker" Name Matters
You might be wondering why a custard shop is named after cave explorers. It’s a nod to the adventurous spirit of the North Shore. "Spelunking" refers to exploring caves, and while there aren't massive limestone caverns right in Grand Marais, the rugged basalt cliffs and sea caves along Lake Superior are legendary.
👉 See also: Things to do in Hanover PA: Why This Snack Capital is More Than Just Pretzels
The shop is actually part of the Spokengear family. It’s a bike shop, a frame-building workshop, and a custard stand all rolled into one. It’s a weird synergy that works perfectly in a town where people spend $5,000 on a mountain bike but still want to eat a giant bowl of sugar and cream.
The Logistics of Your Visit
Don’t expect a massive seating area inside. It’s small. Most people grab their dish or cone and walk over to the harbor. Watching the ore boats or the sailboats while eating a Spelunkers flavor of the day is the quintessential Minnesota experience.
Wait times can be brutal. 20 minutes is common on a Saturday. Is it worth it? Yeah. Mostly because the texture is so vastly different from anything you’d get at a Dairy Queen or a grocery store. It’s served at a slightly warmer temperature than hard-scoop ice cream, which means your taste buds actually register the flavor instead of just going numb from the cold.
Pricing and Portions
It’s not cheap, but it’s fair. You’re paying for the high butterfat content and the local labor.
✨ Don't miss: Hotels Near University of Texas Arlington: What Most People Get Wrong
- Small: Perfect for most humans.
- Large: Be prepared for a nap afterward.
- The "Flight": If you can’t decide, sometimes they offer a way to sample, though the daily flavor is usually the star of the show.
What Most People Get Wrong
People often confuse Spelunkers with the "World's Best Donuts" down the street. While they are separate entities, they exist in a sort of symbiotic relationship. A common "pro move" is to buy a plain cake donut from the donut shop and then bring it over to Spelunkers to use as a vessel for the custard. It’s a calorie bomb. It’s also genius.
Another misconception is that they only do custard. They actually have a pretty solid coffee program and some great gear. But let’s be real: 90% of the foot traffic is there for the daily rotate.
Planning Your North Shore Trip Around the Menu
If you are a true enthusiast, you don't just show up. You plan. If you see Blueberry Cheesecake on the calendar for Thursday, you make sure you’re off the hiking trail by 3:00 PM.
The flavors change every single day. They rarely repeat the "special" flavors within the same week. This creates a sense of urgency. If you miss the Butter Pecan, it might be another ten days before it cycles back through.
Actionable Tips for Your Spelunkers Visit
To get the most out of your visit and avoid the frustration of a "sold out" sign, follow these steps:
- Check Social Media Early: Look at the Spokengear/Spelunkers Facebook page around 10:00 AM. They usually post the daily flavor then.
- Go During "Off" Hours: Between 2:00 PM and 4:00 PM is usually the sweet spot. After dinner, the line becomes a social event, which is fun but slow.
- The Harbor Walk: Take your custard to the breakwall. Walk all the way to the lighthouse. It’s the best "dining room" in the world.
- Bring Layers: Even if it’s sunny, the lakefront can be 15 degrees colder than the shop.
- Check the Seasonal Hours: They aren't open year-round with the same schedule. Late fall and winter see significantly reduced hours, so call ahead if you’re visiting in the "quiet" season.
Grand Marais wouldn't be the same without this place. It’s a small detail in a big landscape, but that first bite of the Spelunkers flavor of the day usually ends up being the thing people talk about most on the drive home. Whether it’s a simple vanilla or a complex fruit swirl, it’s a tangible piece of North Shore culture that you can actually taste.