You pull up to the intersection of Frederica and Demere Roads and the first thing that hits you isn't the sight of the old gas station. It’s the smell. That thick, heavy, sweet-and-savory cloud of oak and hickory smoke hanging over the roundabout like a low-lying fog. If you’ve ever spent time on the coast, you know exactly what I’m talking about. Southern Soul Barbeque St Simons Island Georgia isn't just a restaurant; it is a landmark that survived a literal fire to become the heartbeat of the island's food scene.
It’s crowded. Always.
If you show up at noon on a Saturday in July, you’re going to be standing in a line that snakes past the outdoor picnic tables while sweating through your shirt. And honestly? Nobody seems to care. People are happy here. They are clutching those little plastic buzzers like they’re winning lottery tickets. There is something about the "low and slow" philosophy that just naturally forces people to chill out, even when the humidity is pushing 90% and the gnats are starting to swarm.
The Gas Station That Conquered the Coast
The building itself tells a story. It started its life as a 1950s era filling station, and if you look closely at the architecture, you can still see the bones of that mid-century roadside aesthetic. Knuckleheads might call it "shabby chic," but locals just call it home. Back in 2010, a massive fire nearly wiped the place off the map. It was a gut-punch to the community. But owners Griffin Bufkin and Harrison Sapp didn't just fold. They rebuilt, and somehow, the phoenix that rose from the ashes tasted even better than the original.
They use wood. Real wood. None of that gas-assist nonsense that you find in chain restaurants that claim to do "authentic" pit cooking. At Southern Soul Barbeque St Simons Island Georgia, the pitmasters are wrestling with logs of local oak and hickory every single day. That matters because the smoke profile on the Georgia coast is distinct. It’s not the harsh, acrid bite of mesquite you’d find in Texas, and it isn't the heavy fruitwood sweetness of some Midwest spots. It is balanced. It’s mellow.
Why the Pork is the Point
Most people gravitate toward the pulled pork, and for good reason. It’s the benchmark. They cook it for upward of 12 hours until it basically gives up and falls apart at the mere suggestion of a fork.
👉 See also: 3000 Yen to USD: What Your Money Actually Buys in Japan Today
The texture is the thing. You get those "bark" pieces—the dark, crunchy, highly seasoned outer bits—mixed in with the tender, juicy interior meat. It creates this contrast that makes a sandwich more than just a delivery system for calories. When you pile that pork onto a bun with a little bit of their "Red State" sauce, which is a tomato-based classic, you start to understand why Southern Living and Garden & Gun keep putting this place on their "Best of" lists. It isn't just hype generated by food bloggers; it’s a technical mastery of heat and time.
Navigating the Sauce Spectrum
Let’s talk about the sauces because that’s where the real arguments happen at the picnic tables. Georgia is a bit of a melting pot for BBQ styles. We are squeezed between the mustard-heavy traditions of South Carolina and the vinegar-tang of North Carolina, with a little bit of Alabama white sauce creeping in from the west.
Southern Soul embraces all of it.
- Red State: Your classic, sweet-but-tangy tomato sauce. It’s the safe bet, the crowd-pleaser.
- Low Country: This is the mustard-based gold. It’s sharp. It’s pungent. It cuts through the fat of the brisket like a knife.
- Sweet and Spicy: Exactly what it sounds like. It has a creeping heat that doesn't blow your head off but definitely lets you know it’s there.
- Hot Leggin’: This is for the folks who want to suffer a little bit. It’s vinegar-forward and heavy on the pepper.
Basically, you’ve got a chemistry set on your table. I usually suggest people try a little bit of everything. Don't just drown the meat immediately. Taste the smoke first. Then, add a drop of the Low Country mustard sauce to a bite of brisket and tell me your soul doesn't leave your body for a second.
Beyond the Bun: The Sides and the Soul
A lot of BBQ joints treat sides as an afterthought. They’ll give you a scoop of bland potato salad or some canned green beans and expect you to be happy because the ribs are good. Southern Soul doesn't play that game.
✨ Don't miss: The Eloise Room at The Plaza: What Most People Get Wrong
The Fried Okra is a revelation. It isn't those soggy, frozen rounds you get at a cafeteria. It’s sliced thin, lightly breaded, and fried until it’s basically a vegetable popcorn. You can eat a pint of it without even thinking. Then there’s the Hoppin’ John—a classic coastal Georgia dish of black-eyed peas and rice that feels like a hug from a grandmother you never had. It’s earthy and filling.
And we have to talk about the Brunswick Stew. If you aren't from the South, you might be confused by this thick, meaty concoction that looks like a hearty porridge. In this part of the world, Brunswick Stew is a holy rite. Southern Soul’s version is dense, packed with shredded meats and corn, and has that perfect balance of savory and slightly sweet. It is arguably the best version of the dish in the Golden Isles.
The Brisket Dilemma
Purists will tell you that you can't get good brisket outside of Austin or Lockhart. They’re usually wrong, but I get the skepticism. Brisket is hard. It’s a fickle muscle that turns into a shoe sole if you look at it wrong.
Southern Soul handles it with respect. Is it "Texas-perfect"? Maybe not every single day—humidity plays hell with bark formation—but on a good day, it competes with the best of them. The fat is rendered down into a buttery silkiness. They don't over-trim it, which is the key. You need that fat cap to protect the meat during the long haul in the pit. If you’re a beef person, skip the sandwich and get the platter so you can see the "smoke ring" in all its pink, chemical-glory.
Living the Island Life
The vibe here is purely St. Simons. You’ll see guys who just stepped off a multi-million dollar sportfishing boat sitting right next to construction workers in high-vis vests and tourists who are clearly lost. It’s a great equalizer.
🔗 Read more: TSA PreCheck Look Up Number: What Most People Get Wrong
The "Soul" in the name isn't just a marketing gimmick. There is a palpable sense of pride in the service. Even when they are slammed—and they are almost always slammed—the staff stays moving with a kind of rhythmic efficiency. They’ve got the "Island Time" thing down, but they don't let it slow down the kitchen.
You should know that parking is a nightmare. Truly. The lot is tiny and people park like they’ve never seen white lines before. If you can’t find a spot, don't stress. There is some street parking nearby, just be mindful of the residential signs. Also, they sell out of stuff. This is real BBQ. When the ribs are gone, they’re gone. They can’t just "make more" in twenty minutes. If you have your heart set on a specific cut, get there early.
The Local Perspective on Southern Soul Barbeque St Simons Island Georgia
Some locals will tell you to try other spots on the mainland or hidden gems in the marsh, and you should. Georgia is full of incredible pits. But Southern Soul has become the cultural touchstone for a reason. They managed to take a traditional craft and make it accessible without stripping away the soul.
They also do a killer breakfast if you happen to be around on the weekends. The brisket hash will change your entire outlook on the day. It’s heavy, sure, but you’re on vacation (or living like you are), so who cares?
Practical Tips for Your Visit
- Check the Daily Specials: Sometimes they do smoked wings or special sausages that aren't on the permanent menu. These are almost always worth the risk.
- Take Home a Rub: They sell their seasonings. If you’re a backyard griller, grabbing a tin of their rub is the best souvenir you can get.
- The Picnic Tables are the Best Seat: Even when it’s hot. There is something about eating ribs outside while watching the traffic circle that just feels right.
- Order the Knucklehead: If you can't decide, this is a solid way to sample the goods.
The reality of Southern Soul Barbeque St Simons Island Georgia is that it lives up to the press. It’s one of those rare places where the fame hasn't ruined the food. They are still using the same wood, the same pits, and the same recipes that made them famous a decade ago. It’s a messy, smoky, delicious slice of the Georgia coast.
To make the most of your trip, head over just before the standard lunch rush—think 11:15 AM—to snag a seat and ensure the full menu is still available. Grab a sweet tea, find a spot in the shade, and prepare to ruin a perfectly good white t-shirt with some of the best sauce in the South. Once you're done, take a slow drive down to the Pier Village to walk off the "meat coma." You'll need it.