Why Sons of Anarchy Season 3 Is Still the Most Divisive Year in TV History

Why Sons of Anarchy Season 3 Is Still the Most Divisive Year in TV History

Sons of Anarchy season 3 is a weird beast. Honestly, if you ask ten different fans what they think of the Belfast arc, you’re gonna get ten different answers, and half of them will probably involve complaining about that "Irish" version of the theme song. It was a massive gamble for Kurt Sutter. Taking a show rooted in the dusty, sun-drenched asphalt of Northern California and transplanting it to the grey, rainy streets of Northern Ireland felt like a different show entirely. Some people loved the world-building. Others just wanted to see Jax Teller punch someone in Charming.

It’s been over a decade since it aired, and yet, the debate hasn't died down. Season 3 is where the show stopped being a "Hamlet on bikes" procedural and turned into a sprawling, international crime epic. It was messy. It was loud. It was occasionally confusing. But it was also the season that gave us one of the most satisfying finales in the history of basic cable.

The Baby Abel Problem and the Search for Meaning

The core of Sons of Anarchy season 3 is the search for Abel. Remember that cliffhanger? Cameron Hayes kills Half-Sack—RIP to a real one—and bolts with Jax’s kid. It’s a gut-punch. But then the show spends the next eight episodes spinning its wheels in California before the club even gets to Ireland. That’s the big sticking point for most viewers. The pacing feels... off. You’ve got Jax basically falling apart, Gemma on the run with Tig and her dementia-ridden father (played brilliantly by Hal Holbrook), and the looming threat of Stahl.

It’s heavy.

While the California episodes feel slow, they do some heavy lifting for the characters. We see Jax at his most vulnerable. He’s not a leader yet; he’s just a grieving, panicked dad. The nuance Charlie Hunnam brings to those early episodes is underrated. He’s playing a man who is ready to give up the life if it means getting his son back, which sets up the massive internal conflict that carries the rest of the series.

Then there’s Gemma. Katey Sagal earned her Golden Globe here, and she earned it hard. The scenes between her and Holbrook are some of the most "human" moments the show ever produced. It wasn't about guns or meth or turf wars. It was about a daughter watching her father fade away while she herself was a fugitive. It’s grounded. It’s painful. It’s the kind of writing that makes the later, more over-the-top violence feel like it has actual stakes.

Welcome to Belfast (and the Accents)

Once the SAMCRO crew actually touches down in Ireland, things get wild. We meet SAMBEL. We meet the True IRA. We meet Father Ashby.

📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana

Let's be real: the accents were a choice. Some were okay; others sounded like they were auditioning for a Lucky Charms commercial. But if you can look past the questionable brogues, the Belfast storyline expanded the lore of John Teller in a way that was necessary. We finally got to see the "other" life JT lived. We met Maureen Ashby and Trinity. Suddenly, the letters Jax had been reading all through the first two seasons had a physical, living manifestation.

The IRA politics are dense. Like, really dense. You’ve got Jimmy O’Phelan (played with slimy perfection by Titus Welliver) squaring off against the council, and the club is caught in the middle. It’s a lot of "who is double-crossing whom" stuff. It’s not always easy to follow on a first watch.

  • The club realizes SAMBEL has gone rogue.
  • Jax discovers he has a half-sister.
  • The IRA proves to be way more dangerous than any street gang in Oakland.

The Liam O'Neill betrayal? Brutal. The scene where they find out he's been working with Jimmy O and the subsequent "interrogation" is classic SOA—dark, violent, and messy. But the heart of the Belfast trip is that scene in the market. You know the one. Jax finds Abel with his adoptive parents. He sees his son in a normal, clean, safe environment. And for a second, he's going to walk away. He’s going to let the kid have a life away from the MC. It’s arguably the most important character moment for Jax in the entire seven-season run. He chooses the father's love over the outlaw's ego, even if it’s only temporary.

June Stahl: The Villain We Loved to Hate

Ally Walker deserves an award for making Agent June Stahl one of the most detestable human beings on television. By Sons of Anarchy season 3, Stahl isn't even pretending to be a "good guy" anymore. She’s a sociopath with a badge. The way she manipulated everyone—Jax, Gemma, her own partner—was masterclass level villainy.

She was the perfect foil because she didn't use a gun to hurt the club; she used the law. She used their own secrets.

The tension she created throughout the season was the real engine of the plot. Every time Jax made a deal with her, you knew it was going to blow up. The audience was screaming at the TV because we’ve seen her betray everyone. The "Jax is a rat" storyline was a gamble because it made the protagonist look like the one thing bikers hate most. It was uncomfortable to watch. It made you question if Jax was losing his soul.

👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed

NS: The Greatest Finale Ever?

Okay, maybe "ever" is a big claim, but the season 3 finale, "NS," is a top-tier episode of television. Period.

Everything comes together. All those slow-burn subplots? They pay off. The way the club executes the plan to take out Jimmy O and Stahl simultaneously is a work of art. It’s one of those rare moments where the outlaws actually win.

When Chibs finally gets his revenge on Jimmy O? "Tell 'em it's from Jackie Boy." Chills.

And then there’s Opie. Seeing Opie finally get some semblance of justice for Donna by taking out Stahl in the back of that SUV... it was cathartic. "This is what she felt." It was cold. It was earned. The look on Stahl's face when she realizes the club hasn't actually turned on Jax, but that they were all in on the ruse, is pure gold.

The final sequence, with the club being hauled off to prison while the "re-mix" of the theme plays and the revelation of the letters to Piney and Maureen, sets the stage for the Shakespearean tragedy of the later seasons. It’s the last time the club feels like a true brotherhood before the weight of Clay’s lies and Jax’s ambition starts to tear them apart for good.

Why Season 3 Still Matters in 2026

We talk a lot about "prestige TV" nowadays, but Sons of Anarchy season 3 was doing the heavy lifting before the streaming wars really kicked off. It proved that a genre show about bikers could handle complex international politics and deep psychological trauma.

✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild

It wasn't perfect. The pacing in the middle was sluggish. The Ireland sets (mostly filmed in California with some clever editing) occasionally looked a bit "backlot-ish."

But the emotional core was rock solid.

If you’re re-watching it now, look at the details. Look at how Sutter uses the letters as a ghost haunting the frame. Look at the way the relationship between Clay and Jax starts to fray, even when they’re working together. It’s all there.

What You Should Do Next

If you’re looking to dive back into the world of SAMCRO or you’re a first-timer trying to make sense of the chaos, here is how to actually digest this season:

  1. Watch the "Director’s Cut" versions if available. Some of the Belfast episodes have extended scenes that clarify the confusing IRA hierarchies.
  2. Pay attention to the background music. SOA was famous for its "montage" songs, and season 3 has some of the best, including "The Matador" and "Bird on a Wire." They often tell you more about the characters' mental states than the dialogue does.
  3. Track the letters. Keep a mental note (or a physical one) of who knows what regarding John Teller’s letters. That is the "ticking time bomb" that eventually explodes in season 4.
  4. Watch the finale twice. Seriously. The first time is for the shock; the second time is to see how many breadcrumbs the writers dropped throughout the season that pointed to that specific ending.

Sons of Anarchy season 3 might be polarizing, but it’s the season that defined the show's legacy. It took the club out of their comfort zone and forced them—and us—to see what they were really made of. It turns out, they were made of a lot more than just leather and chrome. They were a family, for better or (mostly) worse.