Music is weirdly powerful. It can make a roomful of people sob or suddenly feel like they can run through a brick wall. But when it comes to saying goodbye, picking the wrong track can turn a somber moment into something incredibly awkward, or worse, deeply offensive. We've all heard the horror stories. A grandson picks a song because "Grandpa liked the beat," not realizing the lyrics are about a prison riot or a messy divorce. Honestly, navigating songs inappropriate for a funeral is a bit of a minefield because "inappropriate" is subjective, yet there are some hard lines you really shouldn't cross.
Let's be real. Nobody wants to be the person who accidentally blasts "Highway to Hell" while the casket is being lowered, unless the deceased specifically requested it as a final middle finger to the world.
The literal interpretations that go horribly wrong
People often focus on the title of a song and completely ignore what the artist is actually saying. It's a classic mistake. You think a song sounds "heavenly" or "peaceful," but the subtext is basically a wrecking ball. Take "Hallelujah" by Leonard Cohen. It’s one of the most requested funeral songs in the UK and North America. It sounds liturgical. It feels spiritual. But if you actually listen to the verses, it’s a song about broken love, sexual frustration, and personal failure. It’s a masterpiece, sure, but is it a celebration of a life well-lived? Not really. It’s more of a "love is not a victory march" kind of vibe.
Then there’s "Every Breath You Take" by The Police. People play this at weddings and funerals alike. It’s creepy. Sting has said it himself—it’s about a stalker. It’s about obsession and surveillance. Playing a song about someone watching your every move while you’re trying to find peace is, well, it's a choice. It's a bad one.
Sometimes, the "vibe" just doesn't match the reality of death.
"I Will Survive" by Gloria Gaynor is an anthem of empowerment. It’s great for a breakup. It’s great for the gym. It is inherently one of those songs inappropriate for a funeral because, quite literally, the person didn't. It creates this jarring cognitive dissonance. You're standing there in black, holding a tissue, while a disco beat reminds everyone of the biological reality that survival didn't happen in this instance. It feels mocking, even if the intention was to celebrate the person’s "spirit" surviving.
When humor backfires in the chapel
We’ve seen a shift lately. Funerals are becoming "celebrations of life." People want humor. They want to reflect the "joker" personality of the deceased. This is where things get dicey. There’s a very thin line between a cheeky nod and a total lack of respect for the grieving process of others.
"Another One Bites the Dust" by Queen is the gold standard for this.
🔗 Read more: Marie Kondo The Life Changing Magic of Tidying Up: What Most People Get Wrong
If the deceased was a professional comedian or a cynical prankster, maybe it works. But for 99% of families, it’s just jarring. It reduces a human life to a statistic. Similarly, "Stayin’ Alive" by the Bee Gees is practically a dare to the universe. It’s upbeat, it’s fun, and it’s completely wrong for a room full of grieving relatives. You have to consider the "auntie factor." If your Great Aunt Martha is going to have a literal heart attack because she thinks you're making light of her brother's passing, the joke wasn't worth it.
Music is a shared experience.
While the funeral is "for" the deceased, it’s technically for the living. The living are the ones who have to sit there and process the sound. If the music makes them feel unsafe or mocked, the service has failed its primary purpose of providing closure.
The "Good Intentions" trap: Why lyrics matter
I once heard about a service where the family played "Dosed" by Red Hot Chili Peppers because the deceased loved the band. If you know the song, it’s beautiful. But it’s also explicitly about deep regret and the heavy toll of drug use. If the death was related to a struggle with addiction, that song becomes an accidental indictment rather than a tribute.
You have to read the lyrics. All of them. Not just the chorus.
- "Perfect Day" by Lou Reed: Often used for its melancholy beauty. It's actually about a heroin high.
- "The One I Love" by R.E.M.: It’s not a love song. It contains the line "A simple prop to occupy my time." It’s an anti-love song.
- "Wind Beneath My Wings": While it’s a funeral staple, some find it incredibly patronizing. It essentially says "you stayed in the shadows so I could shine." For some siblings or spouses, those lyrics can sting.
Nuance is everything. A song might be "inappropriate" not because it’s vulgar, but because it’s accidentally truthful in a way that hurts. If you’re choosing music, you have to be a bit of a detective. Search for the "meaning behind [song name]" before you put it on the playlist. You might be surprised to find that the "pretty" song is actually about a political uprising or a bad trip.
Cultural and religious boundaries you can't ignore
Different spaces have different rules. A secular crematorium might give you a lot of leeway. You can play "Ding Dong! The Witch is Dead" (yes, people do this, especially after certain political figures pass away) and the staff might just roll their eyes. But a Catholic church? Or a strict synagogue? They have specific rules. Many religious venues won't allow "secular" music at all.
💡 You might also like: Why Transparent Plus Size Models Are Changing How We Actually Shop
I’ve seen priests veto "My Way" by Frank Sinatra. Why? Because the core message is "I did it my way" instead of "I did it God's way." In a strictly religious context, that’s considered an act of pride. It’s a direct contradiction of the liturgy.
If you try to sneak in songs inappropriate for a funeral in a consecrated space, you’re not just being "edgy." You’re creating a conflict with the officiant. That’s the last thing a grieving family needs—a lecture from the pulpit about the playlist. Always check with the venue. Even if the song is "clean," the message might clash with the theology of the space.
The weirdly popular but questionable choices
It’s fascinating to look at the data from funeral directors. They see the same songs over and over. Some of the most popular choices are actually the ones that people argue over the most in terms of appropriateness.
"Tears in Heaven" by Eric Clapton is heart-wrenching. It was written about the tragic death of his four-year-old son. Because the backstory is so specific and so devastating, some people find it too heavy. It doesn't just honor the deceased; it forces everyone to relive a specific, public tragedy. It’s a beautiful song, but it carries a weight that can sometimes smother a service.
Then you have the "ironic" picks.
- "Disco Inferno" (Burn, baby, burn) – Obviously a nightmare for a cremation.
- "Ring of Fire" by Johnny Cash – Also problematic for cremations.
- "Going Down" – Generally a bad idea for a burial.
These might seem like "dad jokes," but in the moment of grief, they land like lead balloons. The "humor" often disappears the second the music starts and the reality of the situation sets in.
How to actually pick music that isn't a disaster
If you’re worried about picking songs inappropriate for a funeral, the best strategy is to look for "anchors." An anchor is a song that is musically neutral but emotionally resonant. Instrumentals are usually the safest bet. They provide a canvas for people to project their own feelings without a lyricist telling them exactly what to think.
📖 Related: Weather Forecast Calumet MI: What Most People Get Wrong About Keweenaw Winters
Think about the tempo. A song that is too fast feels like you're rushing the grief. A song that is too slow can feel oppressive. You want something that breathes.
Think about the person’s actual taste, but filter it through the "Grandmother Test." If you played this for a conservative 80-year-old relative, would you have to explain away the lyrics? If the answer is yes, save that track for the wake. The wake is for the "real" music. The wake is where you play the heavy metal, the explicit rap, or the dirty blues that the person actually listened to. The service itself is a ceremony. Ceremonies require a different level of curation.
Practical steps for finalizing the playlist
Don't leave this to the last minute. Stress leads to bad decisions.
- Read the full lyric sheet: Don't skim. Read every word. Look for themes of suicide, betrayal, or vulgarity that might be hidden in a verse.
- Check the venue's policy: Ask the funeral director or the clergy if they have a "banned" list. Many do.
- Consider the "vibe" transition: The entry music should be different from the exit music. Entry is for settling in; exit is for moving forward. Don't play a "downer" as people are trying to leave the building.
- Test the audio: Make sure the version you have isn't a "live" version with 5 minutes of crowd noise or a weird intro.
- Listen to the whole song: Sometimes a song starts out quiet and ends in a chaotic wall of sound. You don't want a heavy metal breakdown starting right as the moment of silence begins.
Ultimately, the goal is to honor the person without traumatizing the people they left behind. Music is a gift to the mourners. If the song choice creates more confusion than comfort, it's probably one of those songs inappropriate for a funeral.
Stick to songs that have a broad emotional appeal or, at the very least, lyrics that don't require an apology. If you're in doubt, go with an instrumental version of their favorite song. It keeps the melody they loved but removes the risk of a lyric ruining the moment.
Next steps:
If you are currently planning a service, create a shortlist of three songs and send the lyrics to one other person—preferably someone who is a bit more traditional than you. If they flag a line, listen to them. It’s much easier to change a Spotify link now than it is to deal with the awkward silence in the middle of a chapel. Check out your local funeral home’s website as well; many now offer "approved" playlists that can give you a baseline of what works in your specific community or tradition.