Let’s be real for a second. Most people expected a musical based on a DreamWorks movie about a farting ogre to be, well, a bit of a disaster. It sounds like a cynical cash grab. But then you actually sit down and listen to the songs from Shrek the Musical, and suddenly you’re hit with this weirdly sophisticated blend of Jeanine Tesori’s brilliant composition and David Lindsay-Abaire’s sharp lyrics. It’s not just fart jokes set to a beat. It’s a genuine exploration of being an outcast, wrapped in a bright green, Broadway-sized package.
Honestly, the score is doing a lot of heavy lifting. It manages to pay homage to classic musical theater tropes while simultaneously making fun of them. It’s meta. It’s loud. And surprisingly, it’s got a lot of heart.
The unexpected complexity of the Shrek the Musical score
When Jeanine Tesori signed on to write the music, she wasn't just coming off some small project. She’s the mind behind Caroline, or Change and Violet. She knows how to write "serious" music. So, when she tackled the songs from Shrek the Musical, she brought a level of harmonic depth that you wouldn't expect for a show featuring a talking donkey.
Take "Big Bright Beautiful World," the opening number. It starts as this lush, fairytale lullaby that quickly turns into a harsh reality check. It sets the tone immediately: the world isn't nice, and our protagonist is okay with that. Or at least, he says he is. That’s the nuance. The music tells us Shrek is lonely even when the lyrics claim he loves his swamp.
Why "I Know It's Today" is a structural marvel
If you want to talk about clever songwriting, you have to look at "I Know It's Today." It’s a triple-threat song that introduces Fiona at three different stages of her life: as a child, a teenager, and an adult.
They’re all trapped in the same tower, singing the same hopeful melody, but the orchestration gets progressively more frantic and slightly unhinged as "Adult Fiona" takes over. It perfectly illustrates the toll that years of isolation and obsessive reading of fairytale books would actually take on a person's psyche. It’s funny, sure, but it’s also kind of dark if you think about it too long. Sutton Foster, who originated the role on Broadway, used her incredible belt to show that Fiona isn't a delicate princess; she’s a woman who has been waiting twenty years and is about to snap.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
Breaking down the big showstoppers
You can't talk about songs from Shrek the Musical without mentioning "Freak Flag." This is the show's "One Day More" or "Defying Gravity." It’s the anthem for the fairytale creatures who have been kicked out of Duloc.
- It starts small, led by Pinocchio (who, in the musical, has a hilariously high-pitched "wood" voice).
- It builds into a full-scale soulful revolution.
- The message is blunt: let your freak flag fly.
It’s a bit on the nose, but in the context of the theater, it works. It’s the moment the ensemble gets to shine. Unlike the movie, where the fairytale creatures are mostly background gags, the musical gives them a collective voice. "Story of My Life" does similar work earlier in the show, establishing that these characters are victims of Lord Farquaad’s "perfectionist" regime.
Lord Farquaad and the art of the character song
Speaking of Farquaad, "What’s Up, Duloc?" is a masterclass in visual and auditory comedy. Because the actor (originally Christopher Sieber) has to perform the entire show on his knees to simulate Farquaad’s height, the choreography is inherently ridiculous. The song itself is a pastiche of every over-the-top Vegas residency or Broadway production number you’ve ever seen. It’s narcissistic, bouncy, and completely devoid of the soul found in Shrek’s songs. That's intentional. The music reflects the character's shallowness.
The emotional core: "Who I'd Be"
The first act ends with "Who I'd Be," and it’s arguably the best song in the show. It’s a power ballad shared between Shrek, Fiona, and Donkey, though they aren't singing to each other—they are singing their internal desires.
Shrek sings about wanting to be a hero, a poet, or "anything but an ogre." It’s a vulnerable moment that humanizes him more than any piece of dialogue could. The way the three voices weave together at the end is technically difficult and emotionally soaring. It’s the moment where the audience stops seeing a guy in a green prosthetic mask and starts seeing a protagonist they actually care about.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
Let's talk about the Donkey in the room
Donkey’s songs, like "Don't Let Me Go" and "Make a Move," bring the R&B and Motown influence to the swamp. Originally played by Daniel Breaker, Donkey provides the upbeat, rhythmic contrast to Shrek’s more folk-rock or traditional musical theater sound.
"Don't Let Me Go" is a desperate plea for friendship masked as a high-energy pop-rock track. It’s clingy. It’s annoying. It’s exactly what Donkey should be. It also highlights the "buddy comedy" aspect of the show that fans of the film expect.
The "I'm a Believer" debate
Look, we have to address the finale. In the original Broadway run, the show ended with a brief reprise, but they eventually added "I'm a Believer" because, well, the movie.
Some theater purists hate this. They think it feels tacked on.
But honestly? It’s a crowd-pleaser. After two and a half hours of original music, giving the audience a familiar hit to dance to during the curtain call isn't a crime. It bridges the gap between the cinematic Shrek and the theatrical one.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
The legacy of the Shrek soundtrack
Is it Hamilton? No. Is it trying to be? Also no.
The songs from Shrek the Musical succeed because they understand the assignment. They provide a mix of potty humor for the kids and genuine, sophisticated musical theater for the adults. The show didn't just copy-paste the movie's soundtrack (which was mostly licensed pop songs). It created a brand new sonic world.
When you look at the sheet music for songs like "Morning Person," you see the complexity. It’s a bright, 1940s-style musical theater number that involves Fiona literally dancing with rats. It’s absurd, but the music is technically demanding. That’s the secret of the show: it treats the "silly" material with serious musical respect.
How to experience the music today
If you’re looking to dive deeper into these tracks, don't just stick to the movie clips. The Original Broadway Cast Recording is the gold standard here. Sutton Foster and Brian d'Arcy James have a chemistry that translates perfectly through audio alone.
- Listen for the motifs: Notice how certain melodies from "Big Bright Beautiful World" sneak back in when Shrek is feeling vulnerable.
- Watch the Pro-Shot: There is a high-quality filmed version of the Broadway production available on several streaming platforms. Seeing the physical comedy during "What's Up, Duloc?" changes how you hear the music.
- Compare the versions: There are slight differences between the Broadway version and the "Shrek Jr." or "Shrek TYA" (Theater for Young Audiences) versions often performed by schools. The professional version has much more intricate orchestrations.
The best way to appreciate the songwriting is to look past the ears and the green makeup. Focus on the lyrics of "Build a Wall" or the sheer vocal power of "I Know It's Today." You'll find a score that is much more "Broadway" than "DreamWorks," and that's exactly why it works.
For those interested in performing or analyzing the score, the vocal selections book is widely available and provides a great look at Jeanine Tesori's specific chord voicings. Whether you're a fan of the film or a die-hard theater nerd, there's no denying the craft behind the swamp.