Why Songs by Nick Drake Still Haunt Us Decades Later

Why Songs by Nick Drake Still Haunt Us Decades Later

It is a specific kind of quiet. You know the one. It’s that three-in-the-morning stillness where the world feels like it’s held together by nothing but frayed string and static. That is where songs by Nick Drake live. They don’t just play; they sort of seep into the corners of the room. It’s weird because, during his actual life, almost nobody was listening. He sold barely any records. He retreated into a fog of depression and eventually died in 1974 at the age of 26, probably thinking he’d be completely forgotten. But here we are.

People always talk about the "myth" of the tragic artist. Honestly, with Drake, the myth is kinda distracting. It gets in the way of the actual technical brilliance. If you strip away the story of the lonely boy in the English countryside, you’re left with some of the most complex, frustratingly beautiful acoustic guitar work ever recorded. He didn't play like a folk singer. He played like a clockmaker.

The Weird Tuning of Five Leaves Left

When you first hear "Time Has Told Me," it sounds simple. It isn't. Drake was obsessed with non-standard tunings. He’d spend ages on stage between songs, fiddling with his pegs in total silence while the audience just stared at him. It made him a nightmare to watch live, but on record? It created a harmonic depth that most singer-songwriters couldn't touch.

His debut album, Five Leaves Left, was recorded while he was still a student at Cambridge. You can hear the academic influence, but also the total isolation. Take "River Man." It’s written in 5/4 time, which is already a bit of a flex for a folk artist. But it’s the way the strings—arranged by his friend Robert Kirby—swell around that repetitive, circling guitar figure. It feels like moving water. Drake’s voice is barely a whisper, yet it carries this incredible weight. He wasn't shouting for attention. He was basically muttering to himself, and we just happened to be eavesdropping.

Most people get wrong that Drake was just a "sad guy with a guitar." In those early sessions, he was actually quite ambitious. He worked with Joe Boyd, the legendary producer who handled Pink Floyd and Fairport Convention. They used world-class session musicians like Danny Thompson on double bass. There was a real attempt to make him a star. It just didn't take. The public wasn't ready for that specific brand of intimacy.

Why "Pink Moon" Is the One Everyone Remembers

If Five Leaves Left was lush and Bryter Layter was an attempt at jazz-pop (which Drake reportedly ended up hating because it felt too "produced"), Pink Moon is the bone-dry skeleton of an album. It’s only 28 minutes long. No backing band. No strings. Just Nick, a guitar, and a tiny bit of piano on the title track.

It was recorded in two nights.

👉 See also: Nothing to Lose: Why the Martin Lawrence and Tim Robbins Movie is Still a 90s Classic

There’s a story—maybe a bit exaggerated, but mostly true—that he just walked into the Island Records office, dropped the master tapes on the receptionist's desk, and walked out without saying a word. That’s the vibe of the whole record. "Place to Be" is particularly devastating. He sings about being "sunlight" once, but now being "the elder beside the road." He was only 23 or 24 when he wrote that. Think about that for a second. Most twenty-somethings are worried about their careers or who’s texting them back; Drake was writing about his own fading spirit as if he were eighty.

The Technical Mastery Behind the Melancholy

We need to talk about his right hand. Seriously. His fingerpicking style was freakish. Most folkies use a steady thumb-beat (Travis picking), but Drake had this percussive, syncopated style that made it sound like two people were playing at once.

  • He used his fingernails to get a sharp, harpsichord-like attack.
  • He frequently muted the strings with the palm of his hand to create a "thudding" rhythmic drive.
  • His clusters of chords often relied on open strings that rang out against moving bass lines.

In "Road," the guitar part is so fast and precise it almost sounds mechanical, yet the melody on top is fluid and airy. This contrast is why songs by Nick Drake are so hard to cover. If you play them with standard chords, the magic evaporates. You have to learn his specific, idiosyncratic tunings—like C-G-C-F-C-E—to even get close to that shimmering sound.

It wasn't just about sadness. There was a deep, rhythmic groove in things like "Hazey Jane II." He liked the blues. He liked jazz. You can hear the DNA of artists like Randy Newman and even some bossa nova influences in his phrasing. He was a sponge for sophisticated music, but he filtered it all through this very English, very pastoral lens.

The Volkswagen Commercial That Changed Everything

It’s one of the weirdest footnotes in music history. For twenty-five years after his death, Nick Drake was a cult figure. He was the "musician's musician." Then, in 1999, Volkswagen used the song "Pink Moon" in a commercial for the Cabrio.

The ad was simple: four young people driving under a bright moon in a convertible.

✨ Don't miss: How Old Is Paul Heyman? The Real Story of Wrestling’s Greatest Mind

Suddenly, everyone wanted to know who that voice was. The "Pink Moon" album sold more copies in the few years following that commercial than it had in the previous three decades combined. It’s a bit cynical, sure, but it saved his legacy. It proved that his music wasn't tied to the 1970s. It was timeless. It fit just as well in a modern digital world as it did in a wood-paneled bedroom in 1972.

Sorting Through the Discography

If you're trying to figure out where to start, don't just hit "shuffle" on a playlist. The albums have very different personalities.

Five Leaves Left (1969) is the "autumn" album. It’s for when the leaves are actually falling and you’re feeling a bit contemplative. "Day Is Done" and "Way to Blue" are the highlights here. The cello on "Cello Song" is basically a second voice. It’s gorgeous.

Bryter Layter (1971) is the "bright" one, though that’s relative. It’s got drums! It’s got flutes! "Northern Sky" is widely considered one of the greatest love songs ever written. It features John Cale (from the Velvet Underground) on celesta and piano. It’s the one moment in Drake’s catalog where the clouds actually part and let a little warmth in. He sounds hopeful. It’s heartbreaking because you know what comes next.

Pink Moon (1972) is the "midnight" album. It’s for when you're alone. "Things Behind the Sun" is a warning. "From the Morning" is the final track, and it’s surprisingly upbeat—its lyrics are actually inscribed on his gravestone: "And now we rise / And we are everywhere."

The Reality of the "Lost" Recordings

After Pink Moon, Drake's mental health spiraled. He moved back in with his parents in Tanworth-in-Arden. He was barely speaking. He did manage to record four or five more songs in 1974, just months before he died.

🔗 Read more: Howie Mandel Cupcake Picture: What Really Happened With That Viral Post

These tracks, like "Black Eyed Dog," are harrowing. His voice is different. It’s huskier, lower, and more strained. The guitar playing is still sharp, but the content is grim. He was singing about a "black eyed dog" that was calling his name—a clear metaphor for the depression that was consuming him. It’s hard to listen to, honestly. It’s not "pretty" folk music anymore; it’s a document of a human being reaching the end of his rope.

Actionable Ways to Experience the Music Properly

If you want to actually appreciate the depth of these compositions, you have to change how you listen. This isn't background music for a coffee shop, even though coffee shops play it all the time.

  1. Get the lyrics out. Drake was a poet. He studied English Literature at Cambridge and was deeply influenced by William Blake and Yeats. Songs like "Fruit Tree" are eerily prophetic—he sings about how a "fruit tree" only becomes famous once its "branches are empty" and the creator is gone. He knew what was happening.
  2. Listen on vinyl or high-quality headphones. Because his music is so quiet, the "air" in the room matters. On "Pink Moon," you can hear his fingers sliding across the strings and his breath between lines. That physical presence is part of the art.
  3. Don't skip the instrumentals. Tracks like "Introduction" or "Peaced Together" show his compositional skill. He didn't always need words to convey that specific sense of English melancholy.
  4. Research the tunings. If you play guitar, go to a site like NickDrake.com which has archived his specific tunings. Trying to play "Cello Song" will give you a whole new respect for his dexterity.

The legacy of Nick Drake isn't just about his death. That’s the easy way out. The real story is the survival of the work. Despite no promotion, no touring, and a short life, these songs climbed out of the obscurity of a 1970s record bin to become the soundtrack for millions of people. He was right about the fruit tree. The branches are empty, but the fruit is still being gathered.

To really understand his impact, look at the artists who cite him: Robert Smith of The Cure named his band after a lyric in "Northern Sky." Peter Buck of R.E.M. mimicked his arpeggios. Even rappers and electronic producers have sampled his work. He is everywhere now, just like his headstone says.

If you're feeling overwhelmed by the noise of the modern world, put on Five Leaves Left. Sit near a window. Let the guitar work wash over you. You'll realize that what Drake was doing wasn't just "sad"—it was a very brave attempt to be completely honest in a world that usually rewards artifice. That honesty is why we’re still talking about him more than fifty years later.


Next Steps for Deep Listening:

  • Start with the album Five Leaves Left to understand the orchestral foundations of his sound.
  • Compare the version of "Thoughts of Mary Jane" on Made to Blossom with the album version to hear how his arrangements evolved.
  • Read Remembered for a While, the official estate-sanctioned book, for a factual look at his life through his sister Gabrielle Drake's eyes, rather than relying on internet myths.