You’re driving through the North Country, past endless stretches of Adirondack foothills and those distinctively weathered barns, and you expect the usual. You expect a diner with peeling vinyl booths or maybe a fast-food joint where the fries are always a little too salty. But then you hit 180 East Main Street. Honestly, Something Different Malone NY feels like a glitch in the matrix of rural dining, and I mean that in the best way possible. It’s a deli. It’s a specialty shop. It’s a place where you can find Boar's Head meat and authentic gyro meat on the same menu in a town of roughly 6,000 people.
It’s weird. It's great.
Most people heading to Malone are either passing through on their way to the Canadian border or they're locals who’ve lived there since the McCadam Cheese plant was the biggest thing in town. Malone has a specific vibe—it’s rugged, it’s historic, and it’s a bit of a culinary underdog. When Something Different Malone NY popped up, it filled a void that many didn't even realize existed until they were holding a massive, overstuffed sub that actually had some soul to it.
The Reality of Eating in the North Country
Let’s be real for a second. If you want a gourmet meal in Franklin County, your options are usually limited to high-end resort dining in Lake Placid (which is an hour away) or settling for a "good enough" burger at a local pub. Something Different changed that math. They didn't try to be a five-star white-tablecloth establishment. They stayed humble. They focused on being a deli, but they leaned into the "different" part of their name by offering variety that just isn't standard for the 518 area code.
People talk about the portion sizes. That’s usually the first thing you hear. It’s almost a cliché at this point, but it's true. You order a sandwich, and it’s heavy. Like, physically heavy. They aren't skimping. In an era of shrinkflation where your favorite chain sub shop is charging twelve bucks for a sandwich that looks like a pencil, this place feels like a rebellion.
You’ve got the locals who come in for their daily routine, and then you’ve got the tourists who stumbled in by accident. The atmosphere is casual. It’s "order at the counter and find a seat" kind of energy. No frills. No pretension. Just food that hits the spot when you're tired of the same three options.
What Makes Something Different Malone NY... Different?
It isn't just a clever name. They actually back it up with a menu that ranges from your standard turkey club to more eclectic Mediterranean-inspired offerings.
- The Meat Quality. Using Boar’s Head is a signal. It tells the customer that the owners care about the baseline. You aren't getting that rubbery, translucent ham here.
- The Gyros. Finding a decent gyro in upstate New York, north of Albany, is a quest. Here, it’s a staple. The tzatziki is legit. The pita is soft. It’s a massive win for anyone craving something other than a pizza slice.
- The "Surprise" Factor. Sometimes they have specialty salads or baked goods that look like they belong in a suburban bakery in Westchester rather than a small town near the border.
The service is small-town service. That means it might not be lightning-fast during the lunch rush because they’re actually making the food, not just assembling pre-packaged components. You have to appreciate that. In a world of "fast-casual" everything, a bit of a wait usually means someone is actually using a knife and a grill back there.
Why Location Matters Here
Malone is a crossroads. It sits on Route 11 and Route 30. It’s the gateway to the Titus Mountain Ski Center. If you’ve spent a day on the slopes, you don't want a salad. You want calories. You want something that’s going to warm you up and keep you full until tomorrow morning. Something Different Malone NY has become that post-ski or post-hike destination for the "in-the-know" crowd.
They also tap into the community. You’ll see flyers for local events on the door. You’ll hear the staff catching up with regular customers about their kids or the weather—and the weather in Malone is always a topic of conversation. It gets cold. Bitterly cold. Having a spot that feels warm and welcoming isn't just a business strategy; it's a survival mechanism for the community.
Navigating the Menu Without Getting Overwhelmed
If you walk in and stare at the board, you might freeze up. There's a lot going on. Honestly, the best way to handle it is to go with your gut.
- If you're starving: Get the sub. Any sub. The bread-to-meat ratio is heavily skewed in favor of the meat.
- If you want the namesake experience: Go for the Greek options. The gyro or the souvlaki platters are why people drive from out of town.
- The Sides: Don't sleep on the deli salads. They aren't the bland, mayo-heavy tubs you find at the grocery store. They actually have seasoning.
Some people complain that the prices are a bit higher than a fast-food joint. To that, I say: Look at the scale. You’re getting two meals out of most of these orders. When you factor in the quality of the ingredients—real cheese, premium meats, fresh veggies—the value proposition is actually better than the "cheap" alternatives down the road.
The Cultural Impact on a Small Town
It’s easy to overlook how much a single business can change the vibe of a main street. For years, many small towns in the North Country saw their downtowns hollowed out. But places like Something Different Malone NY represent a shift. They bring foot traffic. They give people a reason to stop instead of just driving through.
There’s a certain pride in having a "local spot" that you can brag about to visitors. It's a badge of honor. "Oh, you're going through Malone? You have to stop at Something Different." That kind of word-of-mouth marketing is more powerful than any Google Ad. It’s earned. It’s built on hundreds of consistent sandwiches and thousands of friendly interactions.
Addressing the Critics
No place is perfect. If you go during a peak Saturday lunch hour, it might be crowded. You might have to wait. The seating is functional, not luxurious. If you're looking for a romantic candlelit dinner, this isn't it. This is a deli. It’s a hub. It’s loud, it’s busy, and it’s authentic.
Some might find the menu "too big," but in a town with limited variety, that's actually a feature, not a bug. It allows a family of four with wildly different tastes to all find something they actually want to eat.
Practical Tips for Your Visit
If you're planning to check out Something Different Malone NY, keep a few things in mind to make the experience smoother.
📖 Related: Counting Down: How Many Days Till June 9th and Why We Care
First, check their hours before you go. Small-town businesses sometimes have "North Country hours," meaning they might close earlier than you'd expect if you're coming from a major city.
Second, consider calling your order in if you're in a rush. It’s a popular spot for local workers on their lunch break, and that 12:00 PM to 1:00 PM window can get pretty intense.
Third, take a look at the "specials" board. That’s where the kitchen really gets to play around. You might find a soup or a sandwich combo that isn't on the permanent menu but ends up being the best thing you've had all month.
The Long-Term Outlook
Will Malone ever become a "foodie" destination? Maybe not in the way Burlington or Saratoga are. But it doesn't need to be. It needs places that serve the people who live there and the people who love the Adirondacks. Something Different Malone NY has carved out a niche by simply being better than it has to be. They could probably get away with lower-quality meat and smaller portions, and they'd still be busy because there isn't much competition. The fact that they don't take those shortcuts is why they've built such a loyal following.
It's about consistency. It's about knowing that when you walk through that door, you're going to get exactly what you're craving. That’s a rare thing these days.
👉 See also: Filling Out the 1040: What Most People Get Wrong Every April
Actionable Steps for Your North Country Road Trip
- Plot your route: If you’re heading to Montreal or the High Peaks, make Malone your halfway stop. It’s perfectly positioned for a break.
- Order the Gyro: If it’s your first time, don’t overthink it. The gyro is the flagship for a reason.
- Bring a Cooler: Seriously. Because the portions are so big, you’ll likely have leftovers. If you’re on a long drive, you’ll want a way to keep that second half of your sub fresh for later.
- Explore Main Street: After you eat, take ten minutes to walk around. Malone has some incredible 19th-century architecture that often gets overlooked.
- Support Local: Skip the fast-food chains at the edge of town. Your money stays in the community when you eat at places like this, and you get a much better meal in the process.
The North Country is full of surprises if you know where to look. Something Different Malone NY is one of those spots that reminds you why small-town delis are the backbone of American road trips. It isn't just about the food; it's about the fact that someone decided to do something a little bit better, a little bit larger, and a little bit different in a place you might not expect it. That’s worth celebrating—and eating.