You’re walking through Southside Bethlehem, maybe past the hulking, rusted skeletons of the old Steel stacks, and you see it. A massive stone building that looks more like a fortress or an old-school bank than a place to get a drink. That’s the thing about Social Still Bethlehem PA—it doesn’t try to be a modern, glass-walled cocktail lounge. It’s an old prohibition-era bank building, specifically the Gosztonyi Savings and Trust, and it feels like it.
The air inside smells like wood, high-end grain, and history. It’s heavy. It’s cool.
Honestly, most people go there for the "gram" because of the vaulted ceilings and the massive stills sitting right behind the bar, but the real reason to stick around is the liquid. They aren't just a bar. They are a distillery. They make the vodka, the gin, the bourbon, and the agave spirits right there on-site. If you’ve spent any time in the Lehigh Valley, you know the food scene is exploding, but Social Still sort of anchored the Southside’s revival before it was the "cool" thing to do.
What People Get Wrong About Social Still Bethlehem PA
A lot of folks think this is just a fancy restaurant that happens to have some copper pots in the back for decoration. Nope.
Everything you drink started as raw grain. They are a grain-to-glass operation, which is a massive pain in the neck for the distillers but a win for your palate. When you order a "Standard" vodka soda, you’re getting something distilled from corn that actually has a character. It's not that flavorless, rubbing-alcohol burn you get from bottom-shelf stuff.
Then there’s the "bank" aspect. You can literally eat in the old vault. It’s weirdly intimate and slightly claustrophobic in the best way possible, like you're plotting a heist while eating truffle fries. The owners, the Boyle family—who also run Sand Springs Brewery—knew what they were doing when they preserved the architecture. They didn't "modernize" it into oblivion. They kept the grit.
The Spirits: More Than Just Bourbon
Everyone talks about their bourbon, which is aged in charred American oak. It’s solid. It’s got that vanilla-caramel punch you expect. But if you want to know what’s actually impressive at Social Still Bethlehem PA, look at the gin and the specialty infusions.
📖 Related: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
Their gin isn't that "drinking a pine tree" flavor that scares people off. It’s botanical but balanced. They do these seasonal infusions that sound like they shouldn't work—like habanero-infused spirits or weird berry blends—and yet, they do. They use local ingredients whenever possible, which sounds like a marketing cliché, but in the Lehigh Valley, we actually have the farms to back that up.
Check the menu for the "Blood Orange Cosmo" or their take on an Old Fashioned. They don't over-complicate things. They just use better base ingredients because they made the base themselves.
The Food Strategy (Don't Just Drink on an Empty Stomach)
Look, the drinks are strong. You need a base.
The menu at Social Still leans into that "upscale pub" vibe, but with a bit more finesse. Their burger is usually the go-to, often featuring some kind of jam or aioli that makes it feel worth the price tag. But honestly? The appetizers are where they shine.
- The Duck Fries. If they are on the menu when you go, get them. Don't think about the calories. Just do it.
- Flatbreads. They change these up, but they usually have a good crispy-to-chewy ratio.
- The Charcuterie. It’s a distillery. You need salty meats and cheeses to cut through the proof of the whiskey.
Service can be a bit slow on a Saturday night. Be prepared for that. It’s a massive space with high ceilings, which means it gets loud. If you're looking for a quiet, whispered romantic dinner, maybe head there on a Tuesday. Saturday night is for the energy, the clinking of glasses, and the general vibe of a city that’s proud of its industrial roots.
Why the Southside Location Matters
Bethlehem is split. You’ve got the North Side with the historic Moravian sites and the boutique shops on Main Street. Then you’ve got the South Side.
👉 See also: 100 Biggest Cities in the US: Why the Map You Know is Wrong
The South Side is grittier. It’s where the workers lived. It’s where the Steel was. Putting Social Still Bethlehem PA in an old bank on 3rd Street was a statement. It’s about 10 minutes away from the Wind Creek Casino, but it feels a world apart. It feels authentic to the Lehigh Valley.
When you walk out of the distillery, you see the blast furnaces lit up in blue or red. It’s a reminder of what this town used to be. The distillery feels like the second act of that story. We don't make steel anymore, but we make damn good whiskey.
Reservations and Planning
Do not just show up at 7:00 PM on a Friday and expect to sit in the vault. You won't.
- Book ahead: Use their online system.
- Parking: It’s the South Side. It’s a nightmare. There’s a lot nearby, but you might end up walking a few blocks. Just accept it.
- The Shop: They have a retail area. If you liked that gin, buy a bottle. You can’t get this stuff at the state store (Fine Wine & Good Spirits) in the same variety.
The pricing is fair for the quality. You aren't paying Applebee's prices, but you aren't paying Manhattan prices either. It’s that middle ground where you feel like you’re getting a premium experience without needing a second mortgage.
The Reality of Craft Distilling in PA
Pennsylvania has some of the weirdest liquor laws in the country. For a long time, you couldn't really do what Social Still does. When the laws loosened up about a decade ago, it paved the way for places like this.
But it’s hard work.
✨ Don't miss: Cooper City FL Zip Codes: What Moving Here Is Actually Like
Maintaining consistency in small batches is a nightmare. One batch of corn might be slightly sweeter than the last; the humidity in the Lehigh Valley affects how the barrels "breathe." When you drink at Social Still Bethlehem PA, you’re drinking the result of a lot of trial and error. It’s not a factory. It’s a lab.
They also do events. If you can catch a cocktail-making class or a distillery tour, take it. Seeing the height of those stills from the floor level gives you a different perspective on the engineering involved. It’s not just "making booze." It’s chemistry with a high chance of a hangover.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Visit
If you're planning to head down to the South Side, don't just wing it.
Start by checking their current seasonal cocktail list online; they swap things out fast, and you don't want to miss the limited-run infusions. Make a reservation at least four days in advance if you want a prime weekend slot.
When you get there, ask the bartender what’s new in the barrels. Sometimes they have "distiller's selects" or small-batch runs that aren't featured prominently on the main menu.
Finally, plan to walk. After a heavy meal and a couple of high-proof drinks, take the 10-minute stroll over to the SteelStacks. Seeing the machinery that built America while you have a buzz from a local distillery is the most "Bethlehem" experience you can possibly have. It connects the past to the present in a way a history book never could.
Bring a designated driver or use a rideshare. The drinks at Social Still are deceptively smooth, but they pack the punch of a 1920s heavyweight.