Sucker Punch Productions was on a roll in 2005. They had already established a bit of a masterpiece with the second entry in their thieving raccoon saga, but then they dropped Sly 3: Honor Among Thieves and things got weird. Good weird. It was the kind of sequel that didn’t just add a few new moves; it basically invited the whole neighborhood to the party.
If you played it back then, you probably remember the 3D glasses. Those flimsy red-and-blue paper things tucked into the manual? They were a gimmick, sure. But they represented the sheer ambition of a developer trying to squeeze every last drop of personality out of the PlayStation 2 hardware. This wasn't just another platformer. It was a heist movie you could play, wrapped in a Saturday morning cartoon aesthetic that has, honestly, aged better than almost anything else from that console generation.
The Cooper Vault and the Pressure of Ending a Trilogy
Most trilogies stumble at the finish line. They get too bloated or they lose the heart of what made the first one special. Sly 3: Honor Among Thieves managed to dodge most of those bullets by shifting the focus from just "Sly and his two best friends" to a literal army of specialists. The plot is pretty straightforward but carries a lot of weight: Sly finds out about the Cooper Vault, a massive literal mountain of gold and family history on Kaine Island. But there’s a problem. A guy named Dr. M has set up a fortress around it.
Sly realizes the original trio—Bentley and Murray—isn't enough to crack a nut this big. They need a team.
What follows is basically Ocean's Eleven for kids (and adults who like tight gameplay). You go around the world recruiting former enemies and new weirdos. It’s brilliant because it solves the "sequel fatigue" problem. Instead of just giving Sly a double jump or a new cane swing, the game gives you entirely different ways to play. One minute you're a RC car specialist, the next you're a giant hulking masked wrestler, and then suddenly you're playing a flight simulator.
It Wasn't Just About Stealth Anymore
Purists sometimes complain. They say the first game was a pure "one-hit-and-you're-dead" stealth platformer and that the third one got too distracted by minigames. They aren't entirely wrong. But man, those distractions were fun.
Think about the Penelope introduction in Holland. You aren't just sneaking through hallways; you're engaging in full-scale dogfights in the air. Or look at the Guru. He doesn't even have an attack button in the traditional sense. He just jumps on enemies' heads and minds-controls them. It’s chaotic. It’s a complete departure from the "hide in the shadows" loop of the original, but it fits the narrative of a world-class thief building a crew of specialists.
💡 You might also like: Hogwarts Legacy PS5: Why the Magic Still Holds Up in 2026
The variety is the point.
Sucker Punch was experimenting with what a "mascot platformer" could be. At the time, Jak and Daxter had turned into a gritty GTA clone and Ratchet & Clank was leaning hard into being a third-person shooter. Sly stayed true to its platforming roots but expanded the scope horizontally. You had:
- Boat combat that actually felt weighty.
- Deep-sea diving missions.
- Disguise mechanics that required actual social stealth.
- Massive boss fights that felt like multi-stage puzzles.
The Bentley Factor: Why the Writing Worked
We have to talk about Bentley. In Sly 3: Honor Among Thieves, Bentley is the soul of the game. After the ending of the second game—where he was paralyzed—the developers had a choice. They could have "video game'd" it away and healed him. Instead, they leaned into it. They put him in a gadget-laden wheelchair and made him the most versatile character in the game.
It added a layer of maturity.
The banter between the characters feels real. When Sly and Carmelita Fox have their back-and-forth, it doesn't feel like a forced romantic subplot; it feels like two people who have been doing this dance for years. The voice acting, specifically Kevin Miller as Sly and Matt Olsen as Bentley, is top-tier. They have a chemistry that makes the "honor" part of the title actually mean something.
Does it Actually Rank Against Sly 2?
This is the big debate in the fandom. Sly 2: Band of Thieves is often cited as the best because it introduced the open-world hub structure. It was a revolution. Sly 3: Honor Among Thieves is more of an evolution.
📖 Related: Little Big Planet Still Feels Like a Fever Dream 18 Years Later
One thing people often forget is that the third game removed the "clue bottles." Some people hated this. Collecting those bottles was a staple of the series. But by removing them, Sucker Punch forced players to engage more with the missions and the environment rather than staring at corners looking for a green glow. It made the pacing faster. It made the game feel less like a scavenger hunt and more like an operation.
The locations were also objectively better.
- Venice: A perfect tutorial level that used the water beautifully.
- Holland: The aerial combat was a technical marvel for the PS2.
- China: The verticality of the mountains was insane.
- Blood Bath Bay: Pirate ships. Enough said.
The Technical Wizardry of Cell Shading
Visually, this game is a survivor. If you boot up a realistic game from 2005 today, it probably looks like a blurry mess of brown and gray polygons. But Sly 3: Honor Among Thieves used a refined version of the "Sly Render" (their custom cell-shading tech).
The lines are sharp. The colors pop. The character silhouettes are so distinct that you can tell exactly who is on screen just by their shadow. This is why the game looks so incredible in the Sly Collection on PS3 or even when upscaled on an emulator today. It’s timeless. It’s an art style that prioritizes "vibe" over "realism," and in the long run, vibe always wins.
A Legacy Left in Limbo
It’s kind of heartbreaking that we haven't seen the Cooper gang in a long time. Sanzaru Games did a great job with Sly 4: Thieves in Time, but it didn't quite capture that Sucker Punch magic. The third game felt like a definitive ending for a long time, especially with how it handled the Sly and Carmelita relationship.
There’s a reason people still clamor for a remaster or a sequel. The gameplay loop of "explore a hub, do small jobs, then pull off a massive multi-stage heist" is something very few games have replicated. Grand Theft Auto V tried it with their heists, but they lacked the whimsical, rhythmic flow of a Sly Cooper operation.
👉 See also: Why the 20 Questions Card Game Still Wins in a World of Screens
The "Honor Among Thieves" subtitle isn't just flavor text. It’s the core of the game’s philosophy. It’s about a group of outcasts who are better together than they are apart.
How to Experience Sly 3 Today
If you’re looking to dive back in, you have a few options. The original PS2 discs are getting expensive, but they are the "purest" way to play, especially if you have a CRT television to hide some of the jaggies.
The Sly Collection on PS3 is generally considered the gold standard. It bumps the resolution to 720p and keeps a rock-solid 60 frames per second. It also supports the 3D mode without the cardboard glasses, though, let’s be honest, nobody is using that in 2026.
For the most modern experience, many fans have turned to emulation. Running the game on an emulator like PCSX2 allows you to crank the resolution to 4K. When you see Sly 3: Honor Among Thieves running at 4K, you realize just how much detail Sucker Punch put into the textures. You can see the stitching on Sly’s hat. You can see the individual scales on the enemies. It’s a testament to the artists who worked on it.
Next Steps for Potential Players:
- Check your hardware: If you have a PS4 or PS5, look into the PS Plus Premium catalog. The Sly series is frequently rotated into the streaming or classics section.
- Skip the 3D gimmick: Seriously, it was a fun idea in 2005, but it makes the game look washed out and gives most people a headache. Play it in standard color.
- Don't rush the hubs: The best part of Sly 3 is the ambient dialogue. Stand near guards, listen to the world-building, and take your time exploring the rooftops before jumping into the main missions.
- Focus on the "specialists": Take the time to master the new characters like the Panda King or Penelope. Their movesets are weird at first but they make the late-game missions much easier.