It still hurts. Honestly, if you were hanging out on Tumblr or Twitter back in 2011, you remember the absolute gut-punch when The CW pulled the plug on The Secret Circle. It had everything: Brittany Robertson looking perpetually stressed, Thomas Dekker being brooding, and Phoebe Tonkin basically auditioning for her future role as a literal queen in The Originals. But then? Poof. Gone after one season. No resolution for the Balcoin bloodline, no closure for the Blackwell family drama. Just a cliffhanger that still stings over a decade later.
Finding shows like The Secret Circle is actually harder than it looks. You aren't just looking for "witches." You’re looking for that specific, moody, Pacific Northwest aesthetic where the lighting is always dim, the parents have terrifying secrets, and the magic feels heavy. It’s a vibe. It’s high-stakes teen melodrama mixed with ancient, generational curses.
Most people think The Vampire Diaries is the only answer, but that’s surface-level. If you want to scratch that specific itch, you have to dig into the stuff that balances the "group of friends" dynamic with legitimate occult horror.
The Coven Dynamic: Why We Keep Searching for This Feeling
What made The Secret Circle work—and why we still look for it—was the "bound" aspect. It wasn't just one girl discovering she’s a witch; it was a collective. If one person messed up, everyone felt it. That creates a forced intimacy that is a goldmine for television drama.
Take The Magicians, for example.
It's much more adult, sure. Syfy (and later Netflix) let them swear and deal with some truly dark trauma. But at its core, it’s about a group of outsiders finding out that the magic they read about in books is real, dangerous, and kind of a nightmare. Quentin Coldwater is essentially a more depressed version of Cassie Blake. If you haven't seen it, the first season feels like a collegiate version of the Chance Harbor drama, but with much higher stakes and a lot more cynical humor.
Then there’s Salem. People forget this one. It’s not "teen," which might turn some people off, but if the part of The Secret Circle you liked was the historical weight of the families, Salem is your best bet. It’s gritty. It’s dirty. The magic isn’t sparkly; it’s visceral. Janet Montgomery plays Mary Sibley with a sharpness that makes the Blackwells look like amateurs.
The Problem With "The CW Formula"
We have to talk about the 2010s era of supernatural TV. Kevin Williamson, who developed The Secret Circle (and Scream, and TVD), has a very specific thumbprint. He likes fast pacing. He likes attractive people in leather jackets standing in the rain.
When you look for shows like The Secret Circle, you’re often fighting against the "Riverdale-ification" of the genre. Modern shows tend to lean so hard into the camp that they lose the earnestness. The Secret Circle was many things, but it wasn't ironic. It took its lore seriously.
Motherland: Fort Salem is one of the few recent shows that actually captures that serious tone. Instead of hiding in a small town, the witches are the military. It’s an alternate history where the Salem Accord ended the witch trials by drafting witches into the U.S. Army. The "group of three" unit at the center of the show—Raelle, Tally, and Abigail—perfectly mirrors that "forced together by destiny" feeling that Cassie and Faye had.
Hidden Gems That Nailed the Aesthetic
If you're okay with subtitles, Ragnarok on Netflix is a massive sleeper hit for this specific niche. It’s Norwegian. It’s moody as hell. Instead of witches, you’re dealing with Norse mythology reincarnated in modern teenagers. The atmosphere—the mountains, the mist, the sense of an impending apocalypse—is the closest thing I’ve found to the visual "soul" of The Secret Circle.
It’s slow.
Sometimes it’s really slow. But the payoff of seeing a teenager realize he has the power of Thor while dealing with a corrupt local corporation? It works.
Another one: A Discovery of Witches.
This is more "adult" in its execution, but the DNA is the same. Diana Bishop is a historian who finds a bewitched manuscript. She’s a reluctant witch, much like Cassie was. The show spends a lot of time on the "rules" of the supernatural world and the politics between vampires, witches, and daemons. It’s based on the Deborah Harkness novels, so the lore is incredibly tight. No plot holes the size of a truck here.
Why The Secret Circle Failed (And Why Its Successors Succeed)
Let's be real: The Secret Circle was expensive.
At the time, the CGI for the elemental magic cost a fortune. The ratings were okay—around 1.3 million viewers—but for The CW at that time, it wasn't enough to justify the budget when Hart of Dixie was cheaper to make.
Today’s shows have a different hurdle. They have to survive the Netflix "three-season curse." Look at First Kill or The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. Sabrina started out strong—very dark, very much in line with the Blackwell-esque occult vibes—but eventually, it spiraled into musical numbers and confusing underworld politics.
If you want the "dark coven" vibe without the fluff, you should check out:
- The Order (Netflix): It’s got secret societies, magic, and werewolves. It’s a bit more "college frat" than "mystical woods," but the stakes are high.
- Witches of East End: This was Lifetime’s attempt at the genre. It’s a bit soapier, but the chemistry between the sisters (Jenna Dewan and Rachel Boston) is great. It also suffered the "cancelled too soon" fate, so proceed with caution if you hate cliffhangers.
- Light as a Feather: This one is more "supernatural thriller." It’s about a game that goes wrong. It’s shorter, punchier, and focuses heavily on the female friendships—and the betrayals within them.
The "Small Town With a Secret" Trove
Cassie moving to her grandmother’s house in Chance Harbor is a classic trope for a reason. It isolates the characters.
Midnight, Texas did this well, though it’s a bit more "ensemble" than "teen drama." Based on the books by Charlaine Harris (who wrote the Sookie Stackhouse/True Blood series), it’s about a town that serves as a safe haven for people who are... different.
🔗 Read more: The Bill Cosby Show Cast: What Really Happened to the Huxtables
If you want something that feels like a spiritual successor in terms of the "dark family history," look at Locke & Key.
It’s less about spells and more about magical keys, but the House (Keyhouse) is a character in itself, much like the abandoned house the Circle used as their headquarters. It deals with grief, the sins of the father, and the terrifying reality of being a kid with too much power.
Does Age Matter?
Some fans of The Secret Circle want to stay in the YA (Young Adult) lane. Others have grown up and want something that reflects their actual age.
If you're in the latter camp, Mayfair Witches on AMC is the heavy hitter. It’s based on Anne Rice’s work. Alexandra Daddario plays a neurosurgeon who finds out she’s the heir to a dynasty of powerful witches haunted by a sinister entity. It is dense. It is Southern Gothic. It is definitely not for kids. But the way it handles the burden of "family power" is exactly what The Secret Circle was trying to do on a broadcast TV budget.
How to Get the Most Out of Your Next Binge
When you’re diving into these shows like The Secret Circle, don’t expect a 1:1 carbon copy. The TV landscape has changed. Everything is shorter now—8 to 10 episodes instead of the 22-episode seasons we used to get. This means the "filler" episodes, where the characters just hang out and develop chemistry, are mostly gone.
To find your next favorite, you have to prioritize what you liked most about the original:
- If you liked the Dark Magic/Occult: Go with Penny Dreadful (for high art) or The Order (for fun).
- If you liked the Teen Romance/Angst: Shadowhunters or Legacies are your best bets.
- If you liked the Moody Atmosphere: Ragnarok or Chambers.
- If you liked the "Forbidden Book" trope: A Discovery of Witches.
The reality is that The Secret Circle was a lightning-in-a-bottle moment for YA supernatural fans. It arrived right as Twilight mania was peaking but before the market got totally oversaturated.
Actionable Steps for the Displaced Fan
Don't just re-watch the same 22 episodes of The Secret Circle for the tenth time. Here is how to actually move on:
- Read the source material: L.J. Smith wrote the books. They are very different from the show (the characters, the pairings, the lore), but it provides a sense of closure you won't get on screen.
- Track the Creators: Look for shows produced by Andrew Miller or Kevin Williamson. Williamson’s Tell Me a Story is a psychological thriller that uses fairy tale motifs—it has that same dark edge.
- Check out "The Bastard Son & The Devil Himself": This was a Netflix gem that got cancelled way too early (surprise, surprise). it follows the son of a notorious "Blood Witch" and has some of the most creative, brutal magic ever put on screen.
- Broaden the Search: Sometimes the best "witch" show isn't about witches. The Umbrella Academy features a dysfunctional family of "powered" individuals who are bound by a dark childhood and a looming apocalypse. The vibe is different, but the emotional core is identical.
The era of the "22-episode moody teen supernatural drama" might be over as the industry shifts toward prestige limited series, but the themes of belonging, power, and legacy are evergreen. You just have to know which shadows to look in.