Abhishek Chatterjee, better known as Shake, became the name everyone loved to hate during the second season of Netflix’s hit social experiment. It’s been years. We’ve had countless new seasons, new villains, and new "wrong reasons" for being on the show. Yet, the conversation around the Love Is Blind Shake era refuses to die out. Why? Mostly because he didn't just play the villain; he broke the fourth wall of the show's entire premise in a way that felt deeply uncomfortable for viewers and his fellow cast members alike.
He wasn't there to find a "soul connection." At least, that's how it looked from the outside. While the show tries to convince us that looks don't matter, Shake was the guy in the pods asking women if he’d be able to lift them onto his shoulders at a music festival. It was jarring. It was shallow. Honestly, it was exactly what the show claims to be the antidote for, which is why he became such a massive lightning rod for criticism.
The Deepti Vempati Situation and the "Auntie" Comment
The core of the backlash stems from his relationship with Deepti Vempati. On paper, they were a great match. They shared a cultural background, they had high-energy personalities, and they seemed to have genuine fun together in the pods. But once they hit the real world in Mexico, things took a nary turn. Shake began telling everyone—except Deepti—that he wasn't physically attracted to her.
He didn't just say he lacked "the spark." He went on camera and compared being with her to being with his "auntie."
Think about that for a second. You’re on a show meant to prove love is blind, you’ve proposed to a woman, and then you’re telling the world she feels like a family member. It was brutal. Deepti eventually found out, of course, leading to that iconic "I choose myself" moment at the altar. But the damage to Shake’s reputation was done. He wasn't just a guy who wasn't attracted to his partner; he was perceived as someone who was actively negging a woman who was widely considered a fan favorite.
Why the Love Is Blind Shake Persona Grated on Everyone
It wasn't just the comments about Deepti. It was the attitude. Shake carried himself with a specific kind of bravado that felt like a defense mechanism. During the Season 2 reunion, he doubled down. He tried to argue that everyone on the show was thinking about physical appearance and he was just the only one "brave" enough to say it out loud.
✨ Don't miss: Blue Bloods in the News: What’s Actually Happening with the Reagan Family
That didn't sit well with Vanessa Lachey. You might remember the heated exchange where Vanessa basically told him he was in the wrong show. Shake’s response? He claimed the only person he was attracted to on the stage was Vanessa herself. It was a chaotic, cringe-inducing moment that cemented his status as the series' most unapologetic antagonist.
The Veterinary Career vs. Reality TV
One of the more interesting layers to this is his professional life. Shake is a veterinarian. People expect vets to be empathetic, kind, and soft-spoken. Seeing that professional background clash with his "DJ Shake" persona created a weird cognitive dissonance for the audience. He’s clearly smart. He’s successful. But his social intelligence in the context of a romantic reality show seemed to be lagging.
Post-show, he didn't go into hiding. He did the opposite. He leaned into the notoriety. He started a podcast. He leaned into the "truth-teller" brand, even when that "truth" felt like it was just being mean-spirited. This is a common trajectory for reality stars now, but Shake was one of the first in the Love Is Blind franchise to truly embrace the villain edit as a permanent lifestyle choice.
The Cultural Impact of the "Villain" Edit
Is it possible he got a bad edit? Sure. Every reality contestant does to some extent. But you can't edit words into someone's mouth. When he’s on a boat in Chicago telling other men that he’s not "feeling it" because of her body type, that’s on him.
The Love Is Blind Shake phenomenon actually forced the show to change how it handles casting and editing. In later seasons, we saw more "villains" like Bartise or Zanab, but Shake remains the blueprint. He represents the segment of the population that cannot actually look past the physical, no matter how much they want to believe they can. In a way, he proved the show’s premise can fail spectacularly if the person involved isn't ready to do the internal work.
- The Music Festival Metric: His obsession with being able to carry a woman on his shoulders became a meme-able symbol of shallow dating.
- The Reunion Fallout: His public spat with the hosts was a first for the franchise.
- Life After Netflix: His move to Miami and his subsequent relationship (which he posted about frequently to prove his "type") felt like a final rejection of the show's values.
What We Can Actually Learn From This Mess
Looking back, the whole saga is a masterclass in what happens when someone values "brutal honesty" over "kind honesty." Shake thought he was being authentic. The rest of the world thought he was being a jerk. There's a fine line there.
If you're dating, the "Shake lesson" is pretty simple: attraction matters, but how you handle the absence of it matters more. You can't force a physical connection. However, you can choose not to humiliate the person you're with while you figure it out. Deepti walked away with a book deal and a massive following. Shake walked away with a reputation that he’s still trying to pivot into a "controversial influencer" career.
He eventually moved on to other reality ventures, appearing on House of Villains alongside people like Jax Taylor and New York. It was a better fit. In a house full of people who are paid to be the bad guy, Shake finally found an environment where his brand of bluntness was the requirement, not the exception.
The Reality of Modern Dating Reflected in Season 2
We have to admit that Shake said out loud what a lot of people think silently. Dating apps have turned us into a society that swipes based on a millisecond of visual data. Love Is Blind tries to fight that. Shake was the reminder that the "old way" of picking partners based on aesthetics is a hard habit to break.
His presence on the show was a failure of the experiment, but a victory for "good" television. It gave us a hero to root for (Deepti) and a common enemy to discuss at the water cooler. Without him, Season 2 might have been a bit too sugary. He provided the friction that made the season's conclusion so satisfying for millions of viewers who wanted to see Deepti realize her worth.
Actionable Takeaways for Reality TV Fans and Daters
If you find yourself still thinking about the Love Is Blind Shake drama, use these insights to navigate your own perspectives on relationships and media:
✨ Don't miss: Bunny Lake Is Missing: Why This 1960s Thriller Still Messes With Your Head
- Differentiate between honesty and cruelty. Being "real" doesn't give you a pass to be unkind. In your own life, if the attraction isn't there, communicate it early and privately rather than venting to third parties.
- Watch for the "Hero/Villain" Binary. Remember that reality TV is edited for maximum impact. While Shake's comments were his own, the show benefits from having a clear antagonist. Always look for the nuance in how these stories are framed.
- Evaluate your own "dealbreakers." Shake’s "shoulder-carry" test was ridiculous, but we all have subconscious biases. Identifying yours can help you avoid the same pitfalls of shallow dating.
- Support the "Rise after the Fall." Follow creators like Deepti who used the negative experience to promote self-love and empowerment. Their post-show journeys often offer more value than the drama itself.
- Understand the "Villain Pivot." When a reality star leans into being the bad guy, it's often a business move. Don't take the bait of online arguments; it’s usually exactly what they want to stay relevant in the algorithm.
The story of Shake is a reminder that while love might be blind for some, for others, the blindfold is just too heavy to wear. He remains the most honest failure in the history of the show.