Why Seven Deadly Sins Meliodas Is Still One of Anime’s Most Controversial Leads

Why Seven Deadly Sins Meliodas Is Still One of Anime’s Most Controversial Leads

He looks like a kid. He drinks like a fish. He carries a broken sword that turns out to be a key to a literal apocalypse. When people talk about the seven deadly sins meliodas, they usually fall into one of two camps: those who love the "troll" energy he brings to every fight, and those who can’t stand his early-series behavior. But if you look past the surface-level tropes that Nakaba Suzuki leaned on back in 2012, there is a strangely complex tragedy underneath that yellow hair.

Meliodas isn't your standard shonen protagonist. Most of these guys—think Naruto or Luffy—start from the bottom. They want to be the King or the Hokage. Meliodas? He starts at the top. He’s already the strongest guy in the room, and honestly, he’s bored of it. Or rather, he’s exhausted.

The Curse That Changed Everything

Imagine living for 3,000 years. Now imagine watching the person you love die over and over again. It’s not just death; it’s a cycle. Meliodas is cursed with Eternal Life by the Supreme Deity, while Elizabeth is cursed with Perpetual Reincarnation by the Demon King.

The mechanics are brutal. Every time Elizabeth regains her memories of her past lives, she dies three days later, usually right in front of him. He’s seen her die 106 times. Think about that for a second. Most people would go catatonic after seeing a loved one pass once. He’s done it over a hundred times while staying physically frozen as a teenager.

This context is what most casual viewers miss when they see him acting goofy or "pervy" in the first season of Nanatsu no Taizai. While the humor hasn't aged particularly well for many modern audiences, within the lore, it’s often framed as a desperate, almost manic mask to hide the fact that he is a literal war criminal who betrayed his own species for a love that is constantly being ripped away from him.

👉 See also: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks

Why His Power Levels Keep Breaking the Scale

Early on, we see him beating down Ruin or Golgius with basically a piece of sharpened metal. It feels like typical "overpowered protagonist" stuff. But the reveal regarding his "Full Counter" ability is where things get interesting. Unlike most mages in the series, Meliodas doesn't actually produce his own offensive magic most of the time. Full Counter is purely a defensive move that reflects magic back at the attacker with more than double the power.

It’s a metaphor for his entire existence. He doesn't want to be the aggressor anymore.

When he was the leader of the Ten Commandments, he was the "Love" commandment—ironic, right?—and he was terrifying. The shift from the ruthless heir of the Demon King to the guy running a moving pub called the Boar Hat is the core of his character arc. His power isn't just about big explosions or "Lostvayne" clones; it's about the struggle to keep his "Assault Mode" suppressed. Every time he uses his true demonic power, he loses a bit of his emotions. He gets colder. He gets closer to the monster he used to be.

The Problem With the Dragon's Sin of Wrath

You’d expect the Sin of Wrath to be a guy who screams a lot. Like Bakugo from My Hero Academia or something. But Meliodas is the Sin of Wrath because of one specific event: the destruction of Danafor.

✨ Don't miss: A Simple Favor Blake Lively: Why Emily Nelson Is Still the Ultimate Screen Mystery

He didn't just get into a fight. He lost control of his power after witnessing the death of Liz (one of Elizabeth's incarnations) and literally wiped a kingdom off the map. A giant, bottomless pit was all that was left. That’s why he’s the Dragon's Sin. His "Wrath" isn't a personality trait; it’s a catastrophic failure of self-control that cost thousands of lives.

Breaking Down the Commandment Era

People often debate whether Meliodas was actually "evil" during the Holy War. From the perspective of the Goddess Clan, absolutely. From the perspective of the Demons, he was a traitor.

The relationship between Meliodas and his brothers, Zeldris and Estarossa (who has his own massive spoiler-heavy identity crisis), is arguably the best-written part of the series. Zeldris hates him not just because he left, but because Meliodas's betrayal made life a living hell for those who stayed behind. It adds a layer of familial guilt that makes the final battles feel much heavier than just "good vs. evil."

What the Fans Usually Get Wrong

A common misconception is that Meliodas is just "naturally" a good guy who happens to be a demon. That’s not really the case. He was a monster. He was the most feared entity in the Demon Realm. His choice to change was sparked by Elizabeth, sure, but the series explores the idea that he’s constantly fighting his nature.

🔗 Read more: The A Wrinkle in Time Cast: Why This Massive Star Power Didn't Save the Movie

Is he a hero? By the end of the manga and the "Four Knights of the Apocalypse" sequel, he’s a King. He’s a father. But he’s also a man who has lived through more trauma than the rest of the cast combined.

How to Engage With the Series Today

If you’re just starting, keep a few things in mind. The animation quality in the later seasons (produced by Studio Deen instead of A-1 Pictures) takes a notorious dive. If the "bloody" scenes looking like white paint bothers you, you might want to switch to the manga for the final arcs. The art in the manga by Nakaba Suzuki remains some of the most consistent and dynamic in the industry.

Actionable Steps for Fans and Newcomers:

  • Watch the Prequel Content First? No. Watch the main series in order. The mystery of why Meliodas doesn't age and why he has a weird symbol on his forehead is part of the hook.
  • The "Four Knights of the Apocalypse" Connection: If you finished the main story and felt it was a bit rushed, read the sequel. It focuses on the next generation, but seeing Meliodas as a settled-down King provides a much-needed "happily ever after" that the main series struggled to land perfectly.
  • Check the Side Stories: There are various "extra" chapters that detail how he met the other Sins. The story of how he recruited Ban is particularly important for understanding their brotherhood.
  • Focus on the Themes: Don't just watch for the fights. Look at the theme of "destiny vs. free will." The entire plot is about two people trying to break a script written for them by literal gods.

Meliodas remains a polarizing figure in the anime community, but his influence is undeniable. He’s a subversion of the "shonen hero" because his battle isn't about becoming the strongest—it's about the burden of already being the strongest and trying to find a way to be a "human" instead.