Honestly, walking into Season 13 Criminal Minds felt like stepping onto a moving train that was missing half its wheels. It was 2017. The show was reeling. If you remember the absolute chaos behind the scenes—Thomas Gibson’s sudden exit the previous year and the revolving door of cast members—you know the vibe was tense. Fans were skeptical. I was skeptical. How do you keep a procedural about the darkest corners of the human psyche fresh after 270-plus episodes?
The answer, it turns out, was a mix of soft-rebooting the team and leaning hard into some of the most experimental storytelling the series had ever tried.
The Casting Carousel and the Arrival of Matt Simmons
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room. The BAU (Behavioral Analysis Unit) has always been about chemistry. When you lose a pillar like Hotch, the structural integrity of the show wobbles. By the time we hit the premiere of Season 13 Criminal Minds, titled "Wheels Up," the producers were scrambling to find a balance.
Enter Daniel Henney.
Henney’s character, Matt Simmons, wasn't actually new. He came over from the short-lived spin-off Criminal Minds: Beyond Borders. It was a smart move. Instead of forcing us to learn a brand-new backstory for a stranger, they gave us a guy we’d already seen work with the team. He fit. He brought this grounded, tactical energy that complimented Alvez and Reid perfectly.
📖 Related: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
But it wasn't just about the new guy. This season had to solidify Paget Brewster’s Prentiss as the definitive leader. She wasn't just "filling in" anymore. She was the boss. Period. Watching her navigate the bureaucratic nightmare of Assistant Director Linda Barnes (played with wonderful villainy by Kim Rhodes) became the season's actual backbone.
What Really Happened With Mr. Scratch?
If you were watching live, you know the "Mr. Scratch" storyline had been dragging on since Season 10. It was getting a bit much. Peter Lewis was essentially a boogeyman with pharmacological superpowers. He was the most "comic book" villain the show ever had, and honestly, the resolution in the season 13 premiere felt like a mercy killing for that plotline.
It was fast. It was brutal. It involved a car crash and a rooftop confrontation that ended Scratch's reign of terror once and for all. Some people hated how quickly it wrapped up, but looking back, the show needed to clear the deck. It allowed the writers to get back to what they do best: weird, isolated cases that make you double-check your locks at night.
The Masterpiece of "Believer" and the 300th Episode Setup
The back half of the season is where things actually got interesting. We need to talk about "Believer."
👉 See also: The Lil Wayne Tracklist for Tha Carter 3: What Most People Get Wrong
This wasn't your standard "unsub of the week" fluff. The introduction of "The Messengers" and the cult leader Benjamin Merva flipped the script. It wasn't just about a serial killer; it was about a systemic failure and a threat that the BAU couldn't just profile away. The season ended on a massive cliffhanger with Reid and Garcia’s lives hanging in the balance, which leads directly into the milestone 300th episode in Season 14.
The pacing here was wild. One week you’d have a standard procedural episode like "Submerged," and the next, you’re diving into a deep-state conspiracy or a cult hideout. It kept the audience on their toes.
Why the Critics Were Wrong About the "Fatigue"
Critics in 2017 were saying the show was tired. They called it "grimdark" for the sake of being grim. But they missed the nuance. Season 13 Criminal Minds actually leaned more into the personal lives of the team than previous years. We saw JJ’s past coming back to haunt her. We saw Reid trying to reintegrate after his prison stint in Season 12—which, let’s be real, was a traumatic arc that the show actually bothered to let him process.
Matthew Gray Gubler’s performance remained the heartbeat of the series. Even as the show around him changed, his portrayal of Spencer Reid evolved from a quirky genius into a deeply scarred, resilient veteran.
✨ Don't miss: Songs by Tyler Childers: What Most People Get Wrong
The Episodes You Actually Need to Re-watch
If you’re binging the series again, don't just let it play in the background. Pay attention to these specific beats:
- "Lucky Strikes" (Episode 5): This brought back Jamie Kennedy as Floyd Feylinn Ferell. It was a callback to Season 3 that actually worked. It didn't feel like cheap fan service; it felt like the show acknowledging its own long, dark history. Plus, seeing Garcia deal with the trauma of her past shooting through the lens of this case was heartbreaking.
- "False Flag" (Episode 9): This is a sleeper hit. It’s basically a bottle episode centered on a group of conspiracy theorists. It’s heavy on dialogue, light on action, and incredibly relevant to the era of "fake news" we were entering. It showed that the BAU’s profiling tools could be used to deconstruct logic, not just find bodies in basements.
- "The Capilanos" (Episode 17): Directed by Matthew Gray Gubler. If you want "weird," this is it. It’s about clowns. It’s terrifying. It has that specific, Lynchian vibe that Gubler always brings to his episodes.
Navigating the Linda Barnes Era
A lot of fans genuinely hated the "Barnes" arc. I get it. She was frustrating. She broke up the team, reassigned everyone to boring desk jobs, and almost ended the BAU.
But from a storytelling perspective, she was necessary. Every long-running show needs an internal antagonist to make the "family" unit bond tighter. When the team was forced to work a case behind her back in "Annihilator," it recaptured that "us against the world" feeling that made the early seasons so addictive. It reminded us why we cared about these people in the first place.
Actionable Takeaways for the Dedicated Fan
If you're revisiting Season 13 Criminal Minds, or perhaps watching it for the first time on streaming, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience:
- Watch Season 12 first. You cannot jump into Season 13 cold. The trauma of Reid's imprisonment and the Scratch cliffhanger are foundational. If you skip the lead-up, the first three episodes of Season 13 won't land.
- Focus on the Prentiss/Barnes dynamic. Instead of just being annoyed by the bureaucracy, look at how Paget Brewster plays the political game. It’s a masterclass in subtle leadership acting.
- Track the "Messengers" clues. The cult storyline in the finale isn't as out-of-nowhere as it seems. There are small breadcrumbs dropped in the later half of the season regarding missing persons and unexplained cult activity.
- Appreciate the tech jump. Season 13 saw a noticeable uptick in how Garcia’s "magic" was presented. The show started integrating more realistic cybersecurity concerns (at least by TV standards) which added a layer of modern dread.
Season 13 Criminal Minds wasn't perfect, but it was a pivot point. It proved the show could survive massive cast turnover and still deliver stories that stick with you. It took a team that was fractured and turned them into a unit that felt earned, not just assigned.
If you want to see how the show finally closed the loop on the 15-year journey, make sure to follow the breadcrumbs from the Season 13 finale straight into the "300" episode. The transition is seamless and provides one of the most satisfying payoffs in procedural history.