Memes usually die. They fade into the digital background, replaced by a new dance trend or a nonsensical audio clip that lasts for exactly three weeks before vanishing. But some things are different. Some things are too weird to disappear. If you’ve spent any time in the stranger corners of YouTube or looked through lists of the most unsettling "kids' movies" ever made, you’ve seen it. You’ve seen the Santa Claus Ice Cream Bunny.
It’s a fever dream. Honestly, there is no other way to describe the 1970 film The Santa Claus Marshmallow Bunny (often conflated with its more popular title, The Santa Claus and the Ice Cream Bunny). It’s the kind of thing that makes you wonder what the producers were thinking, or if they were thinking at all. You have a sweating Santa stuck in the sand in Florida. You have a group of children who seem more confused than excited. And then, for reasons that still haven't been fully explained by modern science or film theory, a giant rabbit arrives in a fire truck.
What Actually Is the Santa Claus Ice Cream Bunny?
To understand why this exists, you have to look at the era of "kiddie matinee" films. Back in the late 60s and early 70s, Barry Mahon—a man known more for his "adult" features and low-budget exploitation flicks—decided to pivot. He realized he could make a quick buck by filming cheap children's stories and renting them out to theaters for weekend morning slots. Parents would drop their kids off for two hours of peace, and the quality didn't really matter.
The plot is thin. Santa’s sleigh is stuck in the Florida sand at Pirates World, a defunct theme park in Dania, Florida. He’s hot. He’s wearing a thick suit in 90-degree weather. He tries to summon help by telepathically calling local children. They bring him various animals to pull his sleigh—a pig, a cow, a gorilla (which is clearly just a guy in a very bad suit). Nothing works. Then, the Ice Cream Bunny arrives.
But here is the kicker: the movie is barely 30 minutes of "plot." To pad the runtime so theaters could actually charge for it, Mahon inserted a completely different, pre-existing film into the middle of it. Depending on which version you see, Santa sits the kids down to watch a live-action version of Thumbelina or Jack and the Beanstalk. You literally watch a movie inside a movie. It’s a nesting doll of low-budget choices.
The Pirates World Connection
The setting isn't just a random beach. It's Pirates World. For those who didn't grow up in South Florida during the 70s, Pirates World was a legitimate, though somewhat chaotic, amusement park. It opened in 1966 and was actually quite popular until Walt Disney World opened up north and basically crushed the local competition.
Filming at Pirates World was a cost-saving measure. The park got free advertising, and Mahon got a set. However, the result is an eerie, abandoned aesthetic that makes the Santa Claus Ice Cream Bunny feel like it was filmed in a post-apocalyptic wasteland rather than a place of joy. The rides are visible in the background, silent and still. It adds a layer of "liminal space" energy that modern internet users find fascinating and creepy.
Why the Internet Won't Let It Go
Why do we care? Because it’s authentic.
🔗 Read more: Marcus Theatres Village Pointe: What Most People Get Wrong
In a world where everything is polished by AI and corporate focus groups, this film is a disaster of human proportions. It’s raw. You can see the sweat on Santa’s brow. You can hear the bad audio mixing. The Ice Cream Bunny itself is a nightmare—a stiff, unblinking costume that looks like it belongs in a true crime documentary.
RiffTrax, the successors to the Mystery Science Theater 3000 crew, played a massive role in reviving interest. Kevin Murphy, Michael J. Nelson, and Bill Corbett gave it the "treatment" in 2010, and it became an instant classic in their catalog. They pointed out things most viewers would miss, like the fact that the fire truck the bunny drives is actually moving at a dangerously high speed through a crowd of small children.
Common Misconceptions About the Film
- It was intended to be scary. No, it was genuinely meant to be a whimsical holiday film. The "horror" is entirely accidental, born from a low budget and poor lighting.
- The bunny is an Easter Bunny. While he looks like one, he is specifically the Ice Cream Bunny. He represents a local ice cream brand/character that was supposed to be a "thing" in Florida.
- It’s a lost film. Not at all. It’s widely available on YouTube, Amazon Prime, and through RiffTrax. It’s very easy to find if you’re brave enough.
The Technical "Art" of a Disaster
From a technical standpoint, the film is a masterclass in what not to do. The cinematography is static. The editing is jarring. The transition between the Santa framing story and the Thumbelina segment is so abrupt it feels like a mistake.
Yet, there is a weird sort of genius in the pacing. It’s slow. Deliberate. It forces you to sit with the absurdity. When the kids are pulling the various animals toward Santa, the scene goes on for an eternity. It breaks every rule of modern "content." It doesn't care about your attention span. It just exists.
How to Experience the Madness Correctly
If you're going to watch the Santa Claus Ice Cream Bunny, don't do it alone. This is a communal experience. It’s a litmus test for your friends. If they can sit through the weirdly long scenes of the dog "singing" or the disturbing close-ups of the bunny's face, they're probably your people.
- Watch the RiffTrax version first. It provides a necessary layer of protection between you and the film’s actual energy.
- Look for the Pirates World landmarks. It’s a fascinating look at a piece of lost Florida history.
- Pay attention to the gorilla. It is widely considered one of the worst costumes in cinematic history. It’s incredible.
The film serves as a reminder that the past was a lot weirder than we remember. Before every piece of media was sanitized for global consumption, you could have a movie where a fire-truck-driving rabbit saves a sweltering Santa in a bankrupt theme park. It’s a piece of "outsider art" that accidentally became a cult legend.
Moving Forward With Your New Knowledge
Now that you've been introduced to this specific brand of holiday chaos, the next logical step is to explore the "Kiddie Matinee" genre. Barry Mahon wasn't the only one doing this. Look into the works of K. Gordon Murray, who imported and dubbed strange Mexican fairy tale films for American audiences.
The Santa Claus Ice Cream Bunny is just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to bizarre, low-budget mid-century children's entertainment. These films represent a time when the rules of cinema were being broken daily, often just to save a few dollars on film stock.
If you're looking for something to watch during the holidays that isn't a Hallmark movie, this is it. It’s memorable. It’s weird. It’s a conversation starter. Just don't blame the bunny if you have weird dreams afterward.
For the best experience, seek out the high-definition restoration by the American Genre Film Archive (AGFA). They’ve preserved the film in all its grain-heavy, over-saturated glory, ensuring that the Ice Cream Bunny will continue to confuse future generations for decades to come.
Check out the RiffTrax "Live" version for the best commentary. It adds a level of context and humor that makes the surrealism much more digestible for a modern audience. Explore other Pirates World history sites to see how the park looked in its heyday compared to the bleak version shown in the film.