Checking the San Francisco 49ers scores on a Sunday afternoon used to feel like a predictable ritual. You knew what you were getting. Brock Purdy would efficiently distribute the ball, Christian McCaffrey would find the end zone twice, and the defense would suffocate the opponent into a low-scoring mess.
Lately? It’s chaos.
Watching the Niners in 2025 and heading into 2026 has been a roller coaster that frankly, most fans' hearts weren't ready for. One week they’re hanging 40 on a division rival, and the next, they're struggling to find the uprights in the fourth quarter. It’s weird. Honestly, it's more than weird—it’s a fundamental shift in how Kyle Shanahan’s offense is operating under pressure. If you're just looking at the final numbers on a scoreboard, you're missing the real story of why this team is suddenly playing so many "one-score" games.
The Red Zone Math That’s Killing the Momentum
The box score usually lies. It tells you the Niners had 400 yards of offense, but it doesn't show you the three times they settled for field goals inside the 10-yard line. That’s been the kryptonite.
Success in the NFL is basically a math problem. When you look at San Francisco 49ers scores over the last two seasons, the volatility comes down to "Expected Points Added" (EPA) in the red zone. Historically, Shanahan’s teams are masters of the "Leaky Roof" defense—they wait for you to mess up. But offensively, they’ve hit a snag where the condensed field is neutralizing their speed.
Brandon Aiyuk’s contract saga and subsequent return to form changed the geometry of the field, but the real issue has been the offensive line's push on third-and-short. When you can't run the ball in the "low red," your scores drop from 28-31 points per game down to that dangerous 17-20 range. That’s where the losses happen.
🔗 Read more: Texas vs Oklahoma Football Game: Why the Red River Rivalry is Getting Even Weirder
It’s frustrating. You see Purdy make a 40-yard laser to George Kittle, the crowd goes nuts, and then—clunk. Three runs for two yards. Field goal. The scoreboard says 3, but the momentum says 0.
Why the Defense Isn't Smothering People Like It Used To
We have to talk about the defensive side of these San Francisco 49ers scores. For years, the Niners were a "lock." If they scored 24, they won. Period. The defense wouldn't allow more than 17.
But the NFL caught up to the wide-9 front.
Teams are using quick-game releases to neutralize Nick Bosa. If you get the ball out in 2.2 seconds, it doesn't matter if Bosa is a Greek god of pass rushing; he isn't getting there. This has forced the Niners into higher-scoring shootouts. They can't just sit on a lead anymore.
- The secondary has been forced to play more man-to-man.
- Injuries to key linebackers have opened up the middle of the field for "Texas" routes and shallow crosses.
- Opponents are going for it on fourth down more often against SF than almost any other team in the league.
Basically, the "safe" lead is dead. If you see a score of 21-10 at halftime, don't turn the TV off. The way this roster is currently constructed, they are built to front-run, but they've struggled when the other team starts swinging back in the third quarter.
💡 You might also like: How to watch vikings game online free without the usual headache
The Purdy Factor and "Garbage Time" Reality
Let’s be real about Brock Purdy. Critics love to talk about "system quarterbacks," but if you actually watch the film, he’s the only reason some of these scores aren't embarrassing.
There’s this phenomenon in San Francisco 49ers scores where the final result looks closer than the game actually was. Or vice versa. Purdy has developed this knack for the "hero ball" scramble that keeps drives alive when the play design fails. According to Next Gen Stats, Purdy’s completion percentage over expected (CPOE) remains elite, but the timing of his turnovers has shifted. A pick-six in the second quarter changes a 14-point swing. That’s why a game that feels like a blowout ends up being a 24-23 nail-biter.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Coaching
People blame Kyle Shanahan for "choking" or mismanaging the clock when the scores flip late. It’s a tired narrative.
The reality is more nuanced. Shanahan calls plays based on a "sequence." If a run works in the first quarter, he’s setting up a play-action for the third. But when the Niners fall behind—which has happened more frequently lately—the sequence breaks. He’s forced to become a "drop-back" play-caller, and that’s not where this team excels.
The scores reflect this struggle. Look at their splits when trailing versus when leading. It’s a different team.
📖 Related: Liechtenstein National Football Team: Why Their Struggles are Different Than You Think
How to Actually Predict the Next Scoreboard
If you're trying to figure out how the Niners will perform next week, stop looking at the opponent's rank. Look at the turf.
Seriously.
The Niners are a "speed and precision" team. On fast tracks (like SoFi or Allegiant), their scores skyrocket. On grass that’s a bit chewed up or in weather, their timing-based offense stutters. Their scores in outdoor, grass stadiums are notably lower over the last 24 months than in domes or on high-end synthetic surfaces.
Also, watch the first fifteen plays. Shanahan is the king of the "scripted" start. If the Niners don't score on their first two possessions, they rarely hit the 30-point mark. They are a momentum engine. Once the engine stalls, it takes a lot of torque to get it moving again.
Essential Action Steps for Following the Niners
Don't just look at the final number. To understand where this team is going, you need to track a few specific metrics that dictate the San Francisco 49ers scores more than any "expert" commentary will.
- Monitor the "Points Per Trip" in the Red Zone. If this number is below 5.0, the Niners are in trouble, regardless of how many yards Purdy throws for.
- Check the "Average Depth of Target" (aDOT). When the Niners are winning big, Purdy is hitting intermediate routes (10-15 yards). If the score is low and the game is tight, it’s usually because they’re dinking and dunking or taking too many desperate deep shots.
- Watch the Turnover Margin in the 2nd Quarter. This is specifically when the Niners tend to let teams back into the game, leading to those frustratingly close final scores.
- Track In-Game Injuries to the Interior O-Line. This team can survive a missing receiver, but if the center or guards go down, the score will plummet because the run game—the heart of the team—dies instantly.
Stop focusing on the win-loss column and start looking at the efficiency of the scoring drives. A 20-17 win against a bad team is often more concerning than a 31-34 loss against a contender. The "how" matters way more than the "what" when it comes to the San Francisco 49ers.