Honestly, most people overthink the whole DIY holiday thing. They spend forty dollars at a craft store on specialized resin kits or fancy glass-blowing setups only to realize they've made a giant, sticky mess on their dining room table. You don't need all that. If you want to know how to make a ornament that actually lasts long enough to become a family heirloom—the kind you pull out of a dusty cardboard box in twenty years and get all misty-eyed over—you only need three things. Flour. Salt. Water. That’s it. It’s the "salt dough" method, and while it sounds like something from a preschool classroom, professional artisans have been using variations of this since the 17th century for "Zopf" bread decorations and folk art.
It's simple. But people still mess it up.
They mess it up because they treat it like a cooking project. It isn't. You aren't making a cookie; you're basically making a ceramic-style stone using kitchen pantry staples. If you rush the drying or get the ratios wrong, the ornament will puff up like a pita bread or, worse, rot from the inside out because of trapped moisture.
The Chemistry of the Perfect Salt Dough
Let’s get into the weeds for a second. The reason this works is the salt. Most people think the salt is just there for texture. Nope. Salt acts as a preservative and a structural binder. When you mix it with flour and water, the sodium chloride inhibits the growth of mold and bacteria. That’s why a well-made salt dough ornament can literally last for decades.
You’ll want to use two parts all-purpose flour to one part fine-grain table salt. Don't use sea salt. The flakes are too big. It makes the surface look like a sidewalk in winter. Use the cheap, ionized stuff from the bottom shelf. Gradually add about three-quarters of a part of warm water. Warm is better than cold because it helps the salt crystals start to dissolve just enough to create a smooth "clay."
Knead it. Then knead it more. You want it to feel like soft playdough but not sticky. If it sticks to your hands, add a dusting of flour. If it cracks when you roll it, add a teaspoon of water. It’s a tactile thing. You’ll feel the moment the gluten in the flour relaxes and the dough becomes elastic.
👉 See also: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
Why Your Ornaments Keep Cracking
The biggest mistake? The oven. I see so many tutorials telling people to "bake" their ornaments at 300 degrees. That is a disaster waiting to happen. High heat causes the water inside the dough to turn into steam. Steam expands. Expansion leads to bubbles, warping, and those annoying cracks that ruin a perfectly good handprint or stamped design.
Set your oven to its lowest possible setting. Usually, that’s around 170°F to 200°F (about 75°C to 95°C). You aren't "cooking" the ornament; you are dehydrating it. Think of it like making beef jerky or dried fruit. It’s a slow process. Depending on how thick you rolled the dough—I recommend about a quarter-inch—this can take anywhere from three to five hours. Flip them halfway through. If you’re patient enough, air-drying for two days is actually the safest way to avoid any distortion, though most of us don't have that kind of shelf space or patience.
Beyond the Basics: Making It Look Professional
Once you have your blank canvas, you have to decide on the aesthetic. This is where most DIY projects go from "Pinterest Win" to "Toddler Art." If you want a high-end look, stay away from the primary color acrylic paints.
Instead, try these techniques:
- Botanical Impressions: Take a sprig of rosemary, a pine needle, or a dried leaf. Lay it on the dough and roll over it once with a rolling pin. Peel it back to reveal a perfect, fossil-like imprint.
- Letter Stamps: Use a small set of metal or rubber alphabet stamps to press names or dates into the dough. It looks incredibly clean and minimalist.
- Sandalwood or Cinnamon: You can actually mix spices directly into the flour before adding water. It changes the color to a warm terracotta and makes the whole house smell like a hearth for weeks.
The Sealing Secret
This is the part everyone skips. If you live in a humid climate, your salt dough ornament will eventually absorb moisture from the air. Salt is hygroscopic—it loves water. If you don't seal it, it will eventually get soft and crumble.
✨ Don't miss: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting
You need a clear acrylic sealer. A spray-on matte finish usually looks the most "high-end," but a glossy Mod Podge works if you want that glazed ceramic look. Make sure you get the edges and the back. You are essentially shrink-wrapping the dough to protect it from the environment.
Advanced Alternatives: The Cornstarch and Baking Soda Method
Maybe you don't like the rustic, slightly grainy look of salt dough. Maybe you want something that looks like pure white porcelain. There’s a "secret" recipe used by wedding decor designers that involves one cup of baking soda, a half-cup of cornstarch, and three-quarters of a cup of water.
You cook this one in a saucepan over medium heat until it looks like mashed potatoes. Once it cools, it’s the whitest, smoothest modeling clay you’ve ever seen. It’s a bit more finicky to work with—it dries out faster than salt dough—but the result is stunning. It’s particularly good for ornaments that use fine-line ink pens or delicate watercolors.
Real-World Examples of What Works
I’ve seen people use these techniques to create incredible things. One artist, Sarah K. Benning, is known for her embroidery, but she’s mentioned in various craft circles how the "impression" method works for capturing textures. People are now using vintage lace doilies pressed into the dough to create intricate, Victorian-style patterns that look like they cost $50 at a boutique.
Another popular trend is the "Map Ornament." You take a simple circular salt dough base, paint it a solid color, and then decoupage a tiny piece of a map—maybe the place you got married or your first home—onto the center. A quick coat of varnish over the top, and it’s a professional-grade gift.
🔗 Read more: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- The Hole Problem: Forget to poke a hole for the string before you dry it? You’re in trouble. Trying to drill through dried salt dough usually results in the whole thing shattering. Use a straw to punch a clean hole while the dough is still wet.
- The Thickness Trap: If it’s too thin, it’ll warp like a potato chip. If it’s too thick (over half an inch), the outside will dry while the inside stays doughy, leading to internal rot.
- Using "Self-Rising" Flour: Don't do it. Just don't. Your ornament will turn into a muffin.
Moving Toward Your First Project
To get started, don't try to make twenty ornaments at once. Start with a small batch. Test your oven’s temperature. Maybe try one traditional salt dough and one baking soda version to see which aesthetic fits your home better.
The real magic of learning how to make a ornament isn't about the physical object. It's about the fact that you're creating something out of basically nothing. It’s sustainable, it’s dirt cheap, and it’s a skill that hasn't changed much in hundreds of years.
Once you’ve mastered the dry-down process, move on to experimenting with natural dyes. You can use beet juice for pinks, turmeric for a vibrant gold, or coffee grounds for a weathered, antique look. The possibilities are honestly endless once you stop looking at it as a "kid's craft" and start looking at it as a medium for sculpture.
Next Steps for Your Ornament Project:
- Clear the Calendar: Allot a full afternoon. Most of the work is passive (drying), but you need to be around to flip the ornaments and check for bubbling.
- Gather Your Tools: Find your rolling pin, a few cookie cutters, and a standard drinking straw for the hanging holes.
- Source Your Sealer: Pick up a can of clear coat spray from a hardware store. It’s the single most important factor in making sure your work lasts until the next generation takes over the tree.
- Practice Your Pressure: If you're doing imprints, practice on a scrap piece of dough first to see how hard you need to press to get a deep detail without cutting all the way through the material.