You know that specific type of hunger that only a greaseless, crispy-edged local pizza can fix? It’s a craving. Honestly, if you live anywhere near Central Connecticut, you’ve probably heard people arguing about the best slice in the "Hard Hittin’" city. New Britain has a crazy deep food history, mostly rooted in Polish delis and old-school Italian spots. But Royal Pizza New Britain occupies this weirdly perfect middle ground. It isn't a fancy artisan bistro with $30 wood-fired pies, and it isn't a cardboard-crust chain either. It’s a neighborhood staple.
People get defensive about their local spots. It’s personal. Royal Pizza has managed to survive the constant churn of the restaurant industry by basically doing one thing: staying consistent. In a world where everything feels like it's getting smaller and more expensive, finding a place that still loads the toppings on a grinder or keeps the crust snap just right matters. It really does.
What Makes Royal Pizza New Britain Stand Out in a Pizza Town?
New Britain isn't exactly short on options. You’ve got the heavy hitters nearby, and everyone has an opinion on who makes the best thin crust. So why do people keep coming back here? It’s the texture. Most people describe the style here as a hybrid—sort of a cross between a traditional New York slice and that slightly thicker, pan-style Greek pizza that’s so common across Connecticut.
📖 Related: Mr Ring A Ding: What Most People Get Wrong About the 1950s Ice Cream Legend
The cheese blend is key. If you look closely at a Royal Pizza pie, it’s not just oily mozzarella. There’s a specific "stretch" and "saltiness" that suggests a blend. It browns in those little polka-dot patterns that tell you the oven is actually hot enough. Cold ovens make sad pizza. Royal doesn't do sad pizza.
Let’s talk grinders for a second. If you’re not from New England, you call them subs or hoagies. Whatever. Here, they're grinders, and Royal Pizza New Britain does them "the right way." That means the bread is toasted enough to have a crunch, but the inside stays soft enough to soak up the oil and vinegar. Their Italian combo is a local legend. It’s huge. Like, "I need a nap immediately after this" huge.
The Menu Mechanics
It’s a massive menu. Seriously. It’s one of those places where you can get a side of gyro meat, a bucket of fried chicken, a calzone the size of a football, and a garden salad all in one order. Usually, when a place does everything, they do everything poorly. That’s the rule, right? Jack of all trades, master of none.
Somehow, they skip that trap.
The wings are a sleeper hit. Most pizza joints have those soggy, sad wings that feel like they were microwaved in a plastic bag. Not here. They actually get some crisp on the skin. If you’re ordering for a game or a Friday night, the "Value Package" deals they run are basically a rite of passage for New Britain residents. It's affordable. That’s a word we don't hear much in 2026, but Royal keeps the price-to-portion ratio actually fair.
The Neighborhood Vibe and Why Location Matters
Located on Arch Street, Royal Pizza is right in the thick of it. It’s not a "destination" spot with valet parking and dim lighting. It’s a "park on the street, run in, grab your steaming hot box, and burn the roof of your mouth on the way home" kind of place. That’s the charm.
New Britain has changed a lot over the last decade. You see new developments, the CTfastrak bringing people in, and the downtown area trying to find its new identity. Through all of that, Royal Pizza New Britain has stayed a constant. It’s a bit of a community hub. You’ll see contractors grabbing lunch, students from CCSU looking for a cheap dinner, and families picking up three large pies for a birthday party.
A Note on the Sauce
Sauce is a polarizing topic. Some people want it sweet like candy. Others want it so acidic it melts your teeth. Royal hits a savory note. It’s got a heavy hit of oregano and garlic, which stands up well against the heavier toppings like sausage or pepperoni. It isn't watery. There is nothing worse than a "soggy bottom" pizza where the sauce has turned the dough into mush. You can hold a Royal slice with one hand—the "fold" works. That's the gold standard.
Dealing With the "New Britain Pizza" Reputation
There is a lot of competition. You have places like Tony’s or Roma’s nearby, each with their own cult following. If you ask ten people in New Britain who has the best pizza, you will get twelve different answers. It’s chaotic.
Royal Pizza New Britain wins on reliability.
Have you ever ordered from a place and it’s amazing one night, then the next week it’s a total disaster? That’s the worst. Royal has a reputation for being the same every single time. If you liked the meat lovers' pizza six months ago, it’s going to taste exactly the same tonight. That consistency is why they have customers who have been coming for twenty years.
- The Crust: Medium thickness, crispy bottom, airy rim.
- The Service: Fast, no-nonsense, local.
- The Variety: They have things like "Buffalo Chicken Pizza" that actually have enough spice to make you sweat a little.
Real Talk: The Limitations
Let’s be honest. If you are looking for a vegan, gluten-free, cauliflower-crust experience with micro-greens and truffle oil... this probably isn't your spot. Royal Pizza is unapologetically old-school. It’s about gluten. It’s about dairy. It’s about meat. While they have salads and some lighter options, the heart of the menu is built for people who want a hearty, filling meal.
Also, it’s a busy spot. If you call at 6:00 PM on a Friday during football season, expect a wait. That’s not a bad thing—it means the food is fresh—but don't expect a 10-minute turnaround when the rest of the city has the same idea as you.
Why Small Businesses Like This Still Matter
In the age of DoorDash and massive corporate pizza chains that taste like salt and chemicals, local spots like Royal Pizza New Britain represent something important. They are locally owned. The money stays in the community. The people behind the counter probably recognize your face if you go there more than twice.
There’s a soul to a local pizza shop. You can hear the dough being slapped, the sound of the metal peels hitting the oven floor, and the chaotic energy of the kitchen. It’s a sensory experience that a chain simply cannot replicate.
Actionable Tips for Your Next Order
If you’re planning on heading over or calling in an order, here is how to maximize the experience. Don't just wing it.
First, check the specials. They almost always have a combo deal that includes a soda or wings which ends up being significantly cheaper than ordering a la carte. Second, if you like your pizza extra crispy, ask for it "well done." Because of the cheese blend they use, a "well done" Royal pizza gets these incredible caramelized edges that are arguably the best part of the whole meal.
Third, don't sleep on the appetizers. The garlic knots are usually drenched in enough garlic butter to keep vampires away for a century, which is exactly how they should be.
Next Steps for Your Royal Pizza Experience:
👉 See also: Original flavors of Starburst: The Real Reason They Still Dominate the Candy Aisle
- Try the "Royal Special": It’s the namesake for a reason. It’s loaded with peppers, onions, mushrooms, and several types of meat. It’s the ultimate litmus test for the kitchen.
- Download their direct app or use their website: While they are on third-party delivery platforms, you usually get better pricing and faster service by going direct.
- Explore the Grinder Menu: If you aren't in the mood for pizza, the steak and cheese or the chicken parm grinders are top-tier. Ask for extra sauce on the side.
- Cash is sometimes easier: While they take cards, having cash for a quick pickup at the counter is always a pro move in local New Britain spots.
Royal Pizza New Britain isn't trying to reinvent the wheel. They're just making sure the wheel is delicious, hot, and delivered on time. Whether you're a lifelong "Hard Hitting" resident or just passing through Hartford County, it’s a slice of the city’s actual culture. It’s honest food for honest people. Go grab a slice. Seriously. You've earned it.