It was the summer of 2021. Las Vegas was buzzing. WWE had just returned to live touring after a long, silent stint in the "ThunderDome," and the Allegiant Stadium was packed for SummerSlam. The main event? Roman Reigns vs John Cena. It felt massive. But if you really look back at the history between these two, that match was actually the second time they’d tried to settle who really owned the "Face of the Company" title.
The first time happened in 2017 at No Mercy. Honestly? It was a bit of a disaster. Not the wrestling itself, but the vibe. Roman wasn’t ready. Cena was too good on the mic. The fans hated the "Big Dog" persona they were being forced to swallow. But by 2021, everything changed. Roman was the "Tribal Chief." Cena was the Hollywood legend coming back for one last run at a record-breaking 17th world title. It wasn't just a wrestling match; it was a collision of two different eras of WWE philosophy.
The Brutal Reality of the 2017 Promo Wars
You can't talk about Roman Reigns and John Cena without talking about that one specific promo on Monday Night Raw in August 2017. It’s legendary for all the wrong reasons if you’re a Roman fan. Cena basically tore him apart. He called Roman a "corporate-created John Cena bootleg." He mocked Roman for forgetting his lines. He looked at the camera and told the world that Roman couldn't do his job.
It was painful to watch.
At the time, WWE was trying to make Roman the new Cena—the white-meat babyface who overcomes the odds. The problem? The fans didn't want a new Cena. They wanted something real. Cena, being the veteran he is, leaned into that. He exposed the cracks in Roman's armor. Even though Roman won the match at No Mercy 2017, he lost the war of public opinion. He hadn't earned the spot yet. He was still living in the shadow of the "Hustle, Loyalty, Respect" era.
Why the Tribal Chief Persona Changed Everything
Fast forward to 2020. Roman returns at SummerSlam with Paul Heyman by his side. Suddenly, the guy who used to wear tactical vests and enter through the crowd was gone. In his place was a cold, calculated mob boss. This version of Roman Reigns didn't care if you cheered him. He wanted you to "acknowledge" him.
👉 See also: Questions From Black Card Revoked: The Culture Test That Might Just Get You Roasted
This is where the John Cena rivalry gets interesting again. When Cena returned at Money in the Bank 2021 to challenge Roman, the power dynamic had flipped completely. Roman was now the most interesting thing in professional wrestling. He wasn't the "next" John Cena anymore; he was the first Roman Reigns.
Cena came back with his classic energy, cracking jokes and wearing colorful t-shirts, but Roman met him with a terrifying, stoic silence. During their contract signing, Roman looked Cena in the eye and basically told him he was a relic. He called Cena "predictable" and "boring." For the first time, Cena didn't have the upper hand. He was the one trying to prove he still belonged in a ring that now belonged to the Bloodline.
The SummerSlam 2021 Showdown
The match itself at SummerSlam was a masterclass in storytelling. You had Cena going for the quick win, trying to catch Roman with an Attitude Adjustment early on. He knew he couldn't outlast Roman in a brawl. He was the veteran looking for a "greatest hits" victory.
Roman, though, was methodical.
Every time Cena built up momentum, Roman shut it down with a glare or a heavy strike. The finish was clean. Roman hit the Spear, pinned the 16-time champion, and stood over him while the crowd—which used to boo Roman out of every building—watched in something resembling awe. It was the definitive end of the Cena era. When Brock Lesnar’s music hit right after the match, it almost felt like a post-credits scene in a movie where the hero had already been defeated.
✨ Don't miss: The Reality of Sex Movies From Africa: Censorship, Nollywood, and the Digital Underground
Breaking Down the Numbers: Cena vs Reigns
If you look at their televised singles matches, the record is pretty lopsided.
- No Mercy (September 24, 2017): Roman Reigns defeats John Cena via Pinfall.
- SummerSlam (August 21, 2021): Roman Reigns defeats John Cena via Pinfall.
It’s rare for a legend like Cena to lose twice in a row in major premium live events to the same person without getting a win back. It shows how much faith WWE put into Roman. They weren't just giving him a "rub"; they were handing him the keys to the kingdom.
But it’s not just about wins and losses. It’s about the "Cena Effect." John Cena has this weird superpower where he makes his opponents better by being a jerk to them. By pushing Roman to his limits on the microphone, he forced Roman to find a personality that worked. Without those embarrassing moments in 2017, we might never have gotten the Tribal Chief in 2020.
The Misconception of the "Fake" Rivalry
People often think these guys hate each other in real life because of how personal those promos got. "You're a part-timer," Roman would yell. "You can't do your job," Cena would fire back.
Actually, it’s the opposite. Cena has gone on record multiple times, including on the WWE After the Bell podcast and various media junkets, praising Roman’s work ethic. He’s called Roman the "GOAT" of this generation. Roman, likewise, has acknowledged that Cena set the blueprint for what a top star needs to be. The heat was "worked," but the stakes were real. They were fighting for the position of being the person the company builds its entire financial future around.
🔗 Read more: Alfonso Cuarón: Why the Harry Potter 3 Director Changed the Wizarding World Forever
What This Taught Us About Modern Wrestling
The Roman vs Cena saga proved that "passing the torch" isn't a single moment. It’s a process. You can’t just beat the old guy and become the new guy. You have to survive the old guy’s shadow first.
- Authenticity beats branding: Roman failed as a babyface because he was a brand. He succeeded as a heel because he was a character.
- The microphone is a weapon: Cena almost "buried" Roman in 2017 just by talking. It proved that in the modern era, if you can’t talk, you can’t lead.
- Legacy is transferable: By letting Roman win decisively, Cena ensured that his own legacy would help prop up the next ten years of WWE programming.
Looking Forward: Will There Be a Third Match?
As of 2026, John Cena has moved into the "Retirement Tour" phase of his career. He’s been open about the fact that his body can’t do this forever. Roman, meanwhile, has moved into a part-time schedule himself, appearing only for the biggest shows.
Is a "Rubber Match" possible? Probably not. The story is told. Roman won the war. Seeing them go at it again would feel like a nostalgia act rather than a high-stakes battle for supremacy. Cena has transitioned into the role of the respected elder, and Roman has become the "Final Boss" of WWE.
If you want to understand why WWE is currently in a massive boom period, you have to look back at these two. The transition from Cena to Reigns was messy, loud, and sometimes uncomfortable, but it worked. It created a standard for excellence that the current roster, including guys like Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins, now has to live up to.
How to Analyze Future "Torch Passes"
When you're watching WWE today and you see a veteran facing a rising star, ask yourself three things to see if it measures up to the Roman/Cena standard:
- Is there genuine tension? Does it feel like the veteran is actually testing the younger wrestler, or are they just "doing the job"?
- Has the younger wrestler evolved? Roman didn't stay the same; he changed his look, his music, and his attitude.
- Is the outcome decisive? Tainted finishes don't pass torches. Clean pins do.
To truly appreciate the depth of this rivalry, go back and watch the "Contract Signing" segment from the August 13, 2021, episode of Friday Night SmackDown. Watch the body language. Notice how Roman doesn't even stand up when Cena enters. That’s where the torch was actually passed—not with a wrestling move, but with the confidence of a man who knew he didn't need John Cena's approval anymore.
Pay attention to the promos of 2017 versus 2021. The difference in Roman's vocal cadence and eye contact is a blueprint for anyone trying to build a personal brand in any industry. It’s about the shift from seeking validation to commanding respect. Once you see that shift, you’ll understand why that feud defined an entire decade of sports entertainment.