Why Return to Monkey Island is the Sequel Nobody Expected But Everyone Needed

Guybrush Threepwood is a mess. When we first met him decades ago, he was a scrawny kid with a dream of becoming a mighty pirate. Fast forward to the release of Return to Monkey Island, and he’s... well, he’s still Guybrush. But everything around him has changed. The world is sharper, the humor is dryer, and the legacy of Ron Gilbert’s creation is finally, mercifully, complete.

It's weird.

For years, the "Secret" of Monkey Island was the gaming world's equivalent of what was inside the briefcase in Pulp Fiction. We obsessed over it. We theorized. Then, Gilbert and Dave Grossman finally came back to give us an answer. But they didn't give us a standard nostalgia trip. They gave us something much more self-reflective.

The Art Style Drama and Why It Actually Works

Let's address the elephant in the room immediately. People lost their minds over the art. When the first trailers for Return to Monkey Island dropped, the internet did what the internet does best: it complained. People wanted the chunky pixels of The Secret of Monkey Island or the lush, hand-drawn vibes of The Curse of Monkey Island. Instead, they got Rex Crowle’s abstract, angular, scrapbook-esque aesthetic.

It felt jarring at first. Honestly, I hated it for about twenty minutes.

But then you play it. You see the way the characters move. You realize that this paper-puppet style allows for more expressive facial animations than we ever would have gotten with a retro-pixel filter. It feels like a memory that’s been slightly distorted by time. That’s the point. Guybrush is telling this story to his son, Boybrush, while they sit on a bench. Memories aren't high-definition. They’re colorful, jagged, and exaggerated.

The art reflects the internal state of a protagonist who is desperately trying to recapture his glory days while the world moves on without him.

Guybrush vs. The New Guard

The story kicks off with a punch to the gut for long-time fans. The old pirate leaders—those iconic guys in the SCUMM Bar—have been replaced. They’ve been ousted by "Dark Ninja Pirates" led by Captain Madison. These newcomers represent the modernization of everything. They don’t care about traditions, "Insult Sword Fighting," or the romanticized version of piracy Guybrush clings to. They’re efficient. They’re corporate. They’re kinda terrifying.

This creates a fascinating friction.

You’re playing as a legacy character in a world that thinks he’s a joke. Even LeChuck, Guybrush’s eternal nemesis, seems weary. Their rivalry has become a routine. It’s a loop. Return to Monkey Island leans heavily into this meta-commentary. Are we, the players, just like Guybrush? Are we just trying to relive 1990 over and over again?

The Gameplay: Modernizing the Point-and-Click

Point-and-click adventures usually die because of "moon logic." You know the type. You have to combine a rubber chicken with a pulley to cross a gap for no logical reason. Terrible.

Grossman and Gilbert fixed this. The hint book in this game is a masterclass in game design. It’s an in-game item that gives you gradual nudges rather than straight spoilers. It knows where you are in the story. It knows if you’ve already picked up the mop or if you’re still wandering around the Low Street.

• The inventory system is streamlined.
• The UI doesn't clutter the screen.
• Context-sensitive cursors tell you exactly what you can do without the old "Verb Coin" hassle.

It’s fast. It’s snappy. You aren't fighting the interface; you're fighting the puzzles. And the puzzles are clever. They require you to actually listen to the dialogue. If you skip the flavor text, you’re going to get stuck. That's how it should be.

Does the Secret Finally Get Revealed?

I won't spoil the ending, but I’ll say this: Ron Gilbert stayed true to himself. If you were expecting a literal, physical treasure that explains the universe, you haven't been paying attention to his work.

The "Secret" has always been a Rorschach test for the player. Return to Monkey Island doubles down on the idea that the journey, the obsession, and the storytelling are the actual point. Some players found the ending frustrating. I get it. It’s abrupt. It’s weird. But it’s also the only honest way to end a series that started as a parody of Disneyland rides.

The game is a literal "return" to the theme park vibes of the original. It’s about the artifice of adventure. When you see the mechanical components behind the scenes of Mêlée Island, it doesn't ruin the magic. It just changes what the magic is.

🔗 Read more: Minecraft The Ender Dragon Egg: What You Actually Do With It

The Return of the Voice Legends

We have to talk about Dominic Armato. The man is Guybrush. Without his specific cadence—that mixture of unearned confidence and whimpering terror—the game wouldn't work. Hearing him interact with Alexandra Boyd’s Elaine Marley feels like putting on a pair of old, comfortable boots.

Elaine is handled much better here than in some previous entries. She isn't just a damsel or a goal to be won. She has her own life. She’s running a campaign to eliminate scurvy. She’s supportive of Guybrush but also clearly worried about his obsession. It’s a mature look at a long-term relationship. It adds a layer of heart that the series usually trades for jokes.

And then there's Stan. Good old Stan the Salesman. He’s in jail when you find him, still wearing that ridiculous jacket. His dialogue is still a mile a minute. The game manages to bring back all these characters—Otis, Carla, Murray the Talking Skull—without it feeling like a cheap "greatest hits" tour. They all have a reason to be there.

Why This Matters in 2026

In an era of hyper-realistic 4K shooters and endless live-service grinds, a game like Return to Monkey Island is a miracle. It’s a quiet, funny, thoughtful puzzle game about growing old. It proves that there is still a massive market for narrative-driven experiences that don't require 100 hours of "map clearing."

The game also addresses its own history with the "Scrapbook." If you’re a newcomer, the Scrapbook catches you up on the lore. If you’re a veteran, it’s a nostalgic trip through the previous five games (yes, it acknowledges the ones Gilbert didn't direct, which was a class act).

Technical Performance

I played this on a few different platforms. The Switch version is surprisingly great. Touchscreen controls make sense for this genre. On PC, it’s flawless. Because the art style isn't chasing realism, it looks crisp on everything from a high-end rig to a Steam Deck. It’s an accessible game. You don't need a $2,000 GPU to appreciate the lighting effects in the Monkey Head.

Navigating the Hard Mode vs. Casual Mode

The game offers two distinct ways to play: Casual and Hard.

Pick Hard. Seriously.

Casual mode removes entire steps from the puzzles. It skips the nuance. The Hard mode (Writer's Cut, essentially) contains the "real" puzzles that make the Monkey Island series famous. If you play on Casual, you’re finishing a 10-hour game in 4 hours and missing the best jokes. The satisfaction of finally figuring out how to get the golden key from the locksmith is why you bought the game in the first place. Don't rob yourself of that.

Is it the Best in the Series?

That’s a loaded question. The Secret of Monkey Island is a foundational text. LeChuck’s Revenge is arguably the best-designed adventure game ever made. Return to Monkey Island sits comfortably in the top three. It’s better than Escape and Tales, and it’s more cohesive than Curse, even if Curse had that beautiful 90s Disney animation style.

It feels like a closing chapter. It’s the "Old Man Logan" of adventure games.

Actionable Steps for Your Playthrough

If you're diving in for the first time or planning a replay, keep these things in mind to get the most out of the experience:

1. Examine everything twice. The dialogue for the second or third time you click an object is often funnier than the first.
2. Talk to the NPCs until you exhaust the tree. The world-building is hidden in the optional dialogue branches, especially with characters like the Museum Curator.
3. Don't use the hint book immediately. Give your brain at least 15 minutes to stew on a puzzle. The "Aha!" moment is the primary currency of this genre.
4. Collect the Trivia Cards. They are scattered throughout the world and hidden under rocks or behind crates. They test your knowledge of the entire series and add a fun, low-stakes collectible element.
5. Pay attention to the music. Michael Land, Peter McConnell, and Clint Bajakian returned for the score. It’s reactive. The music shifts instruments and tempo depending on which part of the island you’re in. It’s a technical marvel that many people overlook.

Return to Monkey Island isn't just a game; it's a conversation between a creator and his audience. It’s a reminder that we can’t go back to the way things were, but we can find something new and meaningful in the present.

Go find the mop. Get on the ship. Just don't expect the "Secret" to be what you think it is.

Next Steps for Players:

• Check your settings and ensure "Writer's Cut" or "Hard Mode" is selected for the full puzzle experience.
• Look for the hidden trivia cards immediately upon arriving at Mêlée Island to maximize your collection.
• If you're stuck on the "Mop Handle" quest, remember to check the forest—the tree you need is more distinctive than the others.