It’s been years, but we still haven’t recovered from the boat trip in Cartagena. Honestly, if you mention the words "Real Housewives of New York City Season 10" to any die-hard Bravo fan, they don’t just remember a TV show; they remember a shift in the tectonic plates of reality television. It was the year of the "mention it all" leg-flash, the year of the Nutcracker, and the year the Luann-Bethenny-Carole triad finally snapped under the weight of its own ego.
People forget how high the stakes felt back in 2018.
The season wasn't just about rich women drinking rosé in the Hamptons. It was a Shakespearean tragedy disguised as a reality show. We saw the disintegration of a decade-long friendship between Bethenny Frankel and Carole Radziwill, a dissolution so bitter it basically changed the DNA of the show forever. It was fast. It was loud. It was deeply, uncomfortably real.
The Carole and Bethenny Fallout Nobody Saw Coming
The primary engine behind Real Housewives of New York City Season 10 was the cold war between "Princess" Carole and the Skinnygirl mogul. For years, they were an inseparable duo. Then, suddenly, they weren't. Fans spent months dissecting every Instagram comment and blog post trying to figure out what happened. Was it about Adam Kenworthy? Was it about Bethenny’s intensity? Or was it just that Carole had finally had enough of being a supporting character in the Bethenny Frankel Show?
The tension peaked during the reunion, which remains one of the most hostile sit-downs in Andy Cohen's career. Carole famously called Andy out for being "scared" of Bethenny. It was awkward. You could feel the air leave the room.
Unlike other seasons where fights are manufactured for the cameras, this felt like watching a real divorce. There was no "agree to disagree" moment. When Carole didn't return for Season 11, it felt like the end of an intellectual era for the franchise. She brought a specific, journalistic detachment that balanced out the shrieking. Without her, the show leaned harder into the slapstick, which was fun, sure, but it lost that "smart girl" edge that defined the middle years of RHONY.
That Nightmare Trip to Colombia
We have to talk about the boat.
📖 Related: Why American Beauty by the Grateful Dead is Still the Gold Standard of Americana
If you haven't seen the Cartagena trip, you haven't seen peak survivalist television. The ladies were trapped on a vessel that was legitimately taking on water and smelling of engine grease. While the editors tried to keep it light with music, the raw footage showed genuine terror. This wasn't a "produced" scare. The women were screaming, crying, and—in a very RHONY twist—suffering from a collective, violent bout of food poisoning that left them all bedridden in a luxury villa.
It was the ultimate equalizer.
Seeing Luann de Lesseps, fresh off a stint in rehab and dealing with the fallout of her arrest in Palm Beach, trying to maintain her "Countess" dignity while the house was in a state of medical emergency was peak comedy. Season 10 captured Luann at her most vulnerable and, arguably, her most delusional. She was obsessed with her cabaret show, Countess and Friends, to a point that bordered on performance art.
The Countess, The Arrest, and The Cabaret
Luann's arc in Real Housewives of New York City Season 10 is actually a case study in crisis management. Or lack thereof. She started the season following a high-profile arrest in Florida for battery on a law enforcement officer. She was facing serious jail time. Most people would go into hiding. Luann? She leaned into the spotlight.
"Life is a cabaret," she sang, while her friends were desperately trying to tell her she was spiraling.
The intervention scene at the dinner table, where Bethenny breaks down in a panic attack while Luann calmly talks about her poster size, is one of the most surreal moments in television history. It highlighted the massive disconnect between the cast members. While Bethenny was grieving the sudden death of her ex, Dennis Shields, and dealing with her own trauma, Luann was in a bubble of sequins and showtunes.
👉 See also: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
It was frustrating to watch, but you couldn't look away.
Why This Specific Cast Worked
The chemistry of the Season 10 cast—Bethenny, Luann, Ramona, Sonja, Carole, Dorinda, and Tinsley—was lightning in a bottle. You had:
- Ramona Singer: The "Ageless" instigator who managed to offend everyone in Brooklyn and Manhattan simultaneously.
- Sonja Morgan: At her most chaotic, trying to launch "Paper Magazine" shoots and living in a townhouse that was literally falling apart.
- Dorinda Medley: The host from hell at Blue Stone Manor. "I made it nice!" turned into "Clip! Clip!"
- Tinsley Mortimer: The socialite trying to find her footing in a group of women who treated her like a younger sister they didn't really like.
They weren't just colleagues. They were a social circle that had existed, in some form, for twenty years. That’s the ingredient modern reality TV misses. You can't fake twenty years of resentment. When Ramona brings up Bethenny’s past or Dorinda attacks Sonja’s finances, it cuts deep because they know where the bodies are buried.
The Technical Brilliance of Season 10
From a production standpoint, the editing this season was top-tier. The use of flashbacks to contradict what the ladies were saying in real-time became a staple of the RHONY brand. If Ramona claimed she never said something, the editors had the receipts ready within three seconds.
It was also the last season that felt truly "New York." We saw the Upper East Side charity circuit, the downtown loft parties, and the ham-fisted attempts at "Hamptons chic." The city was a character. Subsequent seasons felt more like they were filming in a vacuum or a soundstage, but Season 10 felt like a love letter (and a hate mail) to Manhattan high society.
Misconceptions About the Carole vs. Bethenny Feud
A lot of people think the fight was about Adam Kenworthy not wanting to film for free. That was the surface-level spark, but the reality was much deeper. Carole had recently spent time in Ethiopia doing humanitarian work; she came back changed. Bethenny was in the middle of her BStrong disaster relief efforts.
✨ Don't miss: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
They were both under immense pressure, but their coping mechanisms were opposite. Bethenny wanted total loyalty and constant validation. Carole wanted space and intellectual autonomy. It was a classic personality clash that was inevitable. If you re-watch the season, you can see the micro-aggressions starting as early as the first episode. The "ghosting" wasn't sudden—it was a slow fade that turned into a wildfire.
Lessons Learned from the 2018 Era
What can we actually take away from Real Housewives of New York City Season 10?
First, the realization that "reality" in reality TV has a shelf life. After this season, the cracks were too big to mend. The cast started to self-produce more. They became more aware of their "brand" and less willing to be truly ugly on camera. Season 10 was the last time we saw them truly unhinged without a PR script in hand.
Second, it proved that the "villain" role is fluid. In any given week, you could hate Bethenny and love Carole, or find Luann's narcissism charming and Dorinda's "drunk talk" horrifying. There were no white hats.
Moving Forward: How to Watch Like an Expert
If you're revisiting this season or watching for the first time, don't just focus on the screaming matches. Look at the background. Look at the way these women interact with staff, with their children, and with the "regular" people of New York.
Take these steps to get the most out of your re-watch:
- Watch the "Before They Were Housewives" specials: It gives context to the Luann and Ramona rivalry that spans three decades.
- Track the "BStrong" timeline: Notice how Bethenny's real-world heroics contrast with her interpersonal volatility. It's a fascinating look at how someone can be "good" to the world but "difficult" to their friends.
- Read the blogs: During Season 10, the cast still wrote weekly Bravo blogs. Reading Carole’s long-form essays alongside Bethenny’s sharp rebuttals adds a layer of depth the episodes miss.
- Follow the fashion: This was the peak of the "Jovani" era. The obsession with designer labels and the "Countess" aesthetic is a character study in itself.
Real Housewives of New York City Season 10 wasn't just a season of TV. It was the peak of an era. It was the high-water mark before the franchise eventually headed toward a total reboot. While the new cast is great in their own way, they’ll never quite capture the specific, gin-soaked madness of the original Manhattan legends at the height of their powers.