Ever been lying in bed at 3 a.m. and suddenly wondered if a straw has one hole or two? It's a classic. Your brain just decides to go rogue. Most people dismiss these as intrusive thoughts or just "being weird," but there’s actually a deep psychological and philosophical rabbit hole behind why we ask random crazy questions.
Sometimes these queries are literal. Other times, they’re just hypothetical nonsense that helps us decompress. Think about it. We spend our entire day optimizing for "productivity" and "synergy" and "deliverables." Our brains get bored. So, they start asking if you could technically lead an army of crows if you fed them enough peanuts. Spoiler: crows are actually terrifyingly smart, and research from the University of Washington shows they can recognize and remember human faces for years. So, the "army of crows" thing isn't even that crazy.
👉 See also: Why Knee High Moccasin Boots are Still the Best Choice for Your Feet
The Science of Curiosity and the Absurd
Why do we do this? Why does the human mind drift toward the impossible?
Neuroscience suggests that curiosity is linked to the brain's reward system. When we seek answers—even to something as ridiculous as "How many chickens would it take to kill a lion?"—our brain releases dopamine. It’s the same chemical hit you get from eating chocolate or winning a bet. Dr. Matthias Gruber, a researcher at UC Davis, found that when people are in a high state of curiosity, they learn and retain information much better. Even if the information is totally useless.
But let's get into the weeds.
If you ask a physicist a "random crazy question" like "What would happen if you tried to hit a baseball pitched at 90% the speed of light?", they don’t just laugh. Randall Munroe, the creator of XKCD, actually did the math on this one. Basically, everything within a few miles would be leveled by a massive thermonuclear explosion. The ball wouldn't even "hit" the bat; the atoms would just fuse.
We ask these things because we want to test the boundaries of reality. It's a mental stress test.
Philosophy or Just Nonsense?
There is a fine line between a shower thought and a foundational philosophical problem. Take the "Ship of Theseus." It’s a classic thought experiment: if you replace every single board on a wooden ship one by one, is it still the same ship? Now, translate that into a "random crazy question" for the 21st century: If you replace every part of your smartphone, do you still have the same phone? Or, more existential: if every cell in your body replaces itself every seven years, are you still "you"?
It’s the same question. One just sounds like a dusty textbook and the other sounds like something you’d ask your friends after three beers.
The Power of "What If"
Hypotheticals are the engine of human progress.
Elon Musk asking if we could land a rocket vertically was once considered a "random crazy question."
People laughed.
Then it happened.
A lot of the tech we use today started as a weird edge case that someone refused to ignore.
✨ Don't miss: Range Rover Car Cost: What Most People Get Wrong
- What if we could put the entire library of human knowledge in a pocket-sized glass rectangle?
- What if we could talk to someone on the other side of the planet instantly?
When kids ask these things, we call it imagination. When adults do it, we call it "random crazy questions." Honestly, we should probably lean into it more. It keeps the mind flexible. If you only ever think about things that are "useful," your cognitive horizons start to shrink. You become a bot.
Social Bonding Through the Bizarre
Let’s talk about social dynamics. Why is "Is a hotdog a sandwich?" the most controversial question of the last decade? Because it’s safe. In a world where everyone is arguing about politics, religion, and the economy, arguing about processed meat is a relief. It’s a low-stakes way to understand how someone else thinks.
Do they rely on strict definitions (the "structuralist" view)? Or do they care more about the vibe (the "functionalist" view)?
If someone says a hotdog is a sandwich, they are likely a chaotic neutral person who enjoys watching the world burn. If they say it's its own category, they probably value order and taxonomy. You’ve just learned something deep about their personality without asking a single boring "So, what do you do for a living?" question.
Breaking Down the Most Common Random Crazy Questions
We see the same ones pop up over and over on Reddit and Quora. There's a reason for that. They tap into universal human experiences.
The "Animal Kingdom" Queries
People love comparing themselves to animals. "How many 5-year-olds could you take in a fight?" is a dark but common one. Or the classic: "Who would win, a trillion lions or the sun?" (The sun. Obviously. It's a giant ball of plasma. Numbers don't matter there).
These questions allow us to explore our place in the natural world. We are physically weak compared to most predators, so we use our brains to win these hypothetical fights. It’s a form of ancestral ego-stroking.
The "Body Horror" Thoughts
"Why can't we tickle ourselves?"
Actually, we know the answer to this. Your cerebellum predicts your own movements and cancels out the sensory response. If you could tickle yourself, it would actually be a sign of a neurological issue, possibly related to schizophrenia, where the brain can't distinguish between self-generated and external stimuli. So, next time you're bored and trying to tickle your own ribs, be glad it isn't working.
The "Physics of Life"
"If everyone on Earth jumped at the same time, what would happen?"
The answer is... nothing. We are tiny. If you gathered all 8 billion people in one spot (like the size of Rhode Island) and everyone jumped, we would push the Earth away by about the width of an atom. Then, when we landed, we'd pull it back. No "earthquake." No orbital shift. Just a lot of tired people.
Why You Should Never Stop Asking Them
The moment you stop asking weird stuff is the moment you stop growing. Creative professionals often use "oblique strategies" or "random input" to solve problems. If you're stuck on a business problem, asking a random crazy question like "How would a pirate solve this?" can actually trigger a breakthrough.
It forces your brain out of its rut. It breaks the "functional fixedness"—the mental bias that limits us to using an object or an idea only in the way it is traditionally used.
🔗 Read more: Fucking the text man for texts: Why Your Messaging Strategy Is Failing
If you want to stay sharp, you need to entertain the absurd. You need to wonder why we drive on parkways and park on driveways. You need to think about whether a straw has one hole (topologically, it’s a torus, so yes, one hole) or two.
Actionable Ways to Use "Crazy" Questions for Brain Health
Don't just let these thoughts pass by. Use them.
- Gamify your social life: Instead of "How's work?", ask "If you had to replace your left hand with a kitchen utensil, which one would it be?" You'll get much better stories.
- Solve problems sideways: When you're stuck, ask the most "random" version of your problem. "How would I solve this if I had a budget of $0 and a team of squirrels?" It sounds stupid, but it forces you to identify the core constraints of your situation.
- Write them down: Keep a "nonsense log." Some of the best inventions and stories in history started as a "what if" that seemed too dumb to mention out loud.
The next time a weird thought hits you at 3 a.m., don't go back to sleep immediately. Google it. Read the physics. Check the philosophy. Your brain is trying to tell you it's ready to learn something new, even if that something is the exact terminal velocity of a falling penny (it’s about 30-50 mph, and no, it won’t kill someone if dropped from the Empire State Building—it just hurts).
Stay weird. It's the most human thing you can do.