Honestly, the first week of the NFL season is a giant lie. We spend months talking ourselves into certain players, then Week 1 happens, and suddenly everyone is ready to bench a future Hall of Famer for a rookie who had one good quarter. It's chaos. But now that we're staring at qb rankings week 2, the picture starts to get a little less blurry. You've got guys like Josh Allen playing like he’s in a video game, while others, like Joe Burrow, are struggling to move the chains.
It's basically a balancing act. Do you trust what you saw for four quarters, or do you trust the four years of elite tape that came before it?
The Heavy Hitters: Who Stays at the Top?
Josh Allen is currently a monster. There’s no other way to put it. In his first game of 2025, he put up 394 passing yards and two scores through the air, then decided to run for two more just for fun. When you look at qb rankings week 2, he’s the undisputed king of the "Elite QB1" tier. He’s facing a New York Jets defense next, which is never a walk in the park, but Allen has become the archetype for the modern dual-threat quarterback.
Patrick Mahomes is right there too, even if he didn't have the "flashiest" opening stat line with 258 yards. He’s the standard. You don't drop Mahomes because of one game. He still creates out of structure better than anyone on the planet.
💡 You might also like: Jake Ehlinger Sign: The Real Story Behind the College GameDay Controversy
Lamar Jackson is the third wheel in this elite tricycle. He looked incredible against Buffalo, completing over 73% of his passes while racking up 70 yards on the ground. He’s basically the linchpin of the league's most prolific offense. If you’re looking at these three, you aren't overthinking it—you're just glad they're on your team.
The Rise of the Young Guns
Jayden Daniels is making a lot of people look smart right now. The Commanders quarterback stepped into Year 2 and looked like a seasoned vet, putting up 233 yards passing and nearly 70 yards rushing. He’s cracking the top 10 in most major rankings because he provides that rushing floor that fantasy managers crave.
Then there’s Drake Maye. The Patriots are actually letting him air it out—46 attempts in a single game! While the yardage wasn't earth-shattering in the rain, the volume is what matters for his trajectory.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With Nick Chubb: The Injury, The Recovery, and The Houston Twist
Mid-Tier Muddle and Streaming Options
This is where things get kinda messy. You have guys like Dak Prescott and Jalen Hurts who are hovering around that 8-12 range. Dak didn't throw a touchdown in his opener against Philly, but his historical dominance over the New York Giants makes him a massive bounce-back candidate for Week 2. He’s averaged 22 fantasy points per game against them in his career. That's a "lock him in" scenario if I've ever seen one.
- Justin Herbert: He lit up the Chiefs for 318 yards and three scores. He looks healthy, and more importantly, he’s actually scrambling again.
- Matthew Stafford: The veteran is leading an offense that scored 30.5 points per game last year. He had 245 yards and a touchdown in Week 1 and remains one of the most stable "high floor" options available.
- Kyler Murray: He gets the Panthers this week. Carolina allowed a league-high 35 passing touchdowns last season. If Murray is ever going to have a 30-point game, it’s this one.
Baker Mayfield is another name that people are sleeping on. He threw three touchdowns in his opener. People keep waiting for the wheels to fall off the Tampa Bay bus, but Baker just keeps driving it. He’s a legitimate top-12 play against a Texans secondary that showed some cracks.
The Caution Tape: Who to Worry About
I’m genuinely concerned about the "system" guys who didn't look comfortable. Brock Purdy had two interceptions in his first outing. While he’s usually the king of efficiency, the 49ers' offense looked a bit out of sync. He’s still a starter, but maybe not the "set it and forget it" elite option we thought he was.
👉 See also: Men's Sophie Cunningham Jersey: Why This Specific Kit is Selling Out Everywhere
Bo Nix and Joe Flacco are also in the "wait and see" category. Nix had a rough outing with two picks and a fumble. The talent is there, but the processing speed needs to catch up to the NFL game. Flacco is... well, he's 40 years old. He can still sling it, but the floor is incredibly low if the pass rush gets home.
Matchups That Matter for Week 2
If you're looking for an edge, look at the defenses. The Giants and Panthers are currently the "green light" matchups for quarterbacks. Anyone playing them gets an automatic bump in the rankings.
- Dak Prescott vs. NYG: As mentioned, he owns this team.
- Kyler Murray vs. CAR: The rushing upside combined with a weak secondary is a recipe for a massive week.
- Justin Herbert @ LV: He’s historically been great in Vegas, and the Raiders' pass defense is still finding its identity.
On the flip side, be careful with Joe Burrow against Jacksonville. Burrow only managed 113 yards in his opener. While the Jaguars aren't the '85 Bears, Burrow hasn't shown he’s fully back to his pre-injury form yet.
Making the Final Call
When you're finalizing your roster or looking at qb rankings week 2, don't just chase the points from last week. Chase the volume and the matchup. A guy who threw for 150 yards but had 12 carries is often more valuable than a pocket passer who threw for 250 and nothing else.
Trust the elite talent, but don't be afraid to bench a "big name" if the matchup is atrocious. Football is a weekly game, and the rankings should reflect that.
Actionable Strategy for Your Roster
- Check the Weather: Several Week 2 games are in outdoor stadiums where wind could be a factor.
- Monitor Injury Reports: Pay close attention to the offensive line health for teams like the Bengals and Jets; a missing left tackle can ruin a QB's day faster than a bad receiver.
- Value the Scramble: Prioritize quarterbacks who can give you 30-40 yards on the ground to insulate their scoring floor if the passing game stalls.