Writing on a desk shouldn't be romantic. Honestly, in most schools, it’s just a fast track to detention or a lecture from the janitor about property damage. But for anyone who grew up reading Kasie West, specifically her 2015 hit P.S. I Like You, that messy ink on a wooden surface became the ultimate symbol of "will-they-won't-they" tension. It’s a trope that feels a bit vintage now—anonymous pen pals in a world of DMs—yet it works.
Lily Abbott is a weirdo. She knows it. We know it. She’s the girl who wears mismatched clothes and hides her song lyrics in her notebook because she’s terrified of what people might think. One day, bored in chemistry class, she scribbles a lyric on her desk. The next day, someone has written the next line.
👉 See also: Why There’s No Crying in Baseball Became the Most Misunderstood Quote in Sports
That’s how it starts. No apps. No swipes. Just pen on wood.
The Chemistry of the Anonymous Pen Pal
The core hook of P.S. I Like You is the anonymity. It’s basically the literary version of You’ve Got Mail, but set in a high school where the stakes feel world-ending. Lily starts exchanging letters with this mystery person, tucked into the crevice of a desk. They talk about everything—music, family drama, the crushing weight of being a teenager who doesn't quite fit in.
Lily starts falling for the person in the letters. Hard. But in the real world, she’s busy clashing with Cade Jenkins. He’s the arrogant, wealthy guy who seems to exist purely to annoy her.
If you’ve read more than two romance novels in your life, you know exactly where this is going. But knowing the destination doesn’t make the drive any less fun. Kasie West is a master of the "clean" YA romance, a genre that often gets dismissed as fluff but actually requires a lot of technical skill to keep the tension high without relying on explicit scenes.
Why the "Hate to Love" Trope Works Here
Cade isn't just a jerk for the sake of being a jerk. West gives him layers. Lily sees him as this privileged jock, but as the letters reveal the mystery writer’s soul, the reader starts to see the cracks in Cade’s armor before Lily does. It’s dramatic irony at its finest. You’re screaming at the book, "Lily, look at him!" while she’s still convinced he’s the villain of her story.
The contrast is what makes the book stick. The letters are vulnerable. The face-to-face interactions are snarky. It shows how much we hide behind our public personas. Lily uses her "indie" identity as a shield just as much as Cade uses his confidence as a weapon.
👉 See also: Why Give Me Jesus by Fernando Ortega Still Hits Different After 25 Years
Beyond the Romance: Lily’s Chaotic Family
Most YA books treat parents like ghosts. They either don’t exist or they’re just there to say "no" to a party. In P.S. I Like You, the Abbott family is a living, breathing, loud entity. Lily’s house is a disaster zone of siblings and noise.
Her parents are actually present. They’re struggling with money, which is a detail often skipped in glossy teen stories. Lily’s desire to win a songwriting contest isn’t just about "following her dreams"—it’s about the very real need for a new guitar she can’t afford.
This groundedness is why people still recommend this book years after its release. It’s not just about a cute boy. It’s about the anxiety of being poor in a school where everyone else seems to have it easy. It’s about the fear that your creative output isn't actually good. It’s about the weird, specific bond of siblings who drive you crazy but are the only ones who truly get you.
The Power of Music and Lyrics
Music is the third main character in this book. Lily’s obsession with indie bands and her own songwriting serves as the bridge between her and her anonymous pen pal.
- It provides a shared language.
- It allows for vulnerability.
- It sets the "vibes" for the entire narrative.
West uses music to signal who Lily is. She isn’t just "the girl who likes music"; she’s the girl who finds her identity in the lyrics of others because she hasn't found her own voice yet. When she finally starts sharing her own lyrics in the letters, it’s a massive step in her character arc.
The "Clean" YA Market and Kasie West’s Influence
We should talk about the "clean" romance label for a second. For a long time, there was this weird gap in the market. You had middle-grade books that were too young, and then you had "New Adult" books that were essentially erotica. P.S. I Like You sits perfectly in that sweet spot.
🔗 Read more: Who Voiced Beavis and Butt-Head: The Surprising Reality Behind Those Iconic Grunts
It’s romantic and swoon-worthy without being graphic. This made it a staple in school libraries and a favorite for parents who were cautious about what their kids were reading. But even for adult readers, there’s something nostalgic and refreshing about a story that focuses purely on emotional intimacy and the tension of a first crush.
West became a titan of this genre because she understood that you don’t need a high body count or explicit scenes to create stakes. The stake is: What if the person who knows my soul is the person I hate most? That’s enough to keep a fifteen-year-old—or a thirty-year-old—turning pages until 2:00 AM.
Addressing the Critics: Is it Too Predictable?
Some people complain that the book is predictable. Well, yeah. It’s a contemporary romance. If they didn’t end up together, readers would throw the book across the room. The goal of a book like this isn't to shock you with a "Sixth Sense" level twist. The goal is the journey.
The "predictability" is actually part of the comfort. In 2026, where the world feels increasingly chaotic, there is immense value in a story where you know the two leads will eventually figure it out. It’s literary soul food.
However, the book does subvert some expectations. Lily isn't always likable. She can be judgmental and stubborn. Cade isn't just a "golden boy" with a secret heart of gold; he has to actually earn his redemption by acknowledging how his behavior affected Lily.
Actionable Takeaways for Readers and Aspiring Writers
If you’re picking up P.S. I Like You for the first time, or if you’re trying to write something similar, keep these points in mind. They are the "secret sauce" that makes this specific story work.
For Readers:
- Look for the subtext in the letters. The way the mystery writer describes their family and their fears mirrors Cade’s life in ways that are subtle on a first read but glaringly obvious on a second.
- Pay attention to the songwriting subplot. It’s not just a hobby; it’s Lily’s primary method of processing trauma and stress.
- Appreciate the side characters. Lily’s best friend Isabel and her brother are more than just plot devices; they provide the necessary friction to keep Lily from staying in her shell.
For Writers:
- Vary your communication methods. Writing letters or texts allows characters to say things they would never say out loud. It’s a great way to show a character's "internal" vs. "external" self.
- Ground your romance in reality. Give your characters financial problems, annoying siblings, or school stress. It makes the romance feel earned rather than existing in a vacuum.
- Don't fear the trope. Enemies-to-lovers is popular for a reason. The key is to make the "hate" believable and the "love" gradual.
P.S. I Like You remains a high-water mark for the contemporary YA genre. It captures that specific, agonizing, wonderful moment in life where a simple note can change everything. Whether you're 14 or 40, the feeling of waiting for a reply is universal. That’s why we keep coming back to the desk in chemistry class.
The best way to experience this story is to go in expecting a light read and realizing halfway through that you’re actually deeply invested in Lily’s weird family and Cade’s hidden vulnerability. It’s a reminder that sometimes, the person we think we know the least is the one who understands us best.