If you were watching TV in 2009, you probably remember the drama. No, not the kind between designers over a missing pair of fabric shears, but the actual, high-stakes legal drama that almost killed the show. Project Runway Season 6 wasn't just another cycle of sewing and snark; it was a total geographical and structural shift that changed the DNA of the franchise forever. It’s the season that moved to Los Angeles, got trapped in a legal freezer for a year, and introduced us to some of the most polarizing talent the workroom has ever seen.
Most fans look back at this era with a bit of confusion. Why did it look different? Why did the energy feel so... off?
Honestly, the "vibe shift" was real. After five seasons of New York grit, the move to the West Coast felt like a sunny, slightly surreal fever dream. Lifetime had just snatched the show away from Bravo, resulting in a massive lawsuit between NBCUniversal and The Weinstein Company. For months, the finished footage just sat on a shelf. By the time it actually aired, the fashion world had already moved on, yet we were watching designers scramble to create "red carpet" looks in a city that felt miles away from the garment district we knew.
The LA Experiment and the Lifetime Leap
Moving a show like this is risky. New York is the undisputed heart of American fashion, and the Parsons workroom was practically a character itself. When Project Runway Season 6 landed at the Fashion Institute of Design & Merchandising (FIDM) in Los Angeles, the scale changed. The light was different. The challenges felt more "Hollywood."
You had designers like Irina Shabayeva, who eventually took the win, navigating a landscape that felt more focused on celebrity than craft. Irina was a powerhouse, though. People called her "Me-rina" because she stayed focused on her own path, often to the annoyance of her peers. She wasn't there to make friends; she was there to build a brand. Her dominance was undeniable, but the season lacked that "found family" feel we got in earlier years. It was colder.
✨ Don't miss: Why October London Make Me Wanna Is the Soul Revival We Actually Needed
The guest judges that year really leaned into the LA theme. We saw Lindsay Lohan, Christina Aguilera, and Eva Longoria. It was peak late-2000s celebrity culture. Looking back, it’s a time capsule of a specific aesthetic—lots of draped jersey, heavy metallic accents, and that "boho-chic" hangover that refused to die.
The Designers Who Actually Defined the Season
Let’s talk about Althea Harper and Carol Hannah Whitfield. Along with Irina, they formed the first-ever all-female finale trio. That was a huge deal. It broke the streak of male-dominated wins and showed a shift in how the judges viewed commercial viability.
- Irina Shabayeva: Her technical skill was lightyears ahead. Her final collection at Bryant Park (which, weirdly, was still in NYC despite the season being in LA) featured those massive, intricate knits and structured coats. It felt expensive.
- Althea Harper: She was the queen of wearable, cool-girl clothes. She understood the "Lifetime" viewer probably better than anyone else.
- Christopher Straub: He was the heart of the season. A self-taught designer from Minnesota who made things out of petals and sheer imagination. He didn't win, but he proved that the show still had room for raw, unpolished talent.
Then there was Nicolas Putvinski. He was theatrical. He was dramatic. He gave the editors exactly what they wanted, even if his designs occasionally veered into the "costume" territory that Nina Garcia famously hates. And speaking of Nina, her absence for part of the season (replaced by Marie Claire’s Zoe Glassner) made the judging panels feel a bit lightweight. We missed that specific brand of Nina-terror.
Why the "Move to Lifetime" Nearly Ruined the Momentum
The transition from Bravo to Lifetime was messy. Like, "lawyers in every room" messy. Because of the legal battles, the season was delayed for nearly a year. In the fashion industry, a year is an eternity. Trends change. Silhouettes evolve. By the time the audience saw the "innovative" designs of Project Runway Season 6, some of them already looked a bit dated.
🔗 Read more: How to Watch The Wolf and the Lion Without Getting Lost in the Wild
Also, the production felt different. The editing became more focused on the "reality" tropes—tears, snarky confessionals, and manufactured tension—rather than the grueling 18-hour workdays. Fans noticed. The show lost a bit of its prestige sheen, trading it for a more standard cable reality TV gloss. It was the price of survival, but it changed the show's legacy.
Critical Misconceptions About the Season 6 Finale
One thing people always get wrong is where the finale happened. Even though the season was filmed in Los Angeles, the final runway show was still held during New York Fashion Week at the tents in Bryant Park. This created a strange disconnect. The designers spent weeks soaking up the California sun and LA inspiration, only to be thrust back into the frantic New York energy for their career-defining moment.
Irina’s win is often debated by those who preferred Althea’s modern edge or Carol Hannah’s whimsical silhouettes. But if you look at the construction, Irina was the only choice. Her "Aspen" inspired collection was cohesive and professionally executed in a way that the others just couldn't match. She understood that Project Runway isn't just a sewing competition; it's a test of who can manage a production line under pressure.
The Real Impact of Season 6
What did we actually learn from this year?
💡 You might also like: Is Lincoln Lawyer Coming Back? Mickey Haller's Next Move Explained
- Geography matters: The energy of the city dictates the energy of the clothes. LA produced more "red carpet" and "resort" wear, while NY produced "street" and "editorial."
- The "All-Female" Finale was a turning point: It proved the show could move past the "diva" tropes and focus on female entrepreneurs.
- Tim Gunn is the glue: No matter where you put him—a penthouse in Manhattan or a campus in downtown LA—Tim’s mentorship stayed the gold standard. His "Make it Work" became the only thing that felt consistent during the network transition.
How to Revisit the Season 6 Aesthetic Today
If you're a designer or a fan looking back at this era, don't just dismiss the clothes as "so 2009." There are lessons in the layering and the use of unconventional materials that still apply.
- Analyze the construction of Irina’s knits. She used volume in a way that predicted the oversized trend we've seen in the 2020s.
- Study the "Red Carpet" challenge. It shows the transition from the "glamazon" 90s look to the more accessible celebrity style of the early 2010s.
- Watch the interactions between the designers. This season was a masterclass in "workplace politics." How do you stay creative when the person next to you is actively rooting for your failure?
Project Runway Season 6 was a bridge. It bridged the gap between the scrappy, cult-favorite Bravo years and the massive, commercial powerhouse the show became on Lifetime. It wasn't perfect. It was often awkward. But it was essential for the show's survival.
To truly understand where the series is now, you have to look at the time it almost fell apart in the California sun. If you want to dive deeper into the technical side, go back and watch the "Lights, Camera, Action" episode. It captures the exact moment the show realized it wasn't just about clothes anymore—it was about the spectacle.
Take a look at the current portfolios of the Season 6 alumni. Many of them, like Althea Harper, went on to have incredibly successful commercial careers, proving that the "Lifetime era" was actually great at identifying designers who could actually sell clothes to real people, not just fashion editors.
Next Steps for Fashion Enthusiasts
- Compare and Contrast: Watch a Season 6 episode followed by a Season 19 episode. Notice how the "workroom walk-through" by the mentor has evolved from simple critiques to deep psychological coaching.
- Portfolio Review: Look up Irina Shabayeva’s recent couture collections. See how her signature "warrior woman" aesthetic from Season 6 has matured into high-end bridal and evening wear.
- Technical Challenge: Try the "Newspaper Challenge" yourself using modern materials. It’s still the best way to understand structural integrity in garment design without the safety net of expensive fabric.