Jason Priestley will always be Brandon Walsh to a certain generation. That’s just a fact. You can’t escape the sideburns, the moral compass, or the Peach Pit. But honestly? If you haven't watched Private Eyes Jason Priestley, you’re missing the version of the actor that actually feels comfortable in his own skin. He plays Matt Shade, a former hockey player turned detective. It’s light. It’s breezy. It’s exactly what TV used to be before everything became a dark, gritty reboot of a 1940s comic book.
Television in the late 2010s was obsessed with prestige. Every show wanted to be the next Breaking Ball or Succession. Then came this Canadian gem. It didn't try to change the world. It just wanted to give you a good hour of mystery with some great chemistry between Priestley and his co-star, Cindy Sampson.
The Matt Shade Pivot
Matt Shade isn't Brandon Walsh. Thank god.
Shade is a guy who reached the pinnacle of pro sports and then hit the wall. Hard. When we first meet him in the pilot, he’s a scout. He’s a dad. He’s kind of a mess, but a charming one. Priestley brings a level of self-deprecation to the role that he never really got to show on Beverly Hills, 90210. You can tell he’s having fun. It’s that "knowing wink" to the audience. He knows he’s the "TV guy," and he leans into it.
The show is based on the novel The Code by G.B. Joyce. If you read the book, the vibe is a bit different, but the core remains: a guy who knows how to read people on the ice trying to read them in the real world. Shade teams up with Angie Everett, a professional P.I. who has zero patience for his "ex-pro athlete" ego.
It works.
✨ Don't miss: But What If We're Wrong: What Most People Get Wrong About the Future of Now
They have that classic "will-they-won't-they" energy. It’s old school. Think Moonlighting or Remington Steele. In a world of complex anti-heroes, sometimes you just want to see two attractive people solve a crime in Toronto while bickering about who gets to drive the Porsche.
Toronto as the Third Lead
Most shows filmed in Canada try to pretend they’re in New York or Chicago. They hide the CN Tower. They swap out the mailboxes. Private Eyes Jason Priestley doesn't do that. It loves Toronto. It’s a love letter to the city.
You see the Distillery District. You see the skyline. You see the actual culture of the city, from the hockey obsession to the diverse neighborhoods. It feels authentic. Global audiences took notice, too. The show became a massive hit in the UK on Sky and in Italy. Why? Because it felt like a vacation.
I remember talking to a producer once who said that the "Blue Sky" era of USA Network—shows like Burn Notice or White Collar—died out too soon. People miss those. This show filled that void perfectly. It’s sunny even when it’s raining.
The Dynamics of the Everett/Shade Partnership
Angie Everett is the brains. Shade is the... well, he’s the guy who knows people.
Cindy Sampson is a force. If she hadn't been able to go toe-to-toe with Priestley’s established star power, the show would have folded in six episodes. Instead, she often outshines him. She’s the professional. He’s the interloper. This power dynamic keeps the show from feeling like a vanity project for a former teen idol.
- Shade brings the intuition of an athlete.
- Everett brings the cold, hard procedural facts.
- The supporting cast, like Barry Flatman as Shade’s dad, adds a layer of family drama that actually feels earned.
The family stuff isn't just filler. Shade’s relationship with his daughter, Jules, who is visually impaired, is handled with a lot of grace. It gives the character stakes. He’s not just solving crimes for the thrill; he’s trying to be a better man for her. It’s wholesome without being cheesy. Mostly.
Why It Ended and Where It Stands Now
Five seasons. That’s a solid run for any show these days. When Global and ION Television announced the end, fans were devastated. But honestly? Five seasons is the sweet spot. You have enough episodes for a great syndication package, but you don't stay long enough to become a parody of yourself.
The series finale wrapped things up nicely. It didn't leave us on a cliffhanger that would haunt our dreams. It gave the characters the growth they deserved. Shade went from a guy clinging to his glory days to a man who found a new calling.
If you’re looking to binge something that won't give you an existential crisis, this is it.
What to Watch Next if You Miss Shade and Everett
If you’ve already blazed through all 60 episodes, you might be feeling a bit of a void. Don't worry. The genre of "Lighthearted P.I. Procedural" is making a comeback.
- Wild Cards: Another Canadian production that feels very much in the spirit of Private Eyes. It features a con artist and a demoted detective. Same DNA.
- Carter: Starring Jerry O'Connell. It’s a bit more meta—about an actor who played a detective who then becomes a detective—but the vibe is identical.
- The Spencer Confidential movies on Netflix: They have a bit more grit, but the "unlikely duo" trope is strong.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Viewer
Don't go into this expecting The Wire. That’s the biggest mistake people make. Go into it for the chemistry.
- Start with Season 1, Episode 1: The pilot sets the tone perfectly. It doesn't take long to find its footing.
- Pay attention to the cameos: Being a Jason Priestley show, a lot of famous Canadian faces pop up. It’s a "who’s who" of Canadian entertainment.
- Watch the background: If you’ve ever been to Toronto, identifying the filming locations is half the fun.
The legacy of Private Eyes Jason Priestley isn't that it changed the face of television. It’s that it proved there is still a massive market for "comfort TV." You can have a show about murder and kidnapping that still makes you feel good at the end of the hour. That’s a rare skill in writing.
To get the most out of your rewatch, look for the subtle ways the writers integrated Matt Shade’s hockey background into his detective work. It’s not just a gimmick; it’s a character study on how transferable skills work in the real world. Whether it’s anticipating a "play" before it happens or understanding the pressure of a "clutch" moment, those small details are what make Shade feel like a real person rather than a TV trope.
💡 You might also like: Why the Dinner at Eight Cast Is Still the Most Chaotic Ensemble in Hollywood History
Check your local streaming listings—usually Prime Video or ION—to find where it’s currently playing in your region. It’s the perfect "weekend afternoon" show.