You know that feeling when you open a storage bin and find that one specific box that makes your heart skip? For a lot of us, it’s the Pottery Barn 12 days of Christmas ornaments. These aren't just pieces of painted glass or resin. They've become a sort of holiday shorthand for "I’ve officially made it as a festive adult."
Honestly, the obsession makes sense. Most people start looking for these sets in late October because they sell out faster than a latte on a cold Monday morning. They are nostalgic. They are sturdy. And let’s be real—they look expensive on a Douglas Fir.
The "12 Days of Christmas" is an old English carol, but Pottery Barn managed to turn it into a collectible phenomenon. You’ve probably seen the different versions over the years. Some are classic silver, others are colorful and whimsical, and some look like they were plucked straight from a Victorian parlor. But why do people lose their minds over them? It’s not just the branding. It’s the fact that they represent a complete narrative for your tree. You aren't just hanging "stuff"; you're telling a story from partridge to drummers.
The Design Evolution of Pottery Barn 12 Days of Christmas Ornaments
If you look back at the archives, the design hasn't stayed static. Pottery Barn is smart. They know that home decor trends shift from "farmhouse chic" to "maximalist color" every few seasons.
About a decade ago, the sets were heavily focused on a silver-plated aesthetic. These were heavy. They felt substantial in your hand. They had that classic, slightly shiny look that reflected the tree lights perfectly. Then, they moved into the more artisanal, hand-painted territory. We started seeing the "sculptural" sets where each figure—the three French hens, the six geese a-laying—had its own distinct personality and texture.
One of the most popular iterations in recent years has been the "sentiment" or "banner" style. Instead of just a bird or a person, the ornament often includes a small metallic tag or a scrolled banner with the number and the lyric. It’s a design choice that adds a bit of "jewelry" to the tree branches.
People often get confused between the different releases. You'll find the "nostalgic" series, which uses a lot of muted reds and greens, sitting right next to the "glitter" series on eBay. Because that’s the thing—these items have a massive secondary market. Once Pottery Barn retires a specific design of the Pottery Barn 12 days of Christmas ornaments, the prices on resale sites like Poshmark or Mercari tend to skyrocket. It’s basically the Beanie Babies of the Christmas world, but actually tasteful.
What Makes These Different From Generic Sets?
You can go to a big-box store and buy a 12-day set for twenty bucks. So why spend significantly more at Pottery Barn?
👉 See also: Sport watch water resist explained: why 50 meters doesn't mean you can dive
Quality is the short answer.
If you’ve ever dropped a cheap plastic ornament, it either shatters into a million sharp shards or the "gold" paint flakes off immediately. Pottery Barn usually uses materials like zinc alloy, blown glass, or high-density resin. They have weight. When you hang the "Seven Swans a-Swimming," it doesn't just dangle limp; it has presence.
Also, the scale is intentional. They are sized to be seen. A lot of cheaper sets are tiny, maybe two inches tall, and they get lost in the needles. The Pottery Barn versions are typically three to five inches, making them the "anchor" pieces of a tree design.
How to Style Your Tree with the Full Set
Let’s talk strategy. You have twelve ornaments. How do you hang them without making the tree look lopsided or chaotic?
Some people prefer the "Chronological Spiral." You start with the Partridge at the very top, just under the star, and you work your way down in a winding circle until the 12 Drummers are at the bottom. It’s a literal interpretation of the song. It works if you have a very symmetrical tree.
Others—and this is probably the more modern way—treat them as "surprises" tucked into the greenery. You mix them with standard glass balls and tinsel. It makes the tree an interactive experience. Your kids or guests have to "find" the Five Golden Rings. It’s basically a scavenger hunt with eggnog.
Pro-Tip for Longevity
Storage is where people mess up. These ornaments often come in a custom-fitted box with velvet-lined slots. Do not throw that box away. I know it’s bulky. I know your closet is full. But the moment you toss these into a generic "ornament ball" bin, you risk the delicate parts—like the necks of the geese or the drumsticks of the drummers—snapping off.
✨ Don't miss: Pink White Nail Studio Secrets and Why Your Manicure Isn't Lasting
Also, watch out for the ribbons. Pottery Barn usually uses a high-quality satin or velvet ribbon for hanging. Over time, these can fray if they rub against the rough needles of a real tree. It’s a quick fix to replace them, but if you want to keep the "original" look for resale value, be gentle when packing them up in January.
The Resale Value of Pottery Barn 12 Days of Christmas Ornaments
It’s kind of wild to think of Christmas decor as an investment, but here we are.
If you have a complete set from the early 2010s in the original packaging, you’re looking at a value that often exceeds the original retail price. Collectibles like these thrive on scarcity. Every year, Pottery Barn tweaks the design just enough that you can't easily "replace" a single broken piece from a new set.
If you lose the "Eight Maids a-Milking," you can't just walk into a store three years later and buy just that one. You’re headed to the secondary market. This is why collectors are so protective of their sets.
Common Misconceptions
People often think these ornaments are made of solid silver because of the "PB Classic" finish. They aren't. They are usually silver-plated or finished with a metallic lacquer over a base metal. If you try to polish them with heavy-duty silver cleaner, you might actually strip the finish off. A simple microfiber cloth is usually all you need to get the dust off.
Another myth is that they are "shatterproof." Only the metal versions are truly durable. The blown-glass sets are incredibly fragile. If you have a cat that likes to climb trees or a toddler who thinks everything is a baseball, stick to the metal or resin versions of the Pottery Barn 12 days of Christmas ornaments.
Tracking Down Rare Versions
If you’re a completionist, you’re probably looking for the "special editions."
🔗 Read more: Hairstyles for women over 50 with round faces: What your stylist isn't telling you
Occasionally, Pottery Barn Kids will release a version that is felted or made of wood. These are much more whimsical and "child-friendly." They lack the sophisticated "glam" of the main line, but they have a handmade charm that fits a more rustic or "Boho" holiday theme.
Then there are the "mini" sets. These were designed for tabletop trees. They are incredibly hard to find now and are highly coveted by people who live in apartments or like to have a "second tree" in the bedroom.
The Cultural Impact of the 12 Days Collection
Why this song? Why not "Jingle Bells" or "Deck the Halls"?
There’s something rhythmic and mathematical about the 12 Days of Christmas that appeals to our need for order. It’s a countdown. In a season that feels increasingly fast and frantic, having a set of twelve distinct items feels grounding.
It’s also a very "British" aesthetic that Pottery Barn has successfully exported to the American suburbs. It feels like something out of a Dickens novel, especially the versions that use traditional iconography. It taps into that "Old World" Christmas feeling that many people are trying to recreate in their own living rooms.
Practical Steps for Collectors
If you're looking to start your collection now, don't wait until December.
- Check the Website Early: Pottery Barn usually drops their holiday preview in late September or early October. If you want the current year's design at MSRP, that is your window.
- Inspect Upon Arrival: Shipping glass and metal can be tricky. Check every single ornament for chips or broken loops the second the box arrives.
- Save the Box: As mentioned before, the original box is 50% of the resale value and 90% of the protection.
- Mix and Match: Don't feel like you have to have the "matching" tree. These ornaments look great when paired with natural elements like dried oranges, pinecones, and simple white lights.
Buying a set of Pottery Barn 12 days of Christmas ornaments is a bit of a commitment. It's an investment in your "holiday brand." But unlike a lot of trendy decor that feels dated after one season, these have a staying power that lasts decades. They are the kind of thing you eventually pass down to your kids, along with the story of how you spent way too much time hunting down the perfect tree to put them on.
To keep your collection in top shape, store the box in a temperature-controlled area—avoiding the extreme heat of an attic which can cause certain glues or finishes to degrade over time. If you find a set at a thrift store or estate sale that's missing a piece, don't pass it up; individual ornaments often sell for $15-$30 on their own to collectors looking to complete their broken sets. Keep an eye on local marketplace apps in the "off-season" like July, where you can often snag these for a fraction of the holiday price.