You’re standing in the tall grass outside Cherrygrove City. It’s 2010. Or maybe it's 2026 and you’ve just dusted off a pink-tinted DS Lite because you realized modern games don't have that same crunch. You want a Vulpix. You’ve been running in circles for twenty minutes, but all you see are Growlithe. That’s the sting of version exclusives. It’s a mechanic designed to force you to talk to people, but mostly, it just makes you realize you picked the wrong version for your favorite team. Pokémon SoulSilver exclusive Pokémon aren't just a list of sprites; they represent a specific vibe that differentiates the game from HeartGold, leaning heavily into graceful, avian, and somewhat "mystical" designs compared to the aggressive, fiery roster of its counterpart.
Picking SoulSilver means you’re signing up for a specific endgame. You're getting Lugia at level 45, right there in the Whirl Islands, while HeartGold players have to wait until the literal end of the game to see the Great Silver Wing. Honestly, the choice between these games usually boils down to whether you prefer a legendary bird that can take a hit or a legendary dog-thing that breathes fire. But for the casual player just trying to beat Whitney’s Miltank, the real impact is felt in the early-game encounters.
The Johto Exclusives You Can't Ignore
If you're playing SoulSilver, you have access to the Vulpix line. This is a big deal. While HeartGold gets Growlithe—a physical attacker that’s basically a police dog—SoulSilver gives you Ninetales. Ninetales is faster, more about status moves, and frankly, looks cooler trailing behind you in the overworld. But it’s a trade-off. You lose out on the raw power of Arcanine. You also get the Meowth line. This might seem trivial until you realize that Persian with the Technician ability and Fake Out can actually put in work during the mid-game.
Then there’s the Ledyba and Ledian situation. Look, I’ll be real: Ledian is not a good Pokémon. Its base Attack is abysmal. But if you’re a completionist, you’re stuck with the ladybug while your friend with HeartGold is using Spinarak. It’s these small differences that shape your Pokédex. The version exclusivity in the Johto region was always a bit more "balanced" than the Kanto games, where one version clearly had the better competitive edge. Here, it’s about aesthetic.
🔗 Read more: Lust Academy Season 1: Why This Visual Novel Actually Works
Delibird and Skarmory are the late-game fliers that define the SoulSilver experience. Skarmory is a literal tank. It’s a Steel/Flying type that laughs at physical attackers. If you're heading toward the Elite Four and need a defensive backbone, Skarmory is the reason people pick SoulSilver. In HeartGold, you get Mantine. Mantine is fine, but it’s a Special Defense wall in a game where most of the heavy hitters you’ll face in the Johto endgame are physical. Skarmory is objectively the more useful encounter for a standard playthrough.
Don't Forget the Kanto and Hoenn Refugees
Most people forget that the Pokémon SoulSilver exclusive Pokémon list extends far beyond the Johto dex. Once you unlock the National Pokédex or start messing with the Pokéwalker (if you still have one that works), the list expands. You get Mawile. You get Gulpin. You get the legendary heavyweights.
Kyogre is the massive standout here. In the post-game of SoulSilver, after you’ve beaten Red and obtained a Kanto starter from Oak, you can head to the Embedded Tower. If you’re playing SoulSilver, Kyogre appears. This is huge because Kyogre has historically been one of the most dominant forces in the entire franchise due to the Drizzle ability. HeartGold players get Groudon. While Groudon is cool, Kyogre fits the "Silver" theme of water and storms perfectly. To even get Rayquaza, you need both, which means you’re going to have to find someone to trade with anyway.
💡 You might also like: OG John Wick Skin: Why Everyone Still Calls The Reaper by the Wrong Name
Teddiursa and Ursaring are also locked into the SoulSilver cartridge. Ursaring is a beast. If you catch one with the Guts ability and give it a Flame Orb (though that's a bit of a grind to get), it can OHKO almost anything in the Kanto post-game. It’s the "brawn" of the SoulSilver exclusives, contrasting with the more "elegant" Ninetales or Misdreavus.
Speaking of Misdreavus, it’s the only pure Ghost-type from the Johto era, and it’s a SoulSilver exclusive. In a game where Gengar requires a trade to evolve, having access to Mismagius (via a Dusk Stone) gives SoulSilver players a legitimate special attacking ghost without needing a link cable or a second DS. It’s a massive quality-of-life advantage that HeartGold just doesn't replicate with its exclusive, Murkrow.
The Deep Cut: Safari Zone and Swarms
The Safari Zone in HeartGold and SoulSilver is a convoluted mess of blocks and waiting periods. However, it’s also where some version exclusives hide. While most of the "core" exclusives are found in the wild, certain Swarm Pokémon also respect the version divide.
📖 Related: Finding Every Bubbul Gem: Why the Map of Caves TOTK Actually Matters
- Phanpy and Donphan: These are found on Route 45 in SoulSilver. Donphan is an incredible Rapid Spinner and physical wall. In HeartGold, you get Teddiursa in this slot. This is one of those rare cases where SoulSilver gets the "tougher" looking Pokémon while HeartGold gets the "cute" one.
- Shellder and Cloyster: You'll find these via fishing in SoulSilver. Cloyster with Skill Link and Icicle Spear is a legendary-slayer. HeartGold gets Staryu and Starmie. This is a tough choice—Starmie is arguably one of the best Pokémon in the series—but Cloyster offers a unique niche that makes the SoulSilver endgame feel different.
The "vibe" of SoulSilver is consistently more defensive and tactical. You have Skarmory, Cloyster, and Lugia. These are Pokémon that outlast the opponent. HeartGold is the "glass cannon" version with Arcanine, Primeape, and Ho-Oh. It changes how you approach the Kanto gyms. In SoulSilver, you're playing a game of attrition. You're soaking up hits and waiting for the right moment to strike.
Final Verdict on the Silver Roster
If you are looking to build a team that relies on synergy and defense, the Pokémon SoulSilver exclusive Pokémon are far superior. You get the better legendary (Lugia’s Multiscale ability, if you're playing the virtual console or modern ports, is broken, though in the original DS version it's just a massive wall), the better defensive bird in Skarmory, and the better weather setter in Kyogre.
The exclusion of Growlithe and Mankey hurts early on, but you can easily fill those gaps with a Heracross or a Magmar from the Burned Tower. SoulSilver feels like the "complete" experience because Lugia’s lore is so deeply tied to the Whirl Islands, which feel more like a real dungeon than the straightforward path to Ho-Oh.
Actionable Next Steps for SoulSilver Players:
- Prioritize Skarmory: Head to Route 45 as soon as you can. It’s a rare encounter, but it will carry your team through the physical-heavy Kanto gyms later on.
- Hunt for Misdreavus: Don't settle for Gastly if you can't trade. Misdreavus is found in the Cliff Cave or Mt. Silver at night. It’s a fantastic special attacker once evolved.
- Prepare for Kyogre: Ensure you have a heavy lead-type Pokémon with False Swipe before heading to the Embedded Tower in the post-game. Kyogre’s Aqua Ring makes it a nightmare to catch if you don't have a way to negate its healing.
- Use the Pokéwalker: If you have the hardware, use it to find early-game items like the Moon Stone to evolve your Ninetales or Nidoking/queen earlier than the game normally allows.
The version divide isn't about which game is "better," but about which tools you want in your shed. SoulSilver gives you the shield; HeartGold gives you the sword. Choose accordingly.