Grinding Gear Games has a habit of making us wait. We've been looking at Path of Exile 2 trailers for what feels like an eternity, dissecting every frame of Druid gameplay and wondering if the gold economy will actually work. But there is one specific ghost haunting the sequel's development: the Trial of the Ancestors. When it first dropped in PoE 1, it was divisive. People either spent three weeks straight in the Halls of the Dead or they ignored it entirely because they couldn't stand the "autochest" mechanics. Now, with the PoE 2 early access window finally becoming a reality, the conversation has shifted. We aren't just asking if it’s coming back. We're asking how much better it’s going to be with a physics engine that actually functions.
Trial of the Ancestors was basically a sports management sim tucked inside a dark fantasy ARPG. It was weird. You weren't just clicking monsters until they exploded into loot; you were managing a team of Karui warriors, positioning flankers, and trying to banish enemy totems while avoiding a one-shot from an off-screen Titanic Shell. It felt like a different game. That is exactly why it fits the PoE 2 philosophy so well.
The Mechanical Shift in PoE 2 Trial of the Ancestors
PoE 2 is slower. Not "bad" slow, but intentional. You can’t just hold down one button and clear three screens of mobs while watching Netflix on your second monitor anymore. Everything in the sequel is built around "The Couch Co-op Experience" and tactical combat. This is where a potential PoE 2 Trial of the Ancestors becomes terrifyingly addictive. In the first game, the power creep eventually broke the trial. You’d get to a point where your character was so fast that the tactical element of the Karui tournament just dissolved into a mess of visual clutter.
Imagine that same tournament but with the new PoE 2 reactive combat.
The dodge roll changes everything. In the original league, if a Tuatara jumped on you, you usually just died if your resistances weren't capped or your evasion failed a hidden roll. In PoE 2, you have a dedicated dodge. This turns the Trial from a stat check into a skill check. You’re not just hoping your flankers do their job; you’re actively baiting the enemy chieftain's slams, rolling through a projectile, and then punishing them with a freeze.
Jonathan Rogers, the Game Director, has been vocal about wanting every encounter to feel earned. If they bring the Ancestors back—and the community demand suggests they'd be crazy not to—it won't be the same spam-fest. It’ll be a high-stakes tactical brawler.
📖 Related: Is the PlayStation 5 Slim Console Digital Edition Actually Worth It?
Why the Karui Lore Matters Now
The Karui are the backbone of Path of Exile’s flavor. In PoE 1, we saw them as slaves, then as rebels, and finally as spirits in the afterlife. But PoE 2 is set years after the death of the Kitava, and the world is different. The "Ancestors" aren't just names on a passive tree anymore. They are the foundation of the new world's religion and conflict.
When you step into the Halls of the Dead in a PoE 2 context, you’re looking at characters like Hinekora or Tawhoa not as distant myths, but as active participants in a world that is still recovering from the collapse of the Templar authority. The storytelling depth in the sequel is significantly higher. We’ve seen this in the boss designs already revealed, like the Executioner or the Devourer. They have personality. If we get a revamped Trial of the Ancestors, the chieftains like Kaom or Utula won't just be static NPCs with a few voice lines. They'll be bosses with phases, mechanics, and actual AI.
The Loot Problem and the Tattoo Solution
Let’s be real: people played Trial of the Ancestors for the Tattoos.
The ability to swap out useless +10 Strength nodes for something actually good, like projectile speed or maximum fire resistance, was a godsend for build diversity. It solved the "dead node" problem on the passive tree. In Path of Exile 2, the passive tree is already getting a massive overhaul. We have the dual-specialization system now, where you can swap weapons and have your passives swap with them.
Tattoos in a PoE 2 Trial of the Ancestors would be insane.
👉 See also: How to Solve 6x6 Rubik's Cube Without Losing Your Mind
Think about the complexity. If you're running a Mercenary with a crossbow, you might want specific tattoos that trigger on-hit effects. But when you swap to your mace for a slam skill, those tattoos might need to provide stun threshold. If GGG integrates the Ancestor rewards into the new dual-spec system, the theory-crafting is going to go off the rails. It’s the kind of depth that keeps people playing for 4,000 hours.
Is it too much for the base game?
Some people hate "out-of-map" content. They want to run their Underground Sea, kill the boss, and leave. To them, the Trial of the Ancestors is a distraction. And they have a point. If you force a player to manage a roster of Karui warriors just to get the best endgame items, you risk alienating the hardcore "zoom-zoom" crowd.
But PoE 2 isn't trying to be PoE 1.5.
It’s trying to be a different beast. The developers have shown they aren't afraid to take risks, like removing Quicksilver Flasks or making mana a more restrictive resource. Including a complex, standalone tactical mode like the Trial fits that "prestige" feel they're going for. It makes the world feel bigger than just a series of corridors filled with loot.
How to Prepare for the Meta Shift
If you’re looking at the PoE 2 early access and wondering how to approach the game if a mechanic like this returns, you need to change your mindset. Forget the "screen-clear" builds for a second.
✨ Don't miss: How Orc Names in Skyrim Actually Work: It's All About the Bloodline
- Focus on Crowd Control: In the Trial, stunning or freezing an enemy is worth more than raw DPS. This is even more true in PoE 2, where the "Stagger" bar on bosses is a core mechanic.
- Learn the New Movement: If you can't dodge roll, you won't survive the new chieftain AI. Practice your timing now.
- Understand the Dual-Spec System: Start thinking about how two different weapon types can complement each other. A "Trial-ready" build will likely need a high-mobility setup for taking totems and a high-defense setup for holding the line.
The Trial of the Ancestors wasn't perfect in its first iteration. It had balance issues, and the AI for your teammates was sometimes as smart as a bag of hammers. But the core idea—a tactical, team-based sports league inside an ARPG—is brilliant. With the engine upgrades, the new physics, and the refined combat of Path of Exile 2, it could go from a "fun distraction" to the best part of the entire game.
Honestly, the prospect of facing off against a PoE 2 version of Kahuturoa is terrifying. His slams already hurt in the old engine. In the new one, with actual debris flying and the ground shattering? Yeah, good luck with that. You're going to need more than just a lucky dodge roll; you're going to need a plan.
What You Should Do Right Now
The best way to get ready for whatever PoE 2 throws at us—whether it's the Ancestors or a brand-new league mechanic—is to dive into the current PoE 1 leagues and pay attention to how GGG is testing things. They often use the final leagues of PoE 1 as a "stealth beta" for PoE 2 mechanics. Watch the way monsters move. Look at the balance of projectile speed versus melee impact.
Keep an eye on the official Path of Exile forums and the GGG developer interviews. Mark Roberts and Jonathan Rogers have been surprisingly candid about what works and what doesn't. If they mention "tactical placement" or "unit AI," you can bet your bottom chaos orb that they are thinking about how to bring the tournament back.
Get your builds ready. The Halls of the Dead are likely coming back, and this time, the stakes are a lot higher than just a few silver coins. You'll be fighting for your spot in a new era of Wraeclast, and the ancestors are going to be watching every single move you make. Be ready to roll.